Filed under: Software, Reviews
TUAW Review: Griffin Technology's iFill
Installation and Initial Setup
Before you begin, you've got to enable disk use on your iPod. If you haven't done this yet, just plug your 'Pod into your Mac, launch iTunes and click the "General" tab in the iPod preferences. From there, select "Enable Disk Use."
Installation is a simple drag and drop into your Applications folder. When launched for the first time, iFill requests a registration code. If you want to try before you buy, you may request up to four demo codes that will each expire after one week. Finally, connect the iPod you intend to use and iFill sets it as the default recipient. Now you're ready to go.
Interface
The
layout of the application's main window is tidy and unobtrusive, and isn't the typical
toolbar-across-the-top type of thing we've all seen a million times.
Instead, four main points radiate from a central circle (more on the
circle later). First, quickly view how many songs are currently on your
iPod, iFill songs vs. non-iFill songs (note: this works differently on
an iPod shuffle, which is what I used for testing. With a shuffle,
there is no differentiation made between iFill vs. non-iFill tunes).Next, you can designate how much space you wish to allocate for iFill tunes on your iPod, and remove previously collected music with a single click (helpful for shuffle owners like me).
In the center of the window is a status circle that provides a lot of information at a glance. Depending on the lengths of the multi-colored status indicators in the circle, you can view the amount of music on your iPod (iFill vs. non-iFill), as well as the amount of data files and space available for non-music files. It's really quite nice, and you get used to reading it in a snap. Finally, you can select the radio stations you wish to record (yes, you can record more than one at a time!). Now the fun begins.
Real World Use: Recording and Playback
To select a radio station(s) for recording, click the "Choose" button at the bottom of the window for a list of suggested stations. Lucky, the station I was after, WOXY, was in the list. You can add the address you're after manually if you don't see it here. Next, it's simply a matter of clicking the "Record" button, and you're off.
When recording, iFill switches to the Record window. From here, you can see a list of the stations you're currently streaming, view the currently playing song and either listen along or mute the sound. A green status ring gradually fills in as your iPod collects music. Like I've said before, I think that iFill and the iPod shuffle were made for each other. I set iFill to fill my shuffle to the brim overnight, and the next morning I have a radio station that I would not otherwise be able to listen to in my pocket all day. Nice.My only complaint is something that really can't be fixed. Because you're recording an audio stream in real time (as opposed to downloading an Mp3 file), it can take a while to fill your iPod with a decent amount of music (which is partly why I set mine to work overnight). Like I said, there's nothing you can do unless you have power over the very nature of space and time, but don't expect to grab a whole lot of music during your morning shower and breakfast. Griffin suggests taking advantage of the simultaneous recording feature to combat this: record five stations over the course of an hour and you've grabbed five hours of music. True, but I only want to listen to one station.
Once your iPod is full, listening is just as enjoyable as any iPod experience is. My morning and afternoon commutes are so much better now that I'm free of terrestrial radio, as well as the same, old playlists I tend to obsessively listen to on my 'Pod.
Real World Use: Manage your Music Now that you've got all that new music, you've got to keep track of what's what. iFill incorporates a very iTunes-like browser for searching, sorting and basically managing all of your iFill music. Its functionality is very much like that of iTunes, so it's instantly familiar to any iPod owner.
The Bottom Line
iFill is an example of a simple application that does a single task well. I do wish I could somehow speed up the data transfer, but I know that's not possible. Other than that, this app is a winner. iFill requires Mac OS 10.3 or 10.4 or better, and a single license will cost you $19.99 US.

![TUAW [Cafepress]](http://www.blogsmithmedia.com/www.tuaw.com/media/tuaw-cafepress-promo.png)


Reader Comments (Page 1 of 1)
Greg said 5:32AM on 10-07-2005
Nice! I've been waiting this release since the original beta (back in June). Works very well, does what it promises and simple a'la apple style.
Only one thing that bothers me: it names each track automatically (with the artist and song name it receives within the stream). The result is hundreds of artists I never heard of among my "normal" artist list -- makes the list very long. So if I want to listen to something specifically in my ipod library I have to scroll through all these names... wish there was an option to just name all songs' artists to "ifill".
BTW, still no purchase page online - and the product page still says Beta.
Reply
Tom said 7:55AM on 10-07-2005
Want a "winner"? Try Radio Recorder. It's free, open source, splits songs into individual mp3s and saves them directly into iTunes in automatically generated playlists for each station. You can also schedule it to stop and start recording at specific times.
Reply
djoz said 8:40AM on 10-07-2005
Do you also have to set your iPod to update songs and playlists manually? Or can you use iFill and still have your iPod automatically update your playlists?
Reply
Wonkey the Monkey said 10:30AM on 10-07-2005
Does this software work with all streaming radio formats, or does it require particular protocols? Will it record .wmv or .rm streams, or am I better off just sticking with Wiretap Pro for that?
Reply
umijin said 10:59AM on 10-07-2005
I second the recommendation for RadioRecorder (FREE). You can also donate to the author if you want to part with money. :-)
Reply
Drew said 11:11AM on 10-07-2005
Thanks for the recommendations of Radio Recorder. iFill was buggy when I gave it a whirl, but this little freeware gem will suit my needs perfectly.
Reply
john spain said 2:28PM on 10-07-2005
No way to set up a timer to do this at specified times = this app is nearly useless.
Reply
Stephen Jonke said 1:26PM on 10-07-2005
All I can say is... this product is from Griffin and it is software. Ask users of Griffin's once touted "PowerMate", for example, about Griffin's software. Uh... it ain't a pretty scene, folks. Product after product is abandoned by Griffin, never having worked quite right in the first place anyway. iFill is a hack, one that is bound to stop working in the future - it is dependent on how the iPod functions internally, something which Apple does not make any guarantees about.
Griffin does not know how to write software and they always abandon existing products in favor of developing new ones that will get them back in the news again. Also, something this review fails to note that is of quite great significance: iFill requires that your iPod be in "manually managed" mode. I.e. you can no longer sync your iPod. If you switch back to syncing, it will remove everything iFill has put on your iPod. iFill is a hack and one that is bound to fail. If not now, later. And you can bet Griffin will eventually stop trying to fix it, just as they have done to every product before this one. Be afraid. Be very, very afraid... of Griffin software!
Reply
Stephen Jonke said 1:44PM on 10-07-2005
The freeware RadioRecorder does work if you can get the right URL. A URL from iTunes won't work, nor will many you get from the stream's web site. If you get a .pls file, open the file with a text editor and then copy the stream URL out of that. That URL should work.
If you don't want to deal with that type of shortcoming, then I recommend the not-free RadioLover. The UI is a little confusing (mostly it's OK, but manually adding a stream is confusing - you have to add the stream, then click the "Edit URL" button to actually put in the URL), and functionally it can't be beat. Yes it handles iTunes stream URLs, .pls files, etc. Very good product. I use to use iNet Stream Archiver, but it is really klunky and isn't getting regular enough updates. I've abandoned it in favor of RadioLover.
Something that none of these programs does which I would like to see added, is the abilility to fill in missing information by looking it up on the internet, including embedding album artwork. The cool program MP3Freaker does do this and I'd use it, but I want it to be automated so the stream gets recorded and all the info gets filled in automatically - MP3Freaker is not scriptable, so there is no easy way to have it run automatically on the ripped tracks. Sigh.
Reply
JohnO said 5:07PM on 10-11-2005
How does it compare to Audio Hijack?
http://www.rogueamoeba.com/audiohijack/
Reply