TUAW Review: Scrabble for iPhone
Hasbro's Scrabble is a classic board game, and Electronic Arts made the crossword game one of the first releases for the iPhone / iPod touch platform. Although the game has been available since July, I decided to wait to review it until some of the early bugs were squashed and new features were added. Since Scrabble is a holiday favorite for families, it's the perfect time for a review of the game.
The original board game is played with 100 small hardwood tiles, most of which have a letter of the alphabet and a point value printed on them. The playing board is a 15 by 15 grid with some squares marked as double or triple letters or words. The object, to those few people who have never played the game, is to create words from a rack of letters randomly assigned to you.
Points are assigned per word based on the individual point values of the tiles and whether a letter or word overlays a colored multiplier square. After the first word has been placed on the board, subsequent words must touch another word in crossword puzzle fashion.
The iPhone game, available in the App Store (click opens iTunes) for US$4.99, follows the rules of the board game to the letter (no pun intended).
When the app is launched, players are directed to a settings screen that provides a choice of Quick Play, Multiplayer mode (requires multiple players on the same Wi-Fi network), custom play (playing against the computer, against others in "pass and play mode", or solo), options for music and sound effects, and statistics on your play.
Most players, given the amount of time many people have to play games, are going to want to select the Quick Play mode against the iPhone. Believe it or not, the iPhone is a formidable opponent when you're playing Scrabble! In my first ten games, I won only one game without using the "Best Word" assistance that is built into the game.
The graphics in this game are excellent. The board is true to the Scrabble Crossword Game and the pieces look amazingly realistic. If you select a fake word like KWYJIBO or otherwise break any of the other rules of the game, you are properly chastised (and the Scrabble police will also block you from using profanity or ethnic slurs, so don't bother trying).
I hate to say this, but the music in this game sounds like the soundtrack to an adult movie -- not that I'd know what that sounds like... It gets kind of annoying after a very short time, so fortunately there is an option to turn off the music. Unfortunately, you can't substitute your iTunes music for the soundtrack -- the double-press of the home button to call up the mini-Music controls works as it does in other apps, but as soon as you close it Scrabble mutes your song playback.
Scrabble provides an aid in those cases where you can't think of a good word to put on the board -- it's called Best Word, and it uses the built-in word dictionary and the logic used by your computer opponent to determine the highest point value word from a particular rack of tiles. You only get to use the Best Word assistance four times during a normal game, but it can often make the difference between winning and losing against the computer opponent.
Are there any annoyances with Scrabble? Well, it does suck the batteries down if you're playing in multiplayer mode for any length of time. The tiles can sometimes be hard to "grab" with your finger to move into place. Finally, it would be good to have an onboard copy of the Scrabble dictionary to check some of the words that are provided by the game. Not that I think my iPhone is cheating, but some of its word choices seem to be questionable.
What's your favorite board game for the iPhone? Let us know in the comments section. Be sure to check out the gallery below for dazzling color screenshots of this game.
Share
Categories
Hasbro's Scrabble is a classic board game, and Electronic Arts made the crossword game one of the first releases for the iPhone / iPod...
Add a Comment
I love this app! I just saw a sweet demo of it here:
http://tinyurl.com/capk7g
I live in the UK, but managed to set myself up with a US itunes account, then paid for app with US vouchers purchased via ebay. LOVE scrabble.
Best word should have option for disable.
Incorrect word should have option to LOSE your go. (currently you must recall letters, click pass and confirm, relying on honesty when playing with mate !)
I wish this linked up with Facebook Scrabble :(
January 10 2009 at 6:43 AM Report abuse Permalink rate up rate down ReplyMattel doesn't seem to be interested in making a iPhone version of Scrabble for the markets it has the rights to unlike Hasbro/EA who have done many.
January 01 2009 at 2:45 PM Report abuse Permalink rate up rate down ReplyIt's very disappointing that you can only buy it if you have a U.S. based credit card/apple account. What's up with THAT?
December 30 2008 at 1:26 PM Report abuse Permalink rate up rate down ReplyLove this game. It's got problems, but I'm usually just killing a few minutes here and there. For me, it's just about perfect for a mobile Scrabble game.
agreed ... this is a great app ... not perfect, but few apps are. great review!
December 29 2008 at 2:49 PM Report abuse Permalink rate up rate down ReplyI think this is a wonderful implementation of Scrabble for the iPhone. In addition to the complaints registered above, note that PL and TL are used by the Scrabble program as legitimate words. They aren't -- I believe whoever programmed the list misread PI and TI. I've sent this in to the developers, but no joy.
I, too, wish the dictionary weren't "purged" -- like any censorship, it's completely arbitrary. "Shag", for example, isn't allowed, because of it's use in Britain. "Nazi", for some unknown reason, is also disallowed.
That said, I play this all the time. Highly recommended.
1. I've owned and used the game since it first came out with my iPod Touch. Many performance improvements have been made to the app. It launches faster and doesn't crash any more (for me), but still sucks battery power regardless of mode. Turning off wifi before play helps me get 2 hrs out of the app on a good day. Another improvement is the highlighting of tiles just played, and a calculation of the score your word would have (if it was accepted).
2. For me (and many others) the basic quick mode is too easy. I rarely lose to the AI. Unfortunately, the Hard mode is too hard for me. An intermediate level would be helpful. On the Mac version, those are the most enjoyable for me.
3. The dictionary this app uses is... odd. I have my doubts it is the real Scrabble dictionary, as several times it uses foreign words (which are supposed to be verbotten) or slang inconsistently (some recent words available, but other established ones not...). I'm bothered that many basic Hawaiin words are not included, but some more complex ones are (i.e. aa -> Hawaiian for Lava).
4. When a game ends, you get an announcement - then... nothing. No "play again" button. You have to manually go back to the opening screen. And if you want to play the advanced mode again, you can't just hit Quick Play and go, you have to go through the Custom Play settings. You should be able to select Hard level as your default, and quick play with that setting automatically.
5. The inability to play your own audio while playing is pathetic, and unacceptable for a company with the development resources that EA has. Double clicking the home button only temporarily brings your audio until you close the dialog box. Nobody should need a remote to get this to work, and my test with an audio remote did not work. I would be surprised if the buds really allow you to do audio, but I don't have them to check.
The reviews on the app store listing aren't glowing. Has it improved since those reviews were left?
December 28 2008 at 8:46 PM Report abuse Permalink rate up rate down ReplyI definitely recommend the game. Having said that, I think some of the things folks mentioned above would be trivial to address. I'm not sure why Hasbro hasn't. My biggest gripe is a small thing. You cannot stop the app from playing the start-up music even when you turn the game music off. I care because sometimes I play scrabble without earbuds in waiting rooms. Even if I set the volume all the way down before I start the app, it actually turns it back up on launch. Unbelievable! I don't get why Hasbro won't allow the start-up music to be silenced.
January 30 2009 at 5:13 PM Report abuse Permalink rate up rate down ReplyHot Apps on TUAW
Deals of the Day
more deals- Refurb Apple MacBook Air Laptops: 12" 64GB SSD for $699 + free shipping
- JVC Motion Sensing Clock Radio with Dual iPod Docks for $55 + free shipping
- Apple iPhone Headset with Mic for $4 + $2 s&h
- miFrame Picture Frame Dock for iPad for $64 + $8 s&h
- Refurb Apple iPod nano 8GB MP3 Player for $99 + free shipping, 16GB for $119
- Hannspree Apple-Shaped 28" 1080p LCD HDTV for $270 + free shipping
Software Updates
more updates- EFI Firmware Update brings Lion Internet Recovery to 2010-model Macs
- OS X Lion 10.7.3 released with Safari 5.1.3, Wi-Fi bug fix
- Aperture updated to 3.2.2, addresses Photo Stream issue
- Apple updates Keynote to address Lion issues
- Google Search app gets new look on iPad
- Apple releases Apple TV Software Update 4.4.3



30 Comments