Filed under: iPhone, App Store
A different kind of Voicemail
A new app for the iPhone has made its way to the App Store. VoiceMail, $0.99, lets you record a message and send it to a friend on a PC or Mac, or even on an iPhone. I tried the app several times and found it a frustrating experience. First, you click on 'send mail' and the app brings up a list of your contacts. You are still within the VoiceMail app, and if you have a long contact list, all you can do is scroll up or down. No shortcuts. You select the contact, and are instructed to add a short line of text. I entered 16 words, and got an error telling me the limit is 25 words. Grrrrrrr. I shortened my message, then proceeded to record a voice message. After hitting the' send' button I waited for it to go out. Then I waited some more. I noticed my network signal was dipping below 2 bars, so decided to quit. Unfortunately, there was no option to cancel. I forced quit the application and went back in. No sign of that message, so I had to start from scratch.
By this time, I was in a better signal area (4 bars, solid 3G) so I sent another message. This one succeeded, but it took 24 seconds to send a 4 second message. I don't think this app is designed for long, detailed voicemails. Maybe on Wi-Fi.
For further testing, I sent myself a message. It arrived in my mailbox, and it said if I wasn't on an iPhone to click on a URL to retrieve it. Well, I WAS on an iPhone, and saw no indication that there was an attachment to click on or listen to. There is an in box on the app, so I checked there, and hit the refresh button. No message there either. In desperation, I clicked on the URL and got a web page with no way to listen to a message. Grrrrr.
Checking at home, I used my desktop Mac and clicked on the URL. There was an embedded Quicktime control, so I clicked on it. No audio played. Odd. I even checked the message before I sent it and could hear it loud and clear. I tried this on 2 messages. No audio on either. Grrrrrr.
Time for a check with the developer's support site. I clicked on the link at the App Store and was taken to a web page that simply had a link to take me back to the App Store. Grrrrr.
This looks like another App Store submission that Apple never tested. Some apps do get rejected, often for arcane reasons, but it implies at least they were looked at. This app, if anybody ever tested it, would have been killed outright.
Voicemail seems to favor sending these voice messages to iPhones, but why do that? iPhones have voicemail. You can send to a PC or Mac, but the receiving computer needs Quicktime. The developers say they'll add MP3 playback. Maybe so, but that won't solve the myriad other problems. It's almost like every time the developers had a decision to make, they went down the wrong path.
The idea behind this app has merit. It just has zero utility in its current form. The GUI is slow. The recording of messages is picky because you have to speak very softly or you get gross distortion. Transmitting the messages is slow. All that would be forgivable if the app worked, but I could not listen to a message sent to a desktop machine or my iPhone. It didn't work when I sent messages to friends either.
Other than that, VoiceMail is terrific. Grrrrrr.
Get a WordPress.com Blog
![TUAW [Cafepress]](http://www.blogsmithmedia.com/www.tuaw.com/media/tuaw-cafepress-promo.png)
Reader Comments (Page 1 of 1)
kakapo said 3:05PM on 3-11-2009
Obviously there is no Quality Assurance in the decision making process of which Apps make it into the wild.
As lovely as the App Store is and yes, I have purchased a few apps; I feel Apple is shooting itself in the foot by not having a standardised programme for submission, evaluation, acceptance and/or rebuild and reapply, pricing and finally arriving into our hot little iTunes App Store...
It may be headed to a billion dollar business but it may also start getting one off buyers and the market is finite. As big as it seems, it is finite.
This app sounds like it is still in sub-Alpha in development.
Reply
cynyc said 3:20PM on 3-11-2009
I'm using Note2Self, both for voice notes and for emailing voicemails to others (or myself). Works flawlessly. It's $1.99, but worth it.
Reply
JC said 3:26PM on 3-11-2009
** NEWSFLASH! **
Another 99 cent app is flaming pile of s***
Reply
Chris G said 3:58PM on 3-11-2009
For Iphone users, try out Slydial as well. I love this service when I don't have time to talk but want to leave a voice mail.
Also, try Broadcast if you need to send the same message to multiple people at a time. I have 3 retail stores and I oversee all IT as well. Broadcast allows me to send out voice mails to different groups based off what the issue might be without calling them all individually.
Reply
JKT said 5:42PM on 3-11-2009
It's amazing to me to read this review only a day after the whole Tweetie debacle. Apple seems more afraid of the F-bomb than quality. They'll reject an app in a heartbeat for a "bad word" but won't spend 5 minutes assuring an app actually does what it claims to. Sorry guys, but I have a serious problem when debatable morals trump fraud.
Reply