Skip to Content

Live Mesh now available for Mac OS X

[Editor's Note: Several comments objected to the comparison between Dropbox and Microsoft that implied Dropbox's reputation was less than ideal; we also heard directly from Dropbox founder Arash Ferdowsi on this point. The post has been edited to clarify the sense Cory intended -- while Dropbox's service is well-regarded and its backers are notable, some may feel comfortable with a more-established vendor for cloud storage. Our apologies to Dropbox and its users for the unintentional slight.]

While many Mac users use MobileMe for file synchronization, there are the a few (*raises hand*) who think it's overpriced. Therefore, I have been looking for alternatives. Dropbox is nice, but I wanted more storage, and I wanted it from a reputable company with a longer track record. I had heard about Live Mesh, Microsoft's up and coming synchronization service so I decided to check it out.

While there are plenty of anti-Microsoft Mac users, I tend to like some of their products (i.e. Microsoft Office). Their Live Mesh service just recently came to the Mac platform, and is well built. Once you create/sign-in with your Windows Live ID, you can add new devices for file synchronization, including Macs and PCs (phone support coming soon). To add a Mac to your Mesh account, you'll need to download a small application. This menu bar application will upload your specified folders to Mesh, and keep them in sync.

Two things about the Live Mesh service that I really like are: (1) You have the ability to sync up to 5 GBs of data. (2) You can access your files anywhere with the Mesh.com website. However, you'll be presented with a Windows Vista theme, which can be unfamiliar for some Mac users. Overall, I have really liked using this service, but there are a couple of complaints. While the desktop Mesh client is a menu bar application, the Dock icon remians visible -- I found this annoying. Also, the web service is somewhat buggy, and I had problems deleting some older files. However, if you're looking for a good, cheap solution to MobileMe file synchronization, then you might want to give Mesh a try.

Categories

Software MobileMe

[Editor's Note: Several comments objected to the comparison between Dropbox and Microsoft that implied Dropbox's reputation was less than...
 

Add a Comment

*0 / 3000 Character Maximum

55 Comments

Filter by:
Jim Schlight

So I clicked on the link in the original post and landed on a Microsoft page with the message "The Windows Live Network is unavailable..." Oh, well. So much for dealing with a "reputable company with a longer track record".

Can someone give one example of a network-based offering from Microsoft that has ever worked well on the Mac?

November 29 2008 at 4:22 PM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply
Macmonster

I to have tried multiple cloud types of services such as .MacMobile Me, Mozy and Dropbox. I also work off of multiple PC's and Mac's and share a lot of items with others. Dropbox has performed flawlessly so far and I am seriously looking at plunking down another $99 so that I can bypass another external hard disk issue encountered recently.

I just need to wait and hopefully Apple will pay Dropbox a bunch of cash to repackage themselves as iDisk and I will be very happy.

One thing that will be a minus for Mesh is that folks will not want to deal with the Live ID and the complicated nature of this all in one ID for Microsoft. I have to use it for work but try to avoid it at home.

November 29 2008 at 1:37 AM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply
samsonsu

one other advantage of mesh over dropbox is, you can sync files just among your computers and without leaving a copy on the cloud (5gb mesh storage). so if you have 12gb music and want to sync them between computers, it'll just work as long as you exclude mesh desktop (the cloud storage) from the list of devices.

with dropbox, everything has to be synch'ed with cloud, makes it impractical for data over 2gb.

November 27 2008 at 3:09 PM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply
Chad

Quite ironic. The author trashes Dropbox's reputability, yet he likes MS Office for Mac. In my opinion, Cory has no reputability and is just another reason why people only come here to rag on TUAW. And I thought things would improve when Erica left.

November 27 2008 at 11:51 AM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply
Erwin Dink

As a long time .Mac user who has four different computers, most of which need access to the same data, Dropbox is an iDisk killer. I hesitated at spending the extra money (I outgrew the free 2G limit in a few days) for something that is supposed to be included in my .Mac service but Dropbox works so flawlessly, so easily, so reliably and, so quickly that I now would rather give up .Mac than Dropbox if I couldn't afford to keep both.

November 27 2008 at 10:26 AM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply
isky

this is a REVIEW?

November 27 2008 at 10:04 AM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply
waiphyo

Agree with @Doctt.

We have been quite pessimistic about M$ Products for a long time. But this time, I think LiveMesh is a simply good service. It just works. Apart from some hiccups such as versioning or IE woes, MS put great effort in this thing.

APIs are also there. .NET developers are cheering. I dunno if you guys like iPlayer but I saw some neat synchronization there. And heard many more services are on the way, using LiveMesh.

I love Dropbox and use it everyday. It's a fantastic service. Well but, we should really give LiveMesh a try, too. =)

November 27 2008 at 7:38 AM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply
James

This article was the point at which I subscribed to TUAW. Any weblog
which considers opinion "blogging" like this to be acceptable is worth
my time.

November 27 2008 at 4:31 AM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply
Max

I can't sign up for Live Mesh. Says its wants more info from me, sends me to my WindowsLive page, but there is nothing to change. Oh, and it tells me to use IE 6 or higher.

THIS is why I use dropbox. It just works, on mac or PC, within seconds of downloading it.

November 26 2008 at 8:14 PM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply
sriggins

Dropbox seems pretty damn nice and if it is running on S3, I'd take that over Microsoft any day.

Microsoft offerings have always been half-baked on the Mac. Dropbox seems very mac friendly.


November 26 2008 at 7:56 PM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply
Buy an ad here

Hot Apps on TUAW

Tweets

© 2012 AOL Inc. All Rights Reserved.