Video Quality: What $1.99 will buy you
So, I finally managed to get the full copy of Lost that I purchased off the iTMS to download successfully yesterday, and I've been watching it on my Mac, so I thought I'd share what $1.99 per episode will get you, and where the video quality is lacking.I've watched this episode several times already, both live as it aired and we had a chatcast of it over at TV Squad and then later, watching it on ReplayTV, when we did the podcast commentary on the episode, so I'm familiar both with what it looked like when it aired and at medium MPEG2 compression on my PVR device. $1.99 doesn't buy you that level of quality. Those of you who were hoping that this would be the triumphant return of Apple's foray into HD will be disappointed, as will anyone who is looking for truly high-quality video. However, if you are just looking for some TV that you can watch while typing up a report or on your new iPod during the morning commute, it's honestly not too shabby. More details with more detailed screenshots can be found after the jump....

If you click on this picture, which is a screencap taken while watching the Lost episode at full-screen, you will be taken to the full-sized copy of the image, so that you can really get a feel for the artifacts that start showing up as you try to watch these shows on anything larger than an iPod's screen. There is quite a bit of fuzziness and the cigarette that Locke is currently toking looks bent in the still (even though it is straight, and looks so during replay). Also, on shows like Lost where many of the scenes are so dark that they have an almost chiaroscuro effect, there will be multiple block artifacts in particularly dark scenes, when watching the video at larger than its default size. At regular size and even in the little window embedded in iTunes, it looks crystal clear, with no noticeable or distracting artifacts even in fast moving scenes with lots of action. At double normal size, you will start seeing a few artifacts, comparable to the compression artifacts you'll see when watching shows recorded on popular PVRs like TiVo and ReplayTV. Full-screen is much more like watching a VHS tape. Actually, it's more like watching an old VHS tape that has been watched one too many times.
Overall, however, I think $1.99 pre episode is a steal. It is watch-able. It's small and portable. The episode weighs in at 198MBs. The DRM baked into the file prevents you from converting it to other formats for watching on something like your PSP ( I already tried; no luck), but it doesn't prevent you from opening the file in other media-players like QuickTime (where the TV buffs among you can step frame-by-frame through the episode looking for clues to Lost's mysteries).
You cannot burn the files to a set-top viewable DVD, but you can make copies on your system, and it looks like you can burn copies as back up to removable media, just like any other data file. I think not allowing the video to be burned to a viewable DVD has less to do with restrictions put in place by the television industry and more to do with the big pain in the butt that re-encoding all these files to DVD video would entail. I mean it would be several hours of compressing and the resulting DVD would be low-quality. Also, as is evidenced by this post, the DRM doesn't prevent you from taking screencaps of what's going on, which is great for bloggers, film-students, and TV fans. Want a Desktop picture of your favorite scene from Desperate Housewives? It's as simple as Command+Shift+3, then set as Desktop picture.
I've heard a lot of criticism about this already from people saying, "Who would want to spend $1.99 on the show? I have TiVo/ReplayTV/bittorrent!" If you are happy with those solutions, then good, but I think $1.99 is a good deal. I mean, torrented TV shows can be hard to find at times and they often have things like the local TV stations insignia emblazoned along the bottom of the screen or the latest thunderstorm warning. Also, they are usually a bit larger than 198MBs and recompressing them can take time. This is the same difference with PVRs. Sure, I can use mReplay to jump into my networked ReplayTV and grab my shows, but they are in bulky muxed MPEG2 files that take quite a bit of processing to recompress to a manageable size and to remove the commercials. All that work and hassle and saved hard-drive space sounds like it is worth $1.99 to me. Although, I do hope that someone either figures out a way to strip the DRM so I can put these files on my PSP or that Apple and Sony strike a deal. Which of those do you think is more likely? Yeah, me too.
In conclusion, the $1.99 per episode is good for what it is, and it is even good enough to the point where I am actually considering buying the first season of Lost on the iTMS for $34.99 rather than grabbing it on DVD for $10 to $15 more.
As a side note, if you are a Lost fan, make sure you check out this week's podcast commentary on the show. Think; you can download the new episode later today in the iTMS. Open the file in Quicktime. Start playing the video and mute it, while listening to Ryan's commentary on the episode. That's nice podcasting sweetness.
Update: Here's a full-screen screen cap of Pixar's Gerl's Game for comparison. Also, our sibling blog, HD Beat wants to know what you would pay for HDTV download.
Share
Categories
So, I finally managed to get the full copy of Lost that I purchased off the iTMS to download successfully yesterday, and I've been watching...
Add a Comment
Has anyone had problems with the video on itunes being slow and delayed? I downloaded the first show of season 2 of Lost and although the video quality is good it is still like watching a slide show with dialogue. I have high speed internet and other videos like movie trailers play just fine. Can someone give me so pointers? Thanks
October 19 2005 at 1:17 PM Report abuse Permalink rate up rate down Replydude, tv resolution is only 720x576 (at least in pal) and not as huuuge as 1280x854 as your trying to watch it, a normal tv signal in fullscreen on a modern computer monitor will be scaled to at least twice the size and look odd too... take it easy what do u expext, high definition???? its only ment to be seen fullscreen on the TV in 720x576.... even a dvd looks ugly fullscreen on a big computer screen....
October 17 2005 at 4:44 AM Report abuse Permalink rate up rate down ReplyMy new ipod hasn't shipped yet, but I think the tv out connector will offer some interesting possibilities. I've been playing with the sony locationfree player for psp, watching streaming video from my pinnace showcenter and dvd's from a panasonic drm80h is quite watchable, I suspect that I should be able to connect the ipod in much the same manner. we will see.. watch my website www.distributed-home.com for details in the next few weeks.
October 16 2005 at 9:39 PM Report abuse Permalink rate up rate down ReplyWell, all of you are very lucky if you can pay for and download anything at all from Apple. I just tried to do the same, and since I live in the Netherlands and don't have a US addressed credit card I am SOOL!!! I really get fed up with reading about all the nice new things available, but not available outside the US. A WORLD WIDE web is somewhat of a joke. We can look but not buy to download. Let's see, where's my Limewire app....
October 15 2005 at 2:55 AM Report abuse Permalink rate up rate down Replyamen #44 geez.... I thought the comments sections was like engadgets, one continuous page. Someone got to jake before me. Takes the wind outta my sails... It would be GREAY if the new ipod dock could act as the IR receiver for Frontrow and If they integrate my Eyetv into there too...... I wouldn't be able to throw my money at apple fast enough.
October 14 2005 at 10:40 AM Report abuse Permalink rate up rate down ReplyWow Jake, you might wanna research what you say before calling your parents retards. You might wanna actually TRY IT OUT before insulting 320x240. Don't you know it has feelings too? Standard TV sets are usually 640x480 and mainstream is not a HDTV set. So 320x240 doesn't really look THAT bad on a standard tv set. Now if you plug that into an HDTV , thats a different story. Its about VHS quality which is watch-able. Its around VCD quality at a fraction of the storage. 200mbs as opposed to 600-700mbs VCDs. I actually did DLed Lost ep 1 from ITMS and have it on my mac mini output to my tv. To tell you the truth, it ain't half bad. It isn't great, if I go close to the screen I can see artifacts. But I'm watching from 10 feet away on my couch. At that range the artifacts are for the most part unnoticeable. I was kinda impressed. I am with you on wanting higher resolutions from ITMS. 640x480 ( near DVD quality ) sounds good to me. But bandwidth cost for something like that would most likely cost a lot so.... don't expect cheap at that resolution.
October 14 2005 at 10:25 AM Report abuse Permalink rate up rate down Reply"I mean, torrented TV shows can be hard to find at times and they often have things like the local TV stations insignia emblazoned along the bottom of the screen or the latest thunderstorm warning. Also, they are usually a bit larger than 198MBs and recompressing them can take time." 1. I don't think you have looked. There are hundreds of places you can find TV shows. 2. I have never seen a local TV insignia, let alone a "thunderstorm warning." That is simply ludicrious. Those things get edited out if they are there at all, which they are not. And even if they were, the episode would be removed and replaced by a better quality version. 3. Larger? On average a one hour tv show is close to 250-300 megs. And this is PDTV or so. Oh, and it is a much higher resolution. Alternatively, HR.HDTV (High Resolution High Definition TV) are also available, to the tune of 700 megs. I doubt you'll ever see these on iTunes.
October 14 2005 at 10:19 AM Report abuse Permalink rate up rate down ReplyDid someone connect a new iPod to a TV set and played a movie bought from iTMS? How does it look on TV?
October 14 2005 at 4:37 AM Report abuse Permalink rate up rate down ReplyIn RE 48: I have looked at files encoded to about these specs** on a "Home Theater" (42" DLP HDTV Monitor to be exact, via D4->Component conection from IO-Data link player, as well as something else I can't get into here...)in 480i and 480p (you know, what most tvs now do?) and it looks like TV. Computer displays are *much* higher res than TVs are, unless we are talking 720p/1080i/p...which the iPod doesnt output. People keep forgetting the whole "Plug iPod into dock with remote, connect to tv, enjoy the smallest, coolest 'Media Center' around" aspect of this. **320x240 MPEG4 video at 1100kbps, and 480x272 and 1100kbps. Could not use AVC (god i wish i could have, so i added 1/3 bitrate to typical apple download to approximate AVC-ish quality)
October 13 2005 at 11:31 PM Report abuse Permalink rate up rate down ReplyFor those of you looking for better quality, you really should go back and look at the file size for this mutha - 198MB for 320x240. Unless you've got a T1 connection, I wouldn't start looking for 1080i any time soon. Also, remember the intent is for the iPod's 320x240 screen, not for your home theater. If that's what you're after, buy the DVDs when they come out. Personally, I think $1.99s a steal when you have a DVR or TiVo mishap and don't want to wait an entire syndication sequence to catch what you've missed. Now, If we can just convince Apple to make a TV tuner/IR remote firewire box so everyone (not just new iMac buyers) can enjoy Front Row (with the TiVoesk goodness I'm implying), I'd buy a mini in a heart beat.
October 13 2005 at 9:02 PM Report abuse Permalink rate up rate down ReplyHot Apps on TUAW
Deals of the Day
more deals- iFrogz Luxe Lean Hard Case for iPod touch for $10 + free shipping
- Refurbished MacBook Air Laptops: Deals from $849 + free shipping
- iFrogz Breeze Hard Case for iPhone 4 / 4S for $16 + free shipping
- Ventev UltraTHIN Hard Shell Case for iPhone 4 for $2 + $2 s&h, more
- Body Glove Matrix Case for iPhone 4 / 4S for $3 + $2 s&h
- Pogoplug Premium Personal Cloud for PC and Mac for $10 + free shipping
Software Updates
more updates- EFI Firmware Update brings Lion Internet Recovery to 2010-model Macs
- OS X Lion 10.7.3 released with Safari 5.1.3, Wi-Fi bug fix
- Aperture updated to 3.2.2, addresses Photo Stream issue
- Apple updates Keynote to address Lion issues
- Google Search app gets new look on iPad
- Apple releases Apple TV Software Update 4.4.3



57 Comments