Filed under: Audio, Software, Reviews
AudialHub 1.0
We here at TUAW have expressed our love of VisualHub, Techspansion's great video encoding app, time and again. But what if those crazy folks at Techspansion decided to take the video part out of VisualHub? The resulting app would be very much like AudialHub, an audio converter that takes many UI and functionality cues from VisualHub.
Read on for our full review.
Update: I mistakenly quoted the special VisualHub cross-upgrade promotional price as the full price for AudialHub. This error has been corrected.
Main Window
When you first download AudialHub ($14.41 $18.81 for the full version, the free demo will convert the first minute of any compatible audio files) you are prompted to download some open source audio libraries which AudialHub uses to work its magic. The 3.6 meg download is installed very quickly, and then you're good to go.
Here is the main user interface for AudialHub:

Very streamlined. As you can see in this screenshot, I have two audio files waiting to be converted. The first is an MP3 while the second is an AAC file that I purchased from the iTunes Store. You'll notice the red 'X' and the Runtime listing of 'DRM' on the iTunes store track. As you might expect, AudialHub cannot convert any audio formats that are protected with DRM since that would likely not be legal. It would be nice if AudialHub wouldn't even allow you to add DRMed tracks to its conversion queue, but since the app has to determine if the file is DRMed or not the red X is a good solution.
What it can do
AudialHub will convert a wide variety of file formats to and fro, including:
- AAC
- MP3
- WMA (Windows Media)
- 3G (for various cellphones)
- Ogg Vorbis (the format of choice for a number of Hippies 2.0)
- AIFF
- WAV
- Apple Lossless
- FLAC
You can also use AudialHub to burn either an Audio Disc or MP3 CD.
Many of you are thinking, 'Can't iTunes convert audio files for free?' It can but with a few limitations. iTunes only supports encoding in the following formats:- AAC
- AIFF
- Apple Lossless
- MP3
- WAV
If this list covers all the formats you're interested in you might think that AudialHub would be money wasted, but then that might not be the case.
The real advantage that AudialHub has over iTunes is that it has been designed from the ground up as a batch converter. If you have a large number of audio files to convert from one format to another, AudialHub has you covered. Better yet if you want to convert all those files and then upload them all to a server AudialHub is your app. Why? One word: workflows.
The 'When done' menu, my favorite feature of VisualHub, is included in AudialHub:

This seemingly innocuous menu has saved me more than a few dollars of electricity over the years (and isn't being green the new black?). When AudialHub is done doing its thing you can have it quit itself, automatically put your Mac to sleep, add the converted files to iTunes, or open the folder in which the files were saved. Powerusers can even have AudialHub run a script when it is finished encoding. This enables you to create workflows that take those newly encoded files and do any number of things (upload them to a directory, post them to your blog, email them to a distribution list, and so on). The possibilities are endless.
Not only can you take the files AudialHub creates and have a script interact with them, you can even have AudialHub combine them all into one big file. This could come in handy should you want to create an extra long MP3 from a number of different MP3s for an exercise soundtrack (just to name one possible application of this feature off the top of my head).
Another big advantage AudialHub has over iTunes is previewing your files. You don't actually have to convert your whole file in order to hear what it will sound like. Simply click the preview icon and this window pops up:

Click play and you'll hear what the final file will sound like, provided you check the 'Play including Compression' box. Change some settings and hit 'Generate Preview' to make sure the sound is still up to snuff. You can even set how much of the file you want to preview (by default it starts 5 seconds into the file and plays for 10 seconds, looped).
Why spend time working when you can mess with settings?
Speaking of settings, AudialHub offers you a slew of settings to fiddle with. The application is set to automatically determine the best settings for the file itself, but if you're a control freak you can delve into the 'Advanced Settings' and get exactly what you want.
The first Advanced Setting tab is called 'Audio:'

- 'Fit each file into:' This lets you set an upper limit to the size of the resultant file. Very handy for you podcasters out there.
- 'Normalize' This is also handy for podcasters out there who push out audio tracks with a number of different people talking at the same time but not in the same place. The volume levels are usually way off between participants (one person has their mic volume cranked all the way up, another person likes to whisper). Normalizing will try to get all the audio to be around the same volume.
'One-offs' are next:

As you can see these settings were designed for working with only one file in mind, but you can apply them to a batch if you like. You can trim some audio off the front and the end of a file, set the tags of the file, or check out what the tags are currently set to.
'Info' gives you, as you might guess, information about the currently selected file:

You can also set a number of different options in Advanced Settings and then save that configuration for use on another copy of AudialHub, or for use later.
Buy one copy of AudialHub, get infinite copies for free
As I said, AudialHub is all about batch processing of files. But what happens when you have 53 MP3s you want to change into AACs and 14 WMAs that you need to be MP3s? AudialHub has you covered with Queues.

Command-N creates a new AudialHub 'Queue,' which is just another copy of the application. This allows you to run any number of copies of AudialHub concurrently so you can convert large numbers of files from one type to another. This also allows you to convert a number of different files and have each Queue fire off a different script (one queue might be simply converting files, while another is converting files and then uploading them to the web, and so on).
It worked for Ford, it'll work for you.
You say your computer is scattered with MP3s that need to be converted to something else? Or you spend all day creating countless audio files and you want to convert them as you go, rather than creating a batch of them? AudialHub has a mode that's just for you.
Under the Conversion menu sits 'Start Assembly Line,' as seen below:

Once you start the Assembly Line, as I did above, AudialHub patiently waits for you to drag files into the main window or onto the Dock icon. Once a file has been added to the Assembly Line it immediately starts converting according to whatever settings were entered (in the above screenshot any file added to AudialHub would be converted to an MP3). Combine this with Queues and you can have several Assembly Lines running at the same time for each audio format AudialHub supports.
The $18.81 question
All of these features are great, but are they worth $18.81? If you have lots of audio files that need to be converted into other formats then the answer is clearly 'Yes.' Without a doubt, AudialHub will save you countless hours, and allow you to do things with your files that you probably thought about doing before, but didn't get around to doing because implementing them would have taken too much time. AudialHub offers up a number of very good features in a UI that is clear to use, and with documentation that is actually fun to read (seriously, even if you don't buy this app make sure you read the included documentation).
If the fact that iTunes can actually convert audio files into other formats came as news to you, AudialHub is not an app for you. Likewise if you convert an AAC into a MP3 once every few months there is no compelling reason for you to part with your hard earned cash. Just use iTunes for your occasional converting needs and you'll be fine.
AudialHub is a well thought out application that is targeted at a very specific group of users. It's safe to say that those users are very happy that AudialHub is on the scene, and will recoup the $18.81 investment in no time flat.
Get a WordPress.com Blog
![TUAW [Cafepress]](http://www.blogsmithmedia.com/www.tuaw.com/media/tuaw-cafepress-promo.png)


Reader Comments (Page 1 of 2)
G said 9:35AM on 4-21-2008
I don't see anything about LAME MP3 encoding. Is it just using the encoder built into QuickTime? I hope not. Raspy it is. Easy LAME encoding might make it worth $14.41, although..
Free alternative: http://sbooth.org/Max/
Normalizing will not automatically make all members of a Podcast audible if they are in the same recording. That simply finds the loudest part of a recording, and brings everything up equally so that the loud part matches your defined level (usually at or near 100%). But if Mr Loud guy was already at 90% and Ms Whisper was at 20%, and your goal is 100%, she'll still only be around 30% when it's done. For true auto-riding level control, you want a compressor and/or limiter. If this app supported AU plug-ins, you could add whatever you needed while batch processing. That would be smexy, and might make me try it over Max.
Reply
stainboy said 10:36AM on 4-21-2008
what a great idea about the AU plug-ins. this IS a 1.0 product, but maybe if you, me and a whole lot of other paying customers ask for it, we could get it in 2.0....
Simon Arch said 4:31PM on 4-21-2008
Tyler is very receptive to feature suggestions (although he's not always able to accommodate every request or add stuff right away) so you have nothing to lose whatsoever by asking. And I agree, AU plugin support would definitely be a useful addition to the app.
Jorge Asch said 9:38AM on 4-21-2008
The correct price of the App is $18.81. $14.41 is the promotional prices for current Visualhub customers only.
Reply
Billy K said 9:45AM on 4-21-2008
Looks like a decent app. I like Techspansion's stuff. But there are some alternatives, which happen to be free.
The commenter above mentioned Max, which works, but I find it to be slow and crash-y.
I prefer XLD, which is flexible, fast and free. It covers more formats overall than Audial Hub, but not WMV.
http://tmkk.hp.infoseek.co.jp/xld/index_e.html
http://www.makeuseof.com/tag/audio-converters-for-mac-max-vs-xld/
Reply
Simon Arch said 2:35PM on 4-21-2008
I second XLD. It's not quite as pretty as AudialHub, but it seems to do for free most of what AH does.
And I'm not one to jump on the "Who paid you to say this?" bandwagon, but if I didn't know better I'd think Tyler paid you to post this. A full review would highlight the negative aspects of the program. This reads like a press release. You should also have noted, Scott, that the $14.41 price is NOT the application's regular price. That price is only available to registered users of VisualHub.
I know Tyler does good work, so I'm interested in the application already. But I need to know if there are any serious drawbacks or "gotchas" to consider. Are there any?
a ham sandwich said 10:06AM on 4-21-2008
i dunno im skeptical about this article. it sounds like somebody was paid off to write it. :(
Reply
RichardCHerron said 10:09AM on 4-21-2008
I'm yearning to convert podcasts to audiobooks so that I can listen to them faster. For the powerusers: Will this fit the bill? Can this create the audiobook file format?
Reply
RichardCHerron said 10:11AM on 4-21-2008
Will this convert to audiobook format? I'd love to convert my spoken word podcasts to audiobook and listen to them faster.
Reply
Quix said 10:11AM on 4-21-2008
Audio file conversion is great and all, but when are we going to get *real* EAC-like CD ripping on the Mac?
Yes, Max has been trying (though no progress recently), but still does not come close to EAC.
I'm surprised with the surge in OS X popularity that we haven't seen a true OS X version of EAC.
Reply
5cents said 10:17AM on 4-21-2008
I use Switch, the version I have being free. Don't much like using it but usage is rare so who cares...
Reply
Galley said 10:26AM on 4-21-2008
I suspect there are many FLAC enthusiasts who would be interested in this app.
Reply
Bob S. said 11:39AM on 4-21-2008
I use xACT to convert between formats and Tag for filling in tags -- both are free; xACT seems to use the same conversion libraries that AudialHub does, and Tag has a decent interface that's intelligent enough to understand that some tags will be the same among related files (genre, artist, date, for example) but not others (track number, title).
What I'd love is an app that can handle a workflow. Right now I have to take FLAC files and 1) add tags using Tag and copy them to my NAS, where my Soundbridge has access to them using Firefly, and 2) convert to AIFF using xACT, then use iTunes to convert those to ALAC for my iPod, and then add tags to them. An app that can do that for me would get my money.
Reply
lyso said 12:11PM on 4-21-2008
Dunno about everything you're saying there, but Max will certainly convert FLAC to ALAC, preserving tags.
Bob S. said 1:02PM on 4-21-2008
Thanks, lyso. First I'd heard of the program, and the MacUpdate writeup looks promising; I'll check it out.
MickTorrent said 12:59PM on 4-22-2008
I too was using xAct and then iTunes to convert my FLAC to ALAC to play in iTunes, but now I'm using AudialHub as it is. I am still using xAct for tagging (Max is too buggy for me)
Bob S. said 3:01PM on 4-22-2008
Mick, you might want to try Tag ( http://www.macupdate.com/info.php/id/21641 ) -- I can't say whether it's the Best Tagging App Ever, but I can vouch that it's much better than xACT's tagging interface. (I'm not affiliated with MacUpdate or xACT or Tag or much of anything.) I use the Basic panel to batch-set the tags that the files have in common and then use the Tabular panel to enter titles and track numbers; it goes pretty quickly.
I did look at Max and thought its interface was a bit kludgy; it looked like it might actually be a bit less efficient than my current workflow, albeit with the one-app advantage. I'll play with it a bit more but will probably end up sticking with my current workflow if for no other reason than I've got it down to a routine.
Oliver Chesler said 1:33PM on 4-21-2008
It uses the Lame Encoder and that why I bought it. Read my review here:
http://www.wiretotheear.com/2008/04/18/techspansion-releases-audialhub-for-mac-yay/
Reply
Max said 2:44PM on 4-21-2008
Nice looking app. Makes me wonder why VisualHub is so ugly, and has a hideous icon, when this app looks so sweet?
Don't get me wrong, I own and love VH, but it sure is lacking in the looks dept.
Reply
Bob Mc said 3:31PM on 4-21-2008
I purchased VisualHub, but I won't be buying this. For free, I can use XLD which does everything I need it to do.
Reply