
Our friends over at Download Squad reviewed Calgoo, an offline Google Calendar client, last month. The reason we didn't pick it up is simply because it didn't run on Mac OS X at the time. Recently that changed, so here we go - but it is very apparent why they call this a first draft (as opposed to 'beta' or even 'pre-alpha').
Calgoo appears to be a Java app, or at least need it for something under the hood, and as you can see: it isn't quite on the Mac OS X side of the GUI fence. For some odd reason, users must register at Calgoo's site (which I begrudgingly did in the name of blogging) in order to be able to download and actually use the app. The actual setup is pretty straight forward, and syncing seemed to run well (a 'Message Log' tab in the upper right lets you keep an eye on activity), but navigating Calgoo's UI is anything but intuitive. Like Jason at Download Squad, I too couldn't see any of my appointments until I figured out their obscure calendar list in the lower left corner (hint: you can select and view individual calendars, or click at the top of the list to view them all. Why it's an actual process to get even any of your calendars to appear is anyone's guess). There are various other quirks and perks, such as Calgoo running on Mac, PC and Linux, event tagging/filtering and the fact that it downloads your Gmail buddies for easy attendance listing, but I was happy to see what is perhaps the most significant feature of Calgoo work like a charm: syncing with Google Calendar. I created a couple basic events in Calgoo and one in gCal, then synced. Once the dust settled, everything was reassuringly in order across both places, so at least that's a good selling point at this 'first draft' stage - cuz that UI sure won't be winning any Apple Design Awards anytime soon.
So would I recommend Calgoo? Yes and no. If you're just gaga for gCal, sure - it seems like a decent client, but there's definitely a UI learning curve. However, this seems to be the only app I've seen that has put a good foot forward in accomplishing such a task as truly synchronizing with Google Calendar, so I'll tip my hat to Calgoo and hope to see what tidings its evolution brings.













Reader Comments (Page 1 of 1)
9-21-2006 @ 10:19AM
Jason said...
Wouldn't the time be better spent getting some sort of plug-in or sync functionality for the built in iCal client?
Reply
9-21-2006 @ 10:32AM
Mark said...
I agree with Jason -- iCal is a better option. I've been using it to import my friends' gCal for quite a while now. Just follow Google's instructions and iCal takes care of the rest.
(The only shortcoming is that I can't add events to the gCal through iCal.)
Reply
9-21-2006 @ 10:42AM
thinkmilly said...
There's already an offline calendar called :iCal. All you need to do is select the private iCal links from Google Calendar and then subscribe to them. The one bit you have to adjust is making sure it says webcal in the URL and not http.
I do this with all my calendars, even the subscribed ones that are public and presto, offline calendar... also, I can sync it to my phone via blue tooth.
Reply
9-21-2006 @ 12:16PM
David Chartier said...
"The only shortcoming..."
That's the reason why a lot of people are interested in a true, offline/syncing client for gCal. Subscribing to read-only calendars is fine, I have a few myself, but *some* people require a lot more functionality out of a set up like this.
One unfortunately quirk of gCal is that you can't receive event alarms for any events that are *not* in your personal calendar. So if you set up calendars in iCal and subscribe to them in gCal, you can't, for example, receive those handy SMS reminders gCal *does* send out for its native Personal calendar.
This is one of the few good, strong examples why simply making a compromise and setting up a publish/subscribe relationship between gCal and iCal just won't cut it, at least for some people.
Reply
9-21-2006 @ 12:18PM
David Chartier said...
#1: Yea, that would certainly be the icing on the cake. We haven't heard of anything yet, but I would kill for a plugin like that.
Reply
9-21-2006 @ 12:58PM
Tony said...
The difference with using iCal is that it only subscribes to the gCal...It's my understanding that you can't add items in iCal and have them sync back to gCal.
Reply
9-21-2006 @ 2:17PM
Radu Dutzan said...
There's a lot of euphenisms for "it's really butt-ugly" in that post. Assuming it's Java, and most Java apps for OS X are quite ugly, I'd guess it's true.
Reply