Ah, the open road. What's more American than being mobile, drifting along the highways and byways, traveling hither and yon, free as a debt-laden bird? While I try to rein in that derailed train of road metaphor, let's consider the options for Mac users and wireless data. Many of you would love to take your Internet access with you as you travel on family vacation or spring break; for others, terrestrial broadband (cable modem or DSL) is unavailable or prohibitively expensive at your fixed location. Good news for all: the choices on the wireless access front are better than ever before. We'll cover the US domestic options today, and hopefully get to Europe/UK and other international options sometime soon.More on Mac wireless broadband after the break.
For maximum mobility and convenience, the #1 choice of the road warrior is EVDO or HSDPA. These wireless standards are the direct replacement for the "1xRTT" cellphone data service, which topped out at about 100kbps download speed (not at all shabby by modem standards, but it's not really broadband, is it). Current EVDO Rev0 systems (most of the US) max out at about 700kbps down and 150kbps uploads, but just around the corner is EVDO RevA, which boosts the upload performance dramatically; HSDPA performance is comparable. Future revisions to both standards are supposed to rival wired connections for speed. Meanwhile, if you wander out of an EVDO coverage area (most metro environs, airports and highways), your card will automatically fallback to 1xRTT connectivity. Note also that EVDO is based on the CDMA cellphone standard, which is limited mostly to the US of A; HSDPA is an outgrowth of the international GSM standard, so in theory it will work internationally.
There are currently PC Card and ExpressCard EVDO & HSDPA solutions for mobile Mac users from Verizon and Sprint (EVDO) and Cingular (HSPDA), with equipment costs around $100 and monthly service charges around $60 a month for 'unlimited' service; the drivers are even built-in with OS X 10.4.9 and the WWAN update. Until recently, Cingular's support for HSDPA on the Mac was limited, but the AirCard 870 is supposed to work with the WWAN Apple drivers. If you've got a PowerBook G4 and you're thinking of upgrading to a MacBook Pro, you can get the ExpressCard form factor with a PCMCIA adapter and future-proof yourself. What if you've got a machine with no card slot (iBook or MacBook), or a desktop machine? Fear not: Verizon, Sprint and Cingular now all sell USB-connect versions of their cards, which work with pretty much anything.
If you want to share an EVDO connection amongst several of your computers, you can use the built-in Internet Sharing feature of Mac OS X, or for several dollars more, both Kyocera and Linksys sell WiFi routers that sport a PC Card slot for an EVDO card. You let the router handle the wireless WAN connection, much as old Airport base stations could dial up your ISP, and you just connect over the standard WiFi support -- so easy, and great for an RV or field production office. Check out EVDOinfo.com for current pricing and card availability.
A card or USB dongle isn't the only way to get EVDO/HSPDA into your Mac; some cellphone models support direct tethering for broadband on the Mac (not as many as Windows, sadly), and we noted a Blackjack tether solution late last year. You can see a list of the Verizon models that support tethering (also sometimes called DUN for Dial Up Networking) at this driver download page. If you've got a Palm-based Treo 680 or 700p, you can tether your Mac via Bluetooth or via USB with the PdaNet package, and there are plenty of third-party guides out there for other Treos; however, the 650 offers only 1xRTT speeds, or slower in some cases. Blackberry users have fewer tethering options; you can either use a Bluetooth tether and a separate proxy server, or (on Intel Macs) connect the Blackberry in Parallels and back-share the connection to the Mac. Weak!
Speed: Good, getting better with EV-DO Rev A and future HSDPA releases
Coverage: Almost universal for 1xRTT, major metro areas and airports for EV-DO (see EVDOinfo.com for latest coverage areas), more constrained for HSPDA
Cost: Moderate, $60/month in most cases
As a replacement for cable or DSL service to a specific spot, your best choice is fixed or semi-permanent wireless (WiMax or similar) like that offered by Towerstream, Clearwire or other vendors. If you're in the coverage area for one of these services, you can get premium bandwidth over-the-air. Clearwire will also let you move your antenna from place to place within the coverage zone; Towerstream, marketed and priced for business use, requires a permanent antenna install. From the Mac's perspective, these services -- provisioned via a standalone modem and Ethernet-out -- appear just as a cable modem would; both can also be connected to a local WiFi network without difficulty.
Speed: 1.5 Mbit down (Clearwire), up to multiple T1s (TowerStream)
Coverage: limited
Cost: very high (TowerStream), moderate (Clearwire)
The next best thing to a direct fixed-wireless connection is roaming WiFi or community internet, where you can piggyback on an existing deployment of base stations to get your broadband fix. The most well-known of these deployments is probably T-Mobile's HotSpot service, which lights up every Starbucks and FedEx/Kinko's location with those sweet, swift megabits; others include Boingo, iPass and Wayport. All offer daily or weekly pass pricing in addition to a standard subscription plan; T-Mobile charges range from $40/month for month-to-month unlimited access, down to $20/month as an add-on to your existing T-Mobile cellphone service. In either case, if you happen to live within 100 feet of a Starbucks (who doesn't?) or you're a member of the digital bedouin class, this might be the solution for you.
Another approach to shared broadband is community or share-alike WiFi, where municipalities or individuals choose to provide service that's available to all. I'm particularly interested in Fon, a share-alike service where you install one of the company's $40 custom routers and then gain free access wherever others have done the same. For community internet projects or other free access in your neighborhood, check out nodedb.com or jiwire.com and see maps & lists of access points. Please note that when you're using a shared access point, it's bad form to run bandwidth hogging applications such as BitTorrent clients.
Speed: Varies by location, generally good
Coverage: Point coverage
Cost: moderate, offers on-demand pricing with daily passes/free in some cases
For the extreme high ground of broadband, there's nowhere to go but up: Satellite broadband service from providers like WildBlue, HughesNet (formerly DirecPC) and StarBand can get you online in areas where no other connectivity options exist. These are fixed installs, not roaming: the satellite footprint covers most of the continental US, but the back-channel 'squirt' requires fine antenna calibration. Speed offerings vary, with most services starting at a baseline 512Kbps download rate and going up from there with premium pricing. The service isn't suitable for gaming or VoIP use (high latency caused by the trip from geosynchronous orbit) and the initial equipment installation can be pricey ($400 or more in some cases). Still, if your fishing cabin/fortress of solitude/bomb shelter is out of reach of the standard connectivity options, going orbital might be the best choice.
Speed: Comparable with EVDO or DSL (512Kbps + download)
Coverage: Nigh universal, assuming you have sky sightlines
Cost: Moderate ($50/month) but high startup costs
Good luck unplugging! If you have an interesting or terrifying Mac wireless networking setup, let us know.













Reader Comments (Page 1 of 2)
4-03-2007 @ 9:12AM
ZylogZ80 said...
I'm located near Durham NC and I have Clearwire. It's really pretty awesome, and I'd recommend it to anyone who ONLY wants internet access, and not phone or cable.
I get 1.5 down - not the 3 that cable offers where I am, but my bill is just under 40 a month. Plus I don't need to get sh***y services I don't want, like cable (google video, youtube, and iTS are all I need!), or a land line (how last century).
It's reliable, always fricken works, and is pretty darn cheap. I highly recommend it.
Reply
4-03-2007 @ 9:44AM
theoldcoot said...
Great article.
What I'm looking for is a site, since I can't find anything on Apples site that gives information on all the routers that Mac's support. Know of any.
Reply
4-03-2007 @ 10:02AM
Jeremy Goldstein said...
I have been searching for an HSDPA USB device for my Macbook.. Cingular seems clueless as to what I am talking about, but this article mentions the availability of such a device with Cingular.. Do you know something that I (and Cingular) don't?
Thanks!
Reply
4-03-2007 @ 10:02AM
Danny said...
Great topic for a post, and something I'm pretty interested in. But I found this article tough going. Perhaps it's having a UK perspective, but all this talk of EVDO and 1xRTT meant nothing to me and it took me a while to figure out that you were talking about hooking up to the internet through a mobile phone network. Perhaps that was just me being slow... All that said, I did learn something from the post. So thanks.
Reply
4-03-2007 @ 10:11AM
Alex said...
Does anyone know whether the iPhone will include DUN via bluetooth like the Palm Treos? Currently this is how I road surf via a Sprint PCS Treo 650.
Reply
4-03-2007 @ 10:33AM
Michael Rose said...
#2 -- Most routers are OS-agnostic and support the Mac fine, although some have setup utilities that are Windows-only (you can generally set them up via a web UI as well).
#3 -- Updated the post to clarify that HSPDA support is via the WWAN software update, not Cingular-provided drivers. The AirCard 875U is supposed to be out pretty soon and that should work as well, but your mileage may vary.
#4 -- sorry, clarified in the top section that this is a US domestic overview. We would love to do the same for the UK, EMEA and other areas if we can get the info together.
#5 -- I don't know if that's been determined yet, but remember that the iPhone does NOT support HSPDA, and prefers WiFi for high-speed surfing.
Reply
4-03-2007 @ 10:34AM
Michael Rose said...
#2 -- you can also check here for a pretty thorough list of Mac-compatible products:
http://www.apple.com/guide/us/
Reply
4-03-2007 @ 10:34AM
Biffo said...
Although this was of no practical use to me, (not in US) this was an excellently researched and written article.
More of this standard please TUAW!
Reply
4-03-2007 @ 10:38AM
Alfresco said...
A UK version of this would be VERY handy, as I'm planning to go traveling with my MacBook (oh and my wife i guess...) and I don't want to rely on internet cafes.
Reply
4-03-2007 @ 10:42AM
Michael Rose said...
#8 -- thanks Biffo! The best way for you to support this sort of posting is to forward it or tell friends to check it out. The more people who come to read TUAW, the more resources we have to offer this kind of full-featured piece.
#9 -- LOL, and message received; I'll see what I can do about the UK piece as soon as possible. The short answer is that a Cingular HSPDA card will theoretically work in both countries, but your roaming costs may be quite high.
Reply
4-03-2007 @ 10:42AM
David said...
High Speed Downlink Packet Access is "HSDPA". Do a find and replace on "HSPDA". I suppose you can't be blamed because a lot of Cingular's staff can't get this right either.
Reply
4-03-2007 @ 10:44AM
Michael Rose said...
ARGH! Changing HSPDA to HSDPA
Reply
4-03-2007 @ 10:58AM
Brian Allen said...
I would have included in your discuss EDGE and GPRS, which the primary method of connection for the GMS networks in the US. I travel and hit many large cities, but I primary only find EDGE and not UMTS/HSDPA.
Your phone or card is primary limit on the bandwidth. The device will only have so many channels that can be used. Typically, you are looking for the CLASS number that is higher.
The EDGE devices are multi slot class devices. Multi slot Class defines maximum number of slots the device can operate with. Class 10 means: totally maximum 5 slot configuration, with maximum receiving/downloading 4 slots and sending/uploading 2 slots (either 4 receiving + 1 sending or 3 receiving + 2 sending). But, you will find CLASS 8, 12, and others. Phones normally top out at 10 while cards top out at 12.
Reply
4-03-2007 @ 10:59AM
Brian Allen said...
proof read!!! aaagh!
Reply
4-03-2007 @ 11:08AM
Michael Rose said...
#13 & 14 -- I did proofread, and had a colleague look it over as well; just picked up the wrong acronym. Drat! That'll teach me to blog late at night.
EDGE & GPRS I would consider in the same class as 1xRTT, which is to say a pre-3G service and not actually broadband. While they are great solutions for roaming connectivity they don't offer performance that could substitute for DSL or other fixed access. Granted, the iPhone will be GPRS, so it can't be all that bad...
For the UK/Europe review perhaps we'll go into more detail about the 2G and 2.5G services.
Reply
4-03-2007 @ 11:11AM
Paul said...
Lucky as I am I live in good old Austria. We have a UMTS network with good coverage and a fallback GPRS-Edge Network. Using a Nokia 6233 and a PB 12' connected via Bluetooth gives me all the freedom I need.
Reply
4-03-2007 @ 12:38PM
Brian Allen said...
I was complaining about my post's errors and not yours.
Reply
4-03-2007 @ 12:40PM
Brian Allen said...
I believe the iPhone will be EDGE based on Apple's site.
Reply
4-03-2007 @ 2:39PM
Michael Rose said...
#18 -- sorry, you're right, I mis-wrote. iPhone is an EDGE device.
Note here re. the HSDPA USB modem from Sierra Wireless; it WILL be Mac OS X compatible, but is not yet listed as shipping:
http://www.sierrawireless.com/product/usbmodem.aspx
Reply
4-03-2007 @ 2:41PM
eric said...
i use my blackberry pearl as a bluetooth modem. it works pretty well if you use a custom modem script.
Reply