Filed under: iLife, Multimedia, Software, Productivity, Reviews
TUAW Review: iPhoto '09 is a pretty picture
As noted by Robert yesterday, the first boxed copies of iLife '09 reached users today. The two iLife '09 apps that have changed the most are garnering the lion's share of excitement this week. iMovie and iPhoto have some rather dramatic improvements, and I'll detail the iPhoto changes here.Before you install, please note that the iLife '09 setup will nuke your older iLife apps. You'll need your original install disc to revert. I ran a Spotlight search and those old iLife apps are nowhere to be found. If you think you might want to roll back, be sure to back up your apps and your iPhoto library beforehand.
When you start up iPhoto for the first time it updates your libraries and starts an immediate search for faces in your photos. That search goes on in the background, so you can do other things with iPhoto at the same time.
Here's a rundown on the new features:
The most technically advanced feature is Faces. iPhoto now does some face recognition to help you automatically find people in your bushel of images. You start by identifying a face, and you enter the person's name. iPhoto will then suggest matches in your library, and you can confirm them with a click. iPhoto generates a cork board where you can see one example of each face you have identified. Double-click on that face and it displays all the other faces that match.
The technology is not perfect. It didn't get all the matches right, but when it was wrong I'd have to admit the person it found had a similar face. To try and trick it, I showed it a picture of a parrot. Although there were many similar shots of the same parrot, iPhoto utterly failed to match any of them. I think Faces wants human faces (although there are examples of penguins being recognized, and Mac|Life has tested it out successfully on feline faces).
Check out the gallery for some close ups of iPhoto features and controls, and read on for more notes on the updated features.
Gallery: iPhoto '09 Gallery
I had some trouble selecting a group of photos and applying a single location to all of them. It may be something I did, but sometimes it worked and sometimes it didn't. I couldn't find any way to take the info from one photo and apply it across a group of photos. That will be a weakness for some people.
The advantages of geotagged photos are evident in iPhoto's UI. You can look at a map of the United States, for example, see the red pins where photos were taken, click on the pin and see all the photos that were done there. The integration with Google Maps is very powerful, because when you are looking for a location, it is likely Google Maps already knows about it. While it's not a perfect feature, Places is very powerful and a welcome addition to the software.
iPhoto has also added Travel Maps. This feature allows you to enhance photo books that you buy from Apple. The maps can show where you have been, along with the photos from those destinations. It all looks quite professional, and is far beyond the capabilities of other programs.
Themed slide shows are very nice. They allow you to chose a style of slide show and select music as well, either built-in music in iPhoto or anything from your iTunes library. I especially liked the 'Snapshot' theme; that puts a white border around your photos, moves them smoothly across the screen, and as it brings up a new image, fades the older images to gray scale. When you have a slide show tuned the way you like, it can be exported as a movie to be viewed on an iPhone, iPod or an Apple TV.
iPhoto has beefed up the sharing options. You can upload photos to Flickr and Facebook; names of tagged people in the photos will go along with your Facebook upload. Location information will upload to Flickr and appear on Fickr photo maps. iPhoto will create Flickr and Facebook folders in your source list, so if you update or add pictures they will be updated on those photo services.
Finally, the new iPhoto offers some improved photo editing tools. It's not Photoshop, of course, but it can do quite a lot of cleanup and enhancement of photos that need it. The red-eye tool has been improved by using face detection. The retouch tool does a much better job of hiding artifacts, and an improvement in the saturation tool increases the color of images without messing up the face tones. I verified that this worked well. In fact, you could almost lose all the color of an image by reducing saturation, but the face tones stayed the same. Impressive.
Some users will still have some disappointments. You still don't seem to be able to group images by date added, a feature that was lost in iPhoto '08. There will likely be some things I've missed even after spending several hours with iPhoto today. A good sized book could be written on how to use this application, and certainly those books will appear.
iPhoto '09 is just one component of the entire iLife suite, but for many it will be worth the $79 US for iPhoto alone. There are a few rough edges, but it is a solid update of an already wildly popular program. I'm sure we'll hear users of Aperture clamoring for Apple to add similar features to the professional photo app.

![TUAW [Cafepress]](http://www.blogsmithmedia.com/www.tuaw.com/media/tuaw-cafepress-promo.png)


Reader Comments (Page 1 of 3)
WheelSee said 12:12AM on 1-28-2009
Picked up my copy at my local Apple Store today...sooo far I'm impressed
It seems like the more initial faces you tag the better that it recognizes people
Reply
Danny said 6:08AM on 1-28-2009
LOL I went to apple store too, but I tried to shoplift mine, and got arrested... The sales assistant told me it came with the MacBook pro I spent £2k the previous day... So I stole it out of spite.....
I eventually got my gf to go in and buy it...
Soooooo long story short, I shut down the computer halfway through facial recognition process, and now it doesn't work... Any way to get it to start process again?
Landon Gilmore said 12:27AM on 1-28-2009
This article states that "the iLife '09 setup will nuke your older iLife apps...I ran a Spotlight search and those old iLife apps are nowhere to be found."
I would like to correct this statement as I have had a different experience. I found a folder created in "Applications" called iMovie (previous version). The installer script moved iMovie '08 and my copy of iMovie HD (that was in "Applications") into this folder. I can confirm that both apps still work.
Reply
KarlW said 5:16AM on 1-28-2009
Or you could use Time Machine...
Adam said 12:34AM on 1-28-2009
Here is my question:
With Faces, is there any way to take tags you already have on pictures and add them to the new, corresponding face tag? For example, in a picture I have tagged three family members (Abe, Bob, Carey). Is there a way with out having to go through literally tens of thousands of tags and IDing the face a simple way to just add the whole picture to one person, say Abe?
Reply
James F said 1:57AM on 1-28-2009
No, and I am in the same boat as you. If it makes you feel better, the face tagging is pretty good and there are few false positives. I batch confirmed nearly all of them, so it won't take as much time as you imagine
Theo said 6:15PM on 1-28-2009
i have an issue with the Flickr export. It only tells me that I've reached the limit of sets and won't upload the photo until I create a new set.
Reply
Crabs said 1:07AM on 1-28-2009
I'm gonna buy the new iLife pretty much just for this and Garage Band. iMovie got good updates too, but I don't make many movies. I take tons of pictures, and hate sorting through them, and have never found iPhoto all that necessary. Faces and Places make it, if not necessary, much, much more useful. And the new stuff in Garage Band, I want to learn to play both the piano and guitar better, but want to do it in my spare time without hiring someone. So the built in lessons are great.
I'm excited for when I have 80 extra bucks lying around. Too bad it's not today.
Reply
andreas said 1:48AM on 1-28-2009
Is it possible to turn off backup when doing changes to a image? I can't believe it takes a backup even if I only removed red eyes. My library has pretty much doubled in size because of small adjustments to each picture.
Reply
James F said 1:58AM on 1-28-2009
There are utilities that will strip out the backups from the iPhoto library.
andreas said 2:01AM on 1-28-2009
Thanks. But that's not good enough.
Stephen.4 said 1:59AM on 1-28-2009
I can't wait until my copy arrives.
How are the new iWeb templates? If there are any?
Reply
joey said 2:10AM on 1-28-2009
Does anyone know if it 09 will nuke my Jam Packs? Or is Jam Pack compatible with 08 only?
Reply
Josh said 12:27AM on 2-06-2009
While face detection is a very cool feature, it doesn't seem to be very advanced judging from this post:
http://www.trick77.com/2009/01/28/iphoto-09-face-detection-not-very-advanced/
What are your experiences with Faces?
Reply
Chris said 7:02AM on 1-28-2009
Hi,
Maybe its just my noob-ish - but after I rotated an image, it seemed to get confused and started flipping betweent the landscape and portrait versions. These also looked to be done at the wrong scale - the image looked squeezed/stretched...
It also confused a face tag I put in and instead had my face as a patch of grass :(
I wish I could make it use iDisk to store the images... oh well, perhaps Picasa will get these features soon :)
Reply
Ed said 8:51AM on 1-28-2009
Have you tried moving the iPhoto library to your iDisk. I'd think it would get filled up pretty quickly, at least it would at the rate I put photos on...
I guess you should take it as a compliment that you look like a patch of grass - there's much worse things it could have chosen!
Chris said 5:21PM on 1-28-2009
Yay - moved it to iDisk - press the key during startup to choose a different location. Its then the default going forward.
Works for my tiny 5gb photo collection...
tom said 3:49AM on 1-28-2009
What's the Facebook integration like? Presumably you could actually outsource a lot f the IDing to your Facebook friends?
Reply
zerock said 7:01AM on 1-28-2009
when i get the new iPhoto I'm probably going to re-import all my facebook albums for the integration feature.
Reply
oz_paulb said 8:20AM on 1-28-2009
Does anyone know if the flickr integration allows you to upload 'full resolution' photos to flickr, or do they get resized?
I currently use flickrExport, and it lets me upload the full-res pics - I want to be sure that the new iPhoto also allows that.
If the new integrated flickr stuff doesn't allow full-res, does anyone know if the flickrExport plugin is compatible with iPhoto '09?
Thanks!
Reply