Filed under: Software, Video, Open Source
First Look: Video Monkey swings in to save the day
When Techspansion closed its doors in October of last year, there were hordes of individuals clamoring for a slice of easy video-conversion pie to fill the void in their now-empty hearts. Many did not find consolation in the fact that Handbrake supported universal input within a scant two months. An application that offers every configuration option available is all well and good for many fine folks; but there are some of us that want this type of thing to be simple. What I and others desired so greatly was a video-conversion app for the rest of us -- and that application was VisualHub.
Enter Video Monkey. Following the release of Tyler's source code for VisualHub as the TranscoderRedux project, one lone soul, named Chris, decided to brave the trepid waters and save all of us from drowning in a sea of videos awaiting conversion for our iPhones and AppleTVs.
Chris makes it perfectly clear that Video Monkey's mission is inspired by, and borrowed from, Visual Hub. However, while Visual Hub relied heavily on AppleScript, Video Monkey is written exclusively in Cocoa. After Chris got in touch with TUAW, I got right to work checking out this holy grail of simple video-conversion applications. Read on for my first impressions and initial thoughts or just check out the gallery.
In the application's toolbar is a button labeled "Show Movie" which provides a nice preview window ensuring you grabbed the correct file. The preview window seems to contain some as-yet-to-be implemented functionality for selecting a clip from the previewed video and only encoding that selection to get a sample of the output. When this functionality is implemented (or fixed) it will be incredibly handy for testing the quality settings and providing an easily-distributed sample of the encoded work.
The section below the grid will seem oddly familiar to VideoHub converts; but rest easy folks, the devil is in the pudding, or something. There is a drop-down list of items to which Video Monkey can convert. Currently it is limited to Apple-specific devices but as you can see from viewing the list, Chris plans to add more in the future.
The quality slider is a nifty little one-trick pony that allows the user to adjust, you guessed it, the quality of the output file created by Video Monkey. Rather than having five separate options on the slider, as VisualHub did, Video Monkey allows the user to dynamically move the slider to any point along the line. While making these changes Video Monkey updates the output file size, frame size, bitrate and audio quality to show the user exactly what the slider affects when it is moved.
Similar to VisualHub, Video Monkey supports H.264 encoding as well as Dolby surround tracks for the Apple TV-owners in the crowd. Also similar to VisualHub, Video Monkey allows you to select from a pre-determined list of actions you would like accomplished when Video Monkey completes its encoding task. My personal favorite is the "Add to iTunes and delete from destination" so I don't end up filling my hard drive with duplicates of miscellaneous video files option.
Video Monkey is a available now and is currently at a very fresh 0.1 release. However, Chris has plans to keep the project rolling and would love for people to submit issues and provide help. Apart from just general Cocoa-development any expertise in XML-crafting and database-scraping would also be of great benefit. In the future Chris plans to add DVD creation as well as support for other output devices. Right now, however, color me impressed with this little monkey!
Get a WordPress.com Blog
![TUAW [Cafepress]](http://www.blogsmithmedia.com/www.tuaw.com/media/tuaw-cafepress-promo.png)


Reader Comments (Page 1 of 2)
Kevin said 12:47PM on 3-16-2009
It would be nice if you made a link to the software being reviewed. I find I frequently have to look hard in your articles to find the link I'm after.
Reply
duke said 12:58PM on 3-16-2009
I agree with Kevin, and TUAW are not alone in doing this, but Blog posts sometimes seem to forget the fundamentals, full of links but missing the real details!
Aron Trimble said 1:00PM on 3-16-2009
Actually, the Source link at the bottom of the post links to the Video Monkey website.
Michael said 1:00PM on 3-16-2009
I agree with Kevin. It would also be nice if you could put SOME of the photos inline with the text instead of in a separate gallery.
Reply
Photo Tim said 1:03PM on 3-16-2009
Well it looks nice but doesn't do anything. I've tried drag and drop and 'Add' an .avi, .mpg, & .wmv and it doesn't.
Reply
brackintosh said 1:10PM on 3-16-2009
I was experiencing the same problem. Then I switched to AppleTV in the Convert To: field and it accepted my test file.
Joseph Crawford said 1:30PM on 3-16-2009
You have to first select a format, such as iPod Touch. Looks like a bug to me as I had the same issue.
chris said 3:33PM on 3-16-2009
Video Monkey is very new. I'm surprised it did nothing with your dragged files. You need to drag them into the File List View or onto the icon in the Dock. Or you can select Add and select one of more files from the File Dialog. If it doesn't understand the format it should put a little red X next to it.
If none of this helps, please send me a sample so I can see what the problem might be.
timelawd said 1:05PM on 3-16-2009
the interface looks a lot like SWITCH. Straaange ....
Reply
Joseph Crawford said 1:30PM on 3-16-2009
AFAIK: They are in violation of Apples terms. They are using an icon for the iphone/ipod touch.
I thought doing this was in violation of the TOS from Apple. or is that *only* iconified artwork?
Reply
colouroflight said 3:43PM on 3-16-2009
Does anyone care?
Joseph Crawford said 4:12PM on 3-16-2009
I guess Apple does because they are declining apps for the app store because they used an iphone icon.
superberg said 1:46PM on 3-16-2009
No cheat codes, no sale.
Reply
iGO said 1:47PM on 3-16-2009
I expect Video Monkey development to continue, and to someday soon, deliver what VisualHub delivers today.
Keep up the good work !
In the meantime, I'm extremely grateful to have my perfectly working copy of VisualHub, which is one of my most used applications.
Reply
Chris said 1:54PM on 3-16-2009
I'd like to contact this guy to thank him. VisualHub was a great resource for the Mac community, I am very grateful he is taking this on!
-Chris
Reply
Jamus said 2:32PM on 3-16-2009
Keep up the good work.
Reply
matt said 3:03PM on 3-16-2009
All you people do is complain. Google is your friend. VISUAL HUB RIP!!!
Reply
Photo Tim said 3:04PM on 3-16-2009
Ok, got it working but it's insanely slow. I know it's beta and all that, just saying.
Reply
Phil said 3:21PM on 3-16-2009
This is working great for me, I can convert FLV files from Vimeo now which VisualHub didn't allow.
One question, is the AVI support coming soon? I can only get it to work with ALL APPLE DEVICES + H264 which is fine for my current needs but I do need to go between formats.
If I am missing something please advise.
Reply
chris said 3:34PM on 3-16-2009
This is Chris, the developer of Video Monkey. I just wanted to clear a couple of things up. First, the When Done: popup is not implemented yet. I will disable it (or implement it :-) in the next release. Same goes for the Apple TV "Keep Surround Track" feature.
I will look into the "need to first select a Convert To: device" bug. But please feel free to post bugs an comments on the Video Monkey SF forum:
https://sourceforge.net/forum/?group_id=244296
Reply