Found Footage: A fanboy's Mac mini concept
TUAW reader, designer, and Mac mini fanboy Sait Alayali decided that it's time for a new look, so he created his own conceptual design for a new mini. Rather than the little flat box we know and love, it's designed like a right angle. It has a low-speed fan for quiet and effective cooling, a design that makes it simple to swap out drives, and it can be placed on a surface in a number of ways.
Call me old-fashioned, but I like the "boxy" look of the existing Mac mini. They're easier to stack and there are plenty of matching peripherals. I'd prefer to see a new Mac mini made with some of the MacBook Air tech so it could be thinner and smaller. How 'bout you? Leave a comment with your ideas for a new Mac mini design.
The New Mac Mini Concept from Sait Alanyali on Vimeo.
Share
Categories
The Mac mini has an amazing following. It's a great machine for switchers who want to use their existing keyboard, mouse, and monitor,...
Add a Comment
What about a MacMini/Apple TV child?
December 15 2008 at 8:23 PM Report abuse Permalink rate up rate down ReplyIf the front surface was an aux display with touch, maybe, but as it is written so shall it hopefully never be done. Personally I'd like a same 6.5 inch square form factor but 1 inch thick. And mini-Displayport takes care of the multiple display issue. What you didn't know they could daisy chain displays? Well, no one makes a compatible display setup yet but it is in the spec. And a Mini driving a 30 inch display would be awesome. I also want the Apple auxillary touch display as well. I tried running on my Xenarc as a secondary display but the touch drivers for it don't like that mode. But the 7 inch widescreen makes a sweet mac mini setup. And yes. We use mac minis in custom cases in racks, 8 to a 4U shelf in our server farms. So the proposed design would hose all those like us who still are waiting for a Apple blade system (and with the recent IBM Apple hiring snafu Apple is unlikely to even step close to that for a while, a long while...)
December 15 2008 at 5:53 PM Report abuse Permalink rate up rate down ReplyBad Idea but a grate way to Fup one of the best selling points of the mac mini.
December 15 2008 at 4:40 PM Report abuse Permalink rate up rate down ReplySait,
NICE WORK!!!
Keep it up!
As for the rest of you: Keep discouraging people from sharing their creativity, because what the world really needs right now are more critics and less visionaries. Wait did I forget the sarcasm tag?
Dave
Your Dumb
Here is how sharing works.
You share an idea then people say GOOD or BAD and you learn from it.
Oh and if they are not nice about how they say BAD, to bad get over it.
And I wanted to say, I don't know if there are any product designers here, but as a product designer I like to try new things. Of course I can take the actual mac mini look, give it a new macbook-appletv kind of look, make it a little bit smaller, etc. But that wouldn't be my design, would it? :) The people at Apple would do it, because it's their design.
There are a lot of redesigns, just by rounding the edge or changing the color, etc... You get the idea. I think the concept of 'conceptual design' is creating new things, sharing experiences, opening minds... A designer who had spent all his/her life designing cars is an experienced car designer, knows all the rules, but a designer who never designed a car but drives a lot, could see a lot of things and could come up with new ideas. This is what I did with this concept. I would be happy to discuss the problems you see in the design. Thanks...
I knew when I put the Apple logo on this design, Iâd get some rough comments :) Iâll try to give some answers if I can.
First of all, Iâm a huge Apple fan, I love them. And specially Iâm not trying to copy or suggest a design. Iâm not saying my design is better than the current Mac Mini design. Iâve been using my Mac Mini 7/24 for the last 5-6 years and as a very devoted customer I think I have the right to say what is right or what is wrong âfor meâ with the actual design. With the Macworld coming up and the new mac mini rumors around, I thought, why not design my own kind of mac mini? Itâd be fun! The whole process took approximately a week, because designing concept computers is not my job -itâs just for fun and learning- and If Iâd spent 2-3 months and submitted the new mac mini design after the new one, it would be just cheating Iâd be very very inspired after I saw the new one. So, yes, itâd be much much better If Iâd spent more than a week on this concept, but itâs pretty detailed for a weekâs job with all the price, size, dimensions, heating, etc. research.
The airflow had some bad comments, people asking me why I didn't put the fans at the bottom of the legs and dissipate the heat with vents from the top. It's a simple physics law, isn't it? But the thing most of these people aren't thinking is, this is a multi-positioned computer. And if you put fans on the legs, it wouldn't be 2 fans. It would be 4 or more fans! Because fans are circular shaped objects, the diameter of the fan should be smaller from the depth of the leg. And because the depth of the legs are so short, the fans would be ridiculously small! So one fan wouldn't be enough, there would be four fans, maybe more. And the most important part is, there are three, maybe more positions you can put a computer like this, and all of them are equally practical for their own purpose, and the airflow design is the best like this for all three positions, believe me I tried a lot :)
For the port reaching problem, the V shape has the advantage of putting your hand&fingers from both sides and especially âseeingâ them while you plug-in the cables or sticks. If your desk arrangement doesnât allow it, you can lift the front and see the ports. You can not do this with the actual design. With the actual mac mini, while itâs a great product, I canât see the USB ports when I try to plug a usb device. Iâd always have to check the direction of the port, the cable, feel the port, try to plug it. And because Iâm a very tidy person, I donât like the cable mess on or under my table so I hide them, tie them, then if I want to pull the mini a little bit closer, some cables unplug with the tension and I have a problem. With the ports facing front, this accident can not happen.
I got some advice from some electronic and computer engineer friends and an Apple expert friend during the process. The HDMI port, the extra HDD, power brick inside, all of them are for pushing some limits and trying to be different. They could be done or not, if you like we can discuss it and we all would learn something. But donât do the âthis is crap, you idiot, this is useless, stupid, pointless designâ , please. Iâd love to see more and more concepts about mac mini and learn from them.
The design is not totally Apple looking because I didnât want it to be a total Apple copycat. If I made it boxed shaped, than a lot people say, the same old boring box shaped Apple design, so whatâs new with you?
Again, itâs not âbetterâ than the current design. Itâs âbetter for meâ than the current design. I spent lot and lots of hours on this, I wish people didn't spend 3 minutes and judge it without thinking all the details. Itâs just a concept, a visual expression of my imagination and my experiences with the product. Thanks for all the comments⦠:)
I love the idea (unlike most people here). However I feel that there is a flaw in the design. Heat rises, it doesnt go down. So if there was a way for the heat to go up you would see better airflow.
December 15 2008 at 3:17 PM Report abuse Permalink rate up rate down ReplyGlad you liked it. I tried to explain the airflow but let me try again :) This is a multi-position computer concept. So, it does not stay like the flipped V position on the picture above all the time. It also has vertical and horizontal positions. So I thought of all the positions and come with the best airflow design I could. If you use it horizontal or vertical, then the heat rises by itself, fan and the heat sink. But if you use it like this, it doesn't? It does because of two reasons. 1- There's a heat sink -you can see in the video- that canalizes the air to the air holes. 2- This is a very very small computer, if it was an Mac Pro, the heat rises rule would be considered but this is smaller than the actual mac mini, the fan and the heat sink could easily dissipate the heat.
Thanks again :)
I'd like to see a larger Mac Mini that has a standard sized drive in it that is easy to replace, and HDMI out. What I'd really like is a Apple TV that also is a full Macintosh, with 1TB of storage. I'd use if for the house iTunes and video repository, and occasionally for surfing from the couch.
December 15 2008 at 1:46 PM Report abuse Permalink rate up rate down ReplyApple should do with the mini, what they did with the Mac Pro.
Have a base model and be able to configure the hell out of it at the online store.
2.0GHz Intel Core 2 Duo with 256MB NVIDIA GeForce 9400M
or
2.4GHz Intel Core 2 Duo with 512MB NVIDIA GeForce 9600M
2 or 4 GB of RAM
1 or 2 Displays
1 or 2 2.5" Drives (SATA or SSD)
Optical Drive (optional)
Use MacBook Air parts in the mini? You have got to be kidding, do you want the mini to be more overpriced and underpowered than it already is?
December 15 2008 at 1:00 PM Report abuse Permalink rate up rate down ReplyHot Apps on TUAW
Deals of the Day
more deals- Verizon Leather Sleeve for Tablets for $4 + free shipping
- Wicked Jaw Breaker Noise-Isolating In-Ear Headphones for $6 + free shipping
- Refurb Apple MacBook Air Laptops: 12" 64GB SSD for $699 + free shipping
- JVC Motion Sensing Clock Radio with Dual iPod Docks for $55 + free shipping
- Apple iPhone Headset with Mic for $4 + $2 s&h
- Refurb Apple iPod nano 8GB MP3 Player for $99 + free shipping, 16GB for $119
Software Updates
more updates- EFI Firmware Update brings Lion Internet Recovery to 2010-model Macs
- OS X Lion 10.7.3 released with Safari 5.1.3, Wi-Fi bug fix
- Aperture updated to 3.2.2, addresses Photo Stream issue
- Apple updates Keynote to address Lion issues
- Google Search app gets new look on iPad
- Apple releases Apple TV Software Update 4.4.3



37 Comments