Filed under: Analysis / Opinion, OS, Other Events, iTunes, Leopard
Aqua is dead, long live Aqua!
Apple seems to use iTunes as a test-bed for new user interface design styles, and iTunes 7 brings with it an almost complete overhaul the Aqua look we have all grown to love/hate/tolerate. While on the surface, the iTunes 7 interface may seem very similar to that of previous versions, there are a few very distinct differences that I think forebode greater system wide changes to come in 10.5 Leopard. Since the initial version 10.0, OS X has gone through a variety of system-wide interface changes while still keeping some very important aspects of the original Aqua UI. First we lost the pinstripes, then we got brushed metal, and most recently, we see the move with most applications to a "unified" interface. With iTunes 7, Aqua is gone for good. Glossy radio buttons, scroll bars, control buttons and track information windows are all gone; replaced by sleek utilitarian sand-blasted metal. I think this is the first significant peek we've had into the rumored complete redesign of the OS X UI for Leopard.
I, for one, welcome this change. While the glossy days of old were an exciting way to draw new users–indeed, it was part of way I switched– it quickly became an eyesore for many; designers in particular. The introduction of the Graphite visual style fixed a lot of issues graphics professionals had with the bright colors of the interface clashing with their work, but everything was still not dandy. For pro and power users their Mac is not only a computer, it is the tool of their trade, and something they use day in and day out to get things done, and while no one wants to work in a badly designed, ugly UI, minimalist utilitarianism is sometimes the key to reducing distraction.
Of course, much of this is personal opinion, but it is an opinion I know is shared by at least a small core group of Mac die hards.
What's your take on the new interface? Is it just a fluke, or a hint at things to come?
![TUAW [Cafepress]](http://www.blogsmithmedia.com/www.tuaw.com/media/tuaw-cafepress-promo.png)
Reader Comments (Page 1 of 5)
Query said 5:40PM on 9-12-2006
I think that we both think alike, Dan. I thought of the same thing (as I JUST posted my opinion on it in the last article).
Oh, and we aren't completely through with pinstripes, yet. Any unfocused window with the light-gray UI still has it (as does the rest of the window at all times).
But it's nice to see Apple moving away from glass, seeing as Vista is so shiny, now, I can see my face in it. :-O
Reply
Brad said 5:41PM on 9-12-2006
Personally, I've always enjoyed the UI of Apple's Pro apps, such as FCP, Motion, and the rest. Aperture was something new, and I've grown accustomed to that too. UI design is essential to any application, and Apple has shown us that they still haven't found what they're looking for (no Apple-U2 pun intended). If this is the look and feel of the interface I'll be staring at next year on my MBP, I can't say anything bad.
Reply
alin Steglinski said 5:45PM on 9-12-2006
hate to say this but the interface sucks. i like the brighter colors. when i go on my computer i dont want it to look minimalist utilitarian i want it to be bright and joyful colors. PCS ARE DULL GREY BOXES (from mac intel commercial "intel processors have been trapped in pcs dull grey boxes doing duitiful work") I DONT WANT MY MAC TO HAVE A PC'ISH INTERFACE. NOW GET YOUR DEVELOPERS BACK ON THOSE CONSOLES AND FIX THE INTERFACE THE WAY IT WAS!!!!
Reply
JD said 5:46PM on 9-12-2006
Personally, I think the new "Unified" look, or whatever you want to call it, is pretty ugly - I dislike the title/toolbar area the most. But, what is worse is being inconsistent. In Tiger, we have brushed metal, Aqua, and Unified; please pick your poison, Apple. Hopefully this is fixed on Leopard.
It's also kind of ironic the new iTunes is very shiny and Aqua-like, when the interface is just the opposite.
Reply
Sean said 5:49PM on 9-12-2006
Oh, Gruber, where art thou? Please save us from Apple's two-minded monster that has seamingly eaten up the entirety of their HIG
Reply
DidYouLoseASock said 5:49PM on 9-12-2006
I am upset because I wish they would have used the GarageBand style :(
Reply
Billy K said 5:50PM on 9-12-2006
I'm not so sure I'd take iTunes new UI as a hint of what's to come in Leopard. iTunes has always kinda done its own thing. I guess that's because it's cross-platform and it updates more frequently than the other iLife apps. This could just be the look of iTunes and nothing more.
I'm still undecided about the new look overall, but I know I'm not into the album view that very closely resembles WMP Vista. Talk about taking up some real estate!
Reply
Billy K said 5:53PM on 9-12-2006
Oh - also - if you're not familiar with Uno, I'd highly reccomend it. It brings all the weird Tiger UI inconsistencies in line very nicely. Works wonders on iTunes 6 and Safari.
I wonder how it will play with iTunes 7.
Reply
Dan said 5:58PM on 9-12-2006
I hope it's not an indication of things to come [in Leopard]. I am not a fan of bright colours. I'm quite conservative in my tastes.
So, the fact I find the new scrollbars etc. in iTunes 7.0 absolutely horribly has nothing to do with me having a prediliction towards Fisher Price toys, and everything to do with aesthetic appeal (or lack of it).
What else that features in iTunes should we consider as portentous with regards to Leopard? Hopefully not the hideous SECTION NAMES (e.g. LIBRARY, STORE etc.) which looks... well. Hideous.
Reply
CajunLuke said 6:14PM on 9-12-2006
Hmmm... it appears to also not accord to my preferences. I like my scroll bars with the buttons doubled ont he top and the bottom. In iTunes, they're only on the bottom. How odd.
I think the whole thing looks like a Dashboard widget.
Reply
aazp said 6:03PM on 9-12-2006
I think something very similar to the new iTunes UI will be used as the iLife 07 UI. Leopard UI's will be closer to the unified aqua toolbar windows.
Reply
Chris Bell said 6:04PM on 9-12-2006
I'm completely with Alin Steglinski. Apple is turning my computer into a dull looking box. I wish they would unify the look then allow us to choose between Aqua/brushed metal/plastic. They could buy Shapeshifter and improve it to work even better than it already does.
Reply
whiggles said 6:03PM on 9-12-2006
Apple has got to get Leopard a complete UI make-over. The UI (though, like Dan said, very cool at first) has become an inconsistent monster of varying styles, buttons, icons and pictograms. Adobe has made a good example of UI redesign in AE 7. MAC OS X needs that, or they will end up just like windows (OK, we all know, that is never going to happen)
Reply
Ken R said 8:50PM on 9-12-2006
Yuck!
Macs are supposed to be nice and shiny. I love Graphite in Aqua, but I hope Leopard doesn't look as dull as iTunes 7. Tiger's Mail is a good example of how Aqua should be, becuase it finds a happy medium between matte and glossy. iTunes 7 reminds me of what a Microsoft designer would do, throwing in reflections and glass in all the wrong places in the middle of a dull box.
Reply
Jason said 6:12PM on 9-12-2006
This new version of iTunes looks like a cheap knock off. I hate the UI. Apple needs to change it back.
P.S. Apple sent me two new batteries for my one recalled powerbook bettery :).
Reply
Tobias said 6:15PM on 9-12-2006
It's been called unified, clean, minimalist, "Web 2.0". I call it confusing. OS X used to be so easy: lines between different part's of the UI, unmistakeable aqua blue for control elements.
How do you explain iTunes 7 to a n00b? "Well, just try clicking on everything, there's no way to tell what will react, though. If something happens you probably found a button (they come in many different shapes these days). If nothing happens, double click. If a support guy mentions things like preference window or confirmation dialog, just ignore it, 'cause everything's a pain now. I meant, pane."
Reply
Matt G said 6:14PM on 9-12-2006
I like the iTunes 6 theme better, the glossier buttons and UI looks far more pleasing to the eye than this new dull interface. I think Apple was totally into the Aqua at first and they wanted to dull it out a bit to get a more reasonable UI, but they've stepped a bit too far over the line.... PLEASE APPLE GO BACK TO THE OTHER UI. It was so much more colorful and vibrant.
Reply
Matt G said 6:14PM on 9-12-2006
Just to clarify i like everything, i just wish they'd go back to the OLD buttons, and make the menu on the left WHITE again, it just looks a bit dull.
Reply
Indiana said 6:17PM on 9-12-2006
It is ugly and unstylish. There is no way around it. Where is the coool atomic-burn-button?? The shaded colors are terrible and so windowesque! I can only hope these "style" ends with this version of iTunes and does not progress anymore, ever.
Reply
mark said 6:23PM on 9-12-2006
the problem is they forget to re-design the preference window, the get info window and all the prompts etc...
so it has this messy feel.
Reply