Skip to Content

Quicksilver and Spotlight

quicksilverI have been using Blacktree's Quicksilver since I first heard of it many months ago. At its most basic, Quicksilver is an application launcher of sorts for Mac OS X. Upon its initial launch it creates a catalog of your drive. You can then launch applications or manipulate files with just a couple of keystrokes. For instance, if I want to launch the Safari web browser, I only need to type "S" and hit the Return key. Quicksilver has "learned" that I want Safari launched when I call it into action and then type "S." Very convenient. Likewise, I open The Unofficial Apple Weblog by typing "Command-space" to activate Quicksilver, "UA" to select the URL and the Return key to open it in a browser. Quicksilver does much more than this, but this is primarily how I used it.

When I installed Tiger, however, I stopped using Quicksilver, having been seduced by Spotlight. After only a few weeks, however, I've begun using Quicksilver again. While a comparison of Spotlight and Quicksilver is really unfair, I can't help but do so. While Spotlight searches the contents of my drive in a very unique and thorough way, I believe I can get an application launched more quickly with Quicksilver. Even though I've set Spotlight up to display applications first, I still have to type "Photoshop" to get to that app, where as with Quicksilver I could type "ps" and then "Return" and have the application launching in the time it would take me to mouse down to it in the Spotlight results window.

What's more is that Quicksilver allows me to do more with my search results.  Having found what I'm looking for, I can then move it, compress it, email it, make a duplicate. . on and on. Understand that I'm not knocking Spotlight. I understand what fantastic technology it is. I'm just coming to the realization that there's room for both Spotlight and Quicksilver on my Mac. Have you used Quicksilver, and if so, what's your take?


Categories

OS Freeware

I have been using Blacktree's Quicksilver since I first heard of it many months ago. At its most basic, Quicksilver is an application...
 

Add a Comment

*0 / 3000 Character Maximum

20 Comments

Filter by:
Kathy C

ScottBruin says: "contents of my drives aren't well categorized (like my pictures are all named PICT001)." Thanks, Scott, for sharing. I just laughed out loud when I read that. Mine are all names like CIMG1532 and DCP_017. I can sympathize. I want to check out QuickSilver, but am I missing the intent of Spotlight? I thought it was for finding files. I launch from the dock. How ordinary.

July 06 2005 at 4:32 PM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply
DougL

AppRocket is a Windows app that does a little of what QS does.

June 28 2005 at 2:43 PM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply
Tony

This is kind of an aside, but I was wondering if there was anything at all resembling Quicksilver on PCs... I really like using the quick app start w/ Quicksilver.

June 14 2005 at 5:36 PM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply
Macuser

Quicksilver is okay. I generally like using the mouse and finder as opposed to having to type. What is the app that opened files like word documents, emails, et cetera in a pane brought up by a hotkey? It was blogged about here a while ago. II've not seen that funcionality in Quicksilver.

June 14 2005 at 8:27 AM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply
Rob Knight

I jus downloaded Quicksilver this morning after reading some of the comments here. WOW, it has been quite awhile since an app impressed me so much. It's the little app that you didn't know you needed. I love it.

June 14 2005 at 4:14 AM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply
Zach

Why is it that I cannot find the module for Spotlight and Adium? The downloads from Blacktree's QuickSilver site doesn't work, does anyone have any advice? Thanks!

June 13 2005 at 10:56 PM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply
Jakob

Jordan V: that was the Flashlight interface module that came out almost a year ago. The Spotlight Module simply performs a Spotlight search (in its own window) of the text you enter in the Quicksilver. It also saves time by only starting the search once you've entered the entire query, rather than searching each bit as you type it. Go to QS preferences->All, you'll find the Spotlight module there. I think you'll find it slightly more useful than the menu item interface.

June 13 2005 at 3:34 PM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply
Jordan V

I thought the Spotlinght module in QS was just a UI option that LOOKED like Spotlight before the real Spotlight existed. I still don't think it has anything to do with the actual Spotlight search engine. Small Paul -- No. QS doesn't use Spotlight. It was around long before Tiger. The new version uses some other Tiger functionality, and therefore you must be running 10.4 to run the most recent build of QS. QS is the ONLY shareware/freeware utility that I run (and still run) on my Mac. It is designed beautifully and supported wonderfully. I use it with Spotlight -- QS to launch apps, find contacts, etc., and Spotlight to find stuff burried further in the metadata. They're quite different from each other.

June 13 2005 at 2:38 PM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply
Matthom

I agree - Quicksilver and/or LaunchBar are FAR BETTER utilites for launching applications quickly. It seems Spotlight is just made for that - although it's certainly useful, and I'm sure eventually it will completely replace the Finder, itself. (Wired News) What's funny is I think there is MORE interest in apps such as Quicksilver, ever since Spotlight was introduced. Initially, I guessed that Quicksilver and LaunchBar would cease to exist, upon the arrival of Tiger. But Spotlight didn't turn out to be like we all thought it would - in some respects. I can't pretend I was not slightly disappointed in Spotlight.

June 13 2005 at 12:51 PM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply
Andy

I too just can't get over QS. When I first installed Tiger I tried mapping Spotlight to command-space but it just didn't work and after a day I was back to QS. Now I have Spotlight on option-space, but I can't remember the last time I used it. I remember where I keep things on my drive because I put them in appropriate folders, and I just use QS to navigate to those folders. Still, I am going to check out the Spotlight plugin and probably use that for the few times I'll want Spotlight.

June 13 2005 at 11:42 AM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply
Buy an ad here

Hot Apps on TUAW

Tweets

© 2012 AOL Inc. All Rights Reserved.