Filed under: Analysis / Opinion, OS
10.4.2 Review
MacJournals takes a long look at the 10.4.2 update to Tiger, and how, after a while with the update, it delivers or fails to deliver on Apple's Tiger promises. Under the synopsis section, the article notes "Although Mac OS X 10.4.2 takes a big swipe at user-reported problems with the first two Tiger releases, its not perfect. A bug that wipes out URL information in Address Book when using synchronizing and using .Mac data as the master source is not fixed in 10.4.2, for example, nor are several other bugs." Near the very end of this section, the article adds "If youve been waiting to install Tiger until they get 'the first bugs' worked out, its time to put that reasoning aside and update."Read the full article and follow all the links for all the info. If you're one of the few who was able to resist upgrading immediately to Tiger, however, I would advise that you wait until 10.4.3 or 10.4.4. There are still bugs, and if you've waited this long, you're clearly fine with Panther.
![TUAW [Cafepress]](http://www.blogsmithmedia.com/www.tuaw.com/media/tuaw-cafepress-promo.png)
Reader Comments (Page 1 of 1)
Guille said 1:10PM on 8-05-2005
I still have this problem where if I'm connected to any network shares and I lose my network connection (either because I lost the wifi signal or because I mistakenly unplugged the network cable) instead of just unmounting the shares, the whole OS hangs forever and I can't do anything about it except press the power button until it shuts down. Does anyone else have the same problem?
I have a 1.5GHz 15" PowerBook with 1.25GB or RAM, running 10.4.2.
Reply
The Jeremy said 1:58PM on 8-05-2005
My dad would like to upgrade to Tiger, but he's miffed at the fact that Virex (one of the main reasons he signed up for .Mac) does not run on Tiger. That should've been solved prior to the release of Tiger, or Norton Antivirus or something else substituted for free for .Mac subscribers upgrading to Tiger.
Reply
Tony said 2:19PM on 8-05-2005
My WiFi will sometimes just disconnect for no reason, and I don't notice until I get a "page not found" error when I click on a link. This never happened with Panther, even with all the same equipment (router, etc.). It's only a small inconvenience, though, because I just click on the AirPort status icon, and select my network again.
Reply
Scott Gardner said 3:01PM on 8-05-2005
I run Virex 7.2 on Tiger, works fine. Although I saw that Virex defs were updated this week yet my version maintains that July 13th definitions are most up-to-date.
As for Tiger 10.4.2, I have been running fine on my PBG4, with the exception of:
1) a fairly consisten coreaudiod (PID 35) not responding error - no symptoms cited
2) three times I have received a allocation error alert (-694) from TechTool Pro on startup. I restart and it goes away.
Bottom line is, 10.4.2 is not perfect. It never will be. But I do agree it *is* "the world's most (commercially available) advanced operating system"...which, as my zainy father-in-law says, makes it "good enough for who it's for!"
Reply
Mr Yuk said 5:06PM on 8-05-2005
Still on Panther (TiBookDVI) 10.3.9 which is IMO much less stable than 10.3.8. Several kernal panics in the past 4 months verus 2 over a 3 year period. I suspect it's the Quciktime 7 update; which sucks because I upgraded (?) from 6.5Pro.
Bottom line: Tiger.2 may be better than Panther.9 unless I downgrade to 10.3.8.
Reply
Mr Yuk said 5:07PM on 8-05-2005
Still on Panther (TiBookDVI) 10.3.9 which is IMO much less stable than 10.3.8. Several kernal panics in the past 4 months verus 2 over a 3 year period. I suspect it's the Quciktime 7 update; which sucks because I upgraded (?) from 6.5Pro.
Bottom line: Tiger.2 may be better than Panther.9 unless I downgrade to 10.3.8.
Reply
The Jeremy said 4:10PM on 8-05-2005
To Guille, Tony, and Scott:
Did you install Tiger on top of Panther or did you do a clean install from the start?
Reply
rip said 5:14PM on 8-05-2005
I thought I read somewhere that Virex was eol'ed? Which would make sense, since there would have to first be virii to require protection from them.
And Scott, I was having that same problem with coreaudiod. It didn't actually result in any issues, but it was annoying to see it in the activity monitor. I solved it by doing a clean install (I did an archive/install the first time)... super annoying but fixed it.
The vpn/cisco issues are major. They need to fix those before any corporate user is going to adopt.
Reply
Ben said 5:48PM on 8-05-2005
I've been using Tiger since release day, and I've seen no bugs and had no problems with it at all.
You say that you would recommend waiting until 10.4.3 or 10.4.4 to upgrade - madness, Tiger is brilliant already, and was far superior to XP at 10.4.0 and with each release its gotten faster - I haven't used my Windows machine once since reaching 10.4.0
Gotta love the shiny side..
Reply
mapin said 6:05PM on 8-05-2005
no more virex, that's correct. just download ClamXav which is free if you're really worried about storing/passing along windows viruses. and forget .Mac, that service is a waste.
Reply
mapin said 6:08PM on 8-05-2005
oh and Ben (message #9), how much time do you spend on your mac? I find it hard to believe that anyone spending at least a few hours a day has not run into a single Tiger bug. That first release was more buggy then windowsMe for crying out loud ! Finally with 10.4.2, its as stable as 10.3.9 was.
Reply
Guille said 7:13PM on 8-05-2005
The Jeremy, I did a clean install. I'm gonna do a fresh install again this weekend and see if that helps.
Reply
Rodimus Prime said 11:57PM on 8-05-2005
" I still have this problem where if I'm connected to any network shares and I lose my network connection... the whole OS hangs forever and I can't do anything about it except press the power button until it shuts down."
I've got this same problem - it drives me nuts. I'm using a dual monitor setup with a remote desktop client running Windows XP professional on my left and Tiger on my right. Been setup this way for the better part of the last 6 months. Roughly 25% of the time I try to copy across the network via a mounted share it just hangs. Force quitting the Finder is useless as that takes down the whole system. Once it happens I just have to force reboot, every time.
I'd still be upset about the situation however my 6 month old Windows XP box died - hard on Monday. Smoke and everything. PSU, MOBO and possibly the processor croaked. I'm not looking forward to fixing it nor to reactiving XP for the fifth time in six months. On a brighter note, it did make me realize that while Macs may have their quirks, the grass really is greener on our side. :)
Reply
Penginkun said 1:54AM on 8-06-2005
I wouldn't say that 10.4.2 is as stable as 10.3.9. Tiger still feels unfinished, has too many rough edges for me to be comfortable. And after re-installing the system SEVEN times last weekend, and having had lots of odd stuff happening (applications restarting unbidden, others quitting without a peep, torrents starting and stopping in Azureus) I've taken a step back in time to 10.3.9. It may all be in my mind but I feel a thousand times more comfortable already.
Reply
Splashman said 5:51AM on 8-06-2005
I'm one of those 10.3.9 troglodytes who's waiting for a 10.4.x release that I can feel comfortable with. I get to play in 10.4 on my wife's iMac, so I'm not unaware of Tiger's benefits, but they're not compelling enough to get me to upgrade my big box. Yet. Panther's been good to me.
Reply
Steve said 11:49AM on 8-06-2005
If the technology works...it is obsolete. Though I have had a few bumps and bruises (mostly over the Quicktime 7.0 munching my 6.5 Quicktime Pro and then not letting me use the reinstall 6.5 "on this computer") I love each upgrade and Tiger is no exception. And you are right Rodimus Prime, the grass is greener (or is it blueer?) on this side.
Reply
Mart said 12:25PM on 8-06-2005
Where to begin?
Tiger introduced Mail v.2, which did not automatically import my mailboxes, addresses or anything. I had to spend about 6 hours manually importing all my mailboxes, so if you have a lot of archived mail and mailboxes like I do then Mail v.2 is a pig. It also doesn't import your Mail rules - so all those filters you set up to combat junk mail will all be lost. It also does not consistently follow the settings you make for sounds; sometimes beeping every time it checks for new mail - even though no new mail arrives.
iTunes: never consistently remembers what you were listening to last so you always have to scroll through the list upon opening iTunes.
System Preferences: Sound refuses to remember that I set the balance of the stereo speakers slightly over to the right, and after a restart the balance will be back in the center again. Also it intermittently forgets what volume setting you left the Mac on before a restart, so that, for example the sound is at full volume after a restart even though it was set on low before.
Finder windows STILL do not update either in the foreground or the background, so that if you keep a window organized by Date Modified, it is lying to you until you click on the files you just updated.
The Search bar in Finder windows is useless. It does not find partial file names; e.g. try finding ".jpg" in a folder that you KNOW contains .jpg files. It won't find any.
SpotLight is way overrated; it is a beta product pretending to be ready for prime time. It looks great - but works inconsistently and does not work in the way a Finder find should do; e.g. having got a list of search results, and then having found several items that seem to fit the description of what it was you were looking for there is no way you can then organize those particular finds in chronological order. Stick with the Finder Find instead.
The desktop STILL refuses to remember icon positions after a monitor resolution change, except when you force it to keep organized by name or date, say.
Reply
Ure A. Kuntz said 5:23PM on 8-08-2005
I'm still on Jaguar!
Am I behind the times? What are the additional benefits of me upgrading, besides the computer stealing more of my free time?
Widgets? Why do I need to be kept up to date with so much crap? Do I need to be handcuffed even more to the computer than I already am?
I mean besides Email, Online Banking and Investments, Digital Photography and reading some world and sports news, I don't use the computer for anything else!
You must be all Video Editors, Animators, Spammers, Porn servers or Advertisers or something, right? Otherwise you must have so much to say on your personal Blogs, to let the world REALLY know what you're thinking?
OK I know I know I know evertually I have to upgrade...... I wish I had someone to do all the computer stuff for me so I could free myself to do other things like play more golf and go fishing without my tech stuff......
Reply
Stevo said 4:37PM on 8-08-2005
Hmmm... Mail 2.0 imported everything just fine for me: mailboxes, messages and even the rules. I've had no problems whatsoever with mail.
Reply