TUAW's review of the DroboPro, plus a discount deal for readers
Data Robotics delivered their "super-sized" version of the Drobo earlier this year. DroboPro has 8 drive bays into which you can drop 3.5" SATA drives of almost any capacity, from the old 160 GB model you've been using to hold the backup of your iTunes library to that 2 TB Western Digital Caviar drive you just purchased. Using a proprietary storage technology called BeyondRAID, Data Robotics makes it easy to use a DroboPro to give you a big box 'o storage right now, and easily expand in the future.
Data Robotics recently lent me a DroboPro for a detailed review, and I was able to give it a thorough workout. Read on to find out more about the DroboPro and an excellent deal available to readers of TUAW.
The DroboPro itself is attractive and is designed to sit on a desktop, although you can purchase option rack "wings" to mount the device in any standard 19" rack. There are no special power requirements, so you just plug a single AC cord into an outlet or UPS and you're ready to go. I know that this will probably drive a number of the system admins in our midst absolutely nuts, since they want redundancy for everything. If the lack of a second power supply is of critical importance to you, then you may wish to consider a more traditional RAID system.
In a phone discussion with Mark Fuccio, Senior Director of Products & Markets at Data Robotics, Mark mentioned that the concept of BeyondRAID is that you basically just buy what you need storage-wise to start out, mixing and matching drives, and then add more drives or swap them out for larger capacity drives later. He estimates that they're offering 95% of the functionality of a traditional RAID setup at about 10% of the initial price. For people who really need that last 5% of functionality (for example, fiber channel interface for video work), they're going to need to look at another and more traditional solution.
Looking at the front of the DroboPro, you can see 8 drive bays, each with a locking lever and door. As with the Drobo, there's no need to put the drives into any special carrier -- you just push the bare drives into the DroboPro, connector-first, until the locking lever springs up into place. Each locking lever has a large LED on the front of it that defines the status of the drive. A green light indicates that the system is healthy, a yellow light warns you that you should add another drive or replace an existing drive with one with more capacity, a flashing green/yellow light is telling you that an important system function is underway and that you should not remove the drive, a red light indicates that you should add another drive (you usually only see this when the DroboPro is completely empty), and a flashing red light denotes an emergency situation where you have a drive failure occurring.
By the way, if you're like me and there's more than one way to put a drive into a DroboPro, you will. That's OK, because the drive won't go all the way into the bay, and the light won't go on. Just pull it back out, put it back in the correct way, and you're on your way to storage goodness.
There are other LEDs as well, making the DroboPro as colorful as a Christmas tree when it's busy. At the bottom of the right side of the case as you're looking at the DroboPro from the front, there are power and activity lights. When the DroboPro is in normal operation, the power light is a steady green, and the activity light will flicker to indicate read/write activity. Also on the right side of the case is a stack of blue LEDs that are used to visually indicate the relative capacity used in the array.
On any Mac or Windows PC that you're using with the DroboPro, you should install the Drobo Dashboard. This is a piece of software that is used to monitor and control the DroboPro. Just after turning on the DroboPro and pushing in the first drive, Drobo Dashboard warned me that a new firmware update was available. With one click, it downloaded and installed the firmware update, even restarting the DroboPro in the process. Drobo Dashboard also provides warnings of critical or important situations. For example, after I pushed in the first drive (a Western Digital 500 GB drive), the software warned me that the drives did not appear to be formatted. Instead of just warning me, Drobo Dashboard also provided a simple choice to format the drive (see below).

Drobo supports several file systems, including HFS+, NTFS, FAT32, and Linux EXT3. For Mac users, you'll most likely want to use HFS+, and the Drobo setup options (see below) gently nudge you in that direction:



Drobo Dashboard has a Tools pane that is extremely useful for anyone who is administering one or more Drobo devices. As you can see in the screenshot below, you can do everything from blink the lights on a Drobo (useful if you're trying to find a specific device in a crowded server room), to renaming the Drobo or the individual volumes on it. Advanced controls also provide the way to shut down the device gracefully or add or delete volumes.

Mark Fuccio pointed out that the maximum capacity of SATA drives tends to double every 18 months or so. That means that we're nearing the point where 3 TB 3.5" SATA drives are going to be available, which translates to a larger maximum capacity for the DroboPro. The theoretical maximum capacity for DroboPro is 16x16 TB volumes, or about a quarter of a petabyte! Of course, we'd need to have 32 TB 3.5" SATA drives to reach that capacity...
DroboPro provides three different connectivity options; USB 2.0, Firewire 800, and iSCSI. While the first two options are familiar to most Mac users, iSCSI is something relatively new. iSCSI uses a Gigabit Ethernet connection and a software "initiator" to create a high-speed connection between the Mac and DroboPro. With many high-end RAID setups, fiber connections are the norm, requiring a significant outlay for fiber switches, adapter cards, and cables. iSCSI only requires a standard Ethernet cable.
What's cool about iSCSI is that you can use it several different ways. If you're just connecting one DroboPro to one Mac, you can make a straight cable connection between the two devices. If you want to connect a group of DroboPros to a Mac, you can connect the DroboPros to a Gigabit Ethernet switch on the same subnet, and then use the Drobo Dashboard software to assign each DroboPro a specific IP address.
I did a few tests just to see how fast the DroboPro was. Connected to my iMac over USB 2.0, copying a large user folder (16.56 GB) took 28 minutes, 30 seconds, at a rate of about .58 GB / minute. Now it was time to test iSCSI on the iMac.
Somehow, I expected this to be more difficult than it was. Since I had just installed Drobo Dashboard on the iMac, I ran the included Ethernet cable between the iSCSI port on the back of the DroboPro and the Gigabit Ethernet port on my iMac, and within a few seconds, the DroboPro had nicely self-configured itself and appeared on my iMac desktop. The same copy done over iSCSI took only 12 minutes, 8 seconds, or about 1.34 GB / minute -- 2.3 times faster than with USB 2.0. The moral of this story? If you want fast copy speeds, use iSCSI -- it's easy to set up and it's much faster than USB. As my iMac doesn't have a Firewire 800 port, I did not test Firewire connectivity. Also note that these are very unscientific tests, and your transfer speeds will vary depending on your specific setup.
Now came the fun part. One of the cool things about the Drobo and DroboPro is that you can add or yank drives while the device is working, so I decided to copy some other huge files to the DroboPro and plug a drive in while it was happening. Other than fumbling the drive installation, since I was doing it with one hand while holding a camcorder in the other, nothing happened. The drive just became a part of the array. By this point, I had added three of the four 1 TB drives to the initial 500 GB drive. According to Drobo Dashboard, this meant that I had about 2.21 TB available storage. Dashboard showed that I had 3.50 TB of drives installed, with a real capacity of 3.16 TB, and with 993.85 GB of storage being used for protection and another 4.07 GB for overhead.
If you want to see just how much capacity you can add to a DroboPro with a mix of existing and new drives that you may have laying around the office, you can use the Capacity Calculator for DroboPro. Just drag drives of varying capacity to the calculator, and you'll see just how much usable capacity you'll have available.
The next fun test was to start up a TV episode M4V playback in QuickTime X, then pull a drive at random out of the DroboPro. The playback continued smoothly, but the remaining drive lights began to flash yellow and green, which (as good students, you should remember this) meant that the other drives should not be removed. Drobo Dashboard had a "Data Protection In Progress" message with a progress indicator showing that protection (making sure that the data on the removed drive was properly copied to the remaining drives) would take about another 30 minutes.
One thing that's different about the DroboPro compared to its older, but smaller sibling is that it can be set up through Drobo Dashboard for RAID 6 dual disk redundancy. That means that whenever you have three or more drives installed in the device, you can turn on the option to allow the DroboPro to recover from two failed or removed drives at once. This isn't difficult to do -- it's a single-click option in Drobo Dashboard. This reduces the amount of usable space in the array, but is a great option for the ultra-paranoid user. While the DroboPro is in the process of setting up the dual disk redundancy (it took 42 minutes with four 1 TB drives and one 500 GB drive), you are reminded to not remove any of the drives. Mark Fuccio of Data Robotics recommended setting up the DroboPro for dual disk redundancy before moving any data to the array.
The DroboPro works well with Time Machine. If you have a number of people who are backing up their Macs to a central server or machine with an attached DroboPro, you can actually divide the space into up to 16 Smart Volumes, all of which can grow to a maximum capacity as the amount of Time Machine data increases over time.
My overall impression of the DroboPro is that it is a flexible, inexpensive, and ridiculously easy-to-use mass storage solution. I'm very tempted to take advantage of the DroboPro offer (see below) and get one of these for capturing all of the media that we have in our household, as well as having a big, redundant storage bin for Time Machine backups.
As an Apple Consultants Network member, I have a number of clients who have been using the original Drobo for expandable storage. The devices have been rock-steady for me, with no glitches or problems from the first day they were installed. I would have no qualms about recommending the DroboPro for my clients with larger storage requirements, and I plan on doing so when the opportunity arises.
The TUAW Deal
If you're intrigued by the DroboPro and want expandable, fast, and relatively inexpensive mass storage, we have a deal for you!
The price of a bare (no drives) DroboPro is US$1,499. Data Robotics has generously offered US$200 off of the price for up to 200 TUAW readers or 7 days, whatever comes first. All you need to do to take advantage of this offer is to use the code TUAW200 (all caps) when purchasing a DroboPro from the Data Robotics online store. Feel free to pass along this information and the coupon code to anyone who might be interested in a DroboPro. After all, it may be the last storage device they'll ever have to purchase!
Share
Categories
Enterprise Hardware Peripherals Features Reviews Deals Mac OS X Server
Data Robotics delivered their "super-sized" version of the Drobo earlier this year. DroboPro has 8 drive bays into which you can drop 3.5"...
Add a Comment
Yes, very strange that they don't allow public access to their support forums.
I really _want_ to like the Drobo, but I also would like to know what my options are if/when the device fails. If I knew that, would buy one immediately. Otherwise, I'll wait and see how the market matures...
Cy,
I have 2 Generation 2 Drobo's and from what I have read, if the unit itself fails, all you have to do is pull the drives from the original unit, get another unit and put the drives back in. You don't even have to put them in the same order. This is much better than when a conventional 4 drive RAID system's box dies and you have to send the drives out to be restored into a new system.
I will say that the data transfer speed of the Drobo works best for my use on FW800. I don't have the DroboPro to test the iSCSI, or the DroboShare to test the ethernet connection. I'm using FW800 to a server machine and sharing it to my other networked computers as a working drive for my digital radiographs. Works great since the files are not huge over my network.
I'm very much liking the idea of a Drobo, but the price seems very, very high. I'm sure they'd sell 10x as many at half the price.
Also, I'm not impressed by the speeds reported in this review:
0.58GB / minute over USB 2.0? That's only 83 Mbps (over an interface rated at 480 Mbps)
My aging PPC Powerbook can push more than that over 100Mb ethernet to a single drive.
And 1.34GB / minute over a gigabit link? That's only using 16% of the link capacity (OK, there's some overhead in there, but not *that* much).
For a target, 6 drives @ 20MB/s each ~= 1Gbps
(or in the un-conventional units of this review, 7.2GB / minute)
I'm not saying that a Drobo(Pro) is a bad thing, just that these numbers suggest that it's strengths are very much biased towards data integrity and convenience, rather than performance.
(with the caveat about how do you recover your data if it's the Drobo itself that lets you down)
What this article doesn't cover (and in fact most that I've read don't cover) is the actual performance of the drobopro, which to date is extremely sub-par. iSCSI does not work on PPC based machines (instant kernel panic) and FW800 and USB2 are very slow. This is NOT on par with the speed of real RAID6 units (BeyondRAID is very similar to RAID6). For the people who complain that there's no eSata connections don't worry, it wouldn't even come close to taking advantage of the speed so there's not much point in having one.
As for the dual drive redundancy options it has it's not much point to trust in your data being safe using a proprietary format like this. If something goes wrong with the drobopro kiss your data goodbye. There are ZERO options for data recovery with it's proprietary format. The drobopro is not a proper backup solution. If you have important data on it make sure and back it up somewhere else as well.
Beware of Drobo rebates!
I have the firewire 4 bay model i ordered 5 months ago and never received my $50 rebate, i have been talking to Drobo people and they initially said that I must have gotten the money and, now they are just straight up ignoring my calls and messages. Over $50 bucks I dont think causing me this much hassle is worth my negative review.
Drobos are pretty cool
September 05 2009 at 2:34 PM Report abuse Permalink rate up rate down ReplyFileMagnet's 10MB filesize limit is the only thing stopping me from buying it :(
September 05 2009 at 12:23 PM Report abuse Permalink rate up rate down ReplySad to say, I cannot buy from a company that restricts access to its support forum to buyers only. What are they hiding? Why can't I read how others are using their units to see if the Drobo will meet my specific needs?
September 05 2009 at 9:17 AM Report abuse Permalink rate up rate down ReplyDroboPro is just too expensive to be worth it. I can buy a Drobo (4-bay version of DroboPro), a DroboShare and a couple of 1TB hard drives from Amazon.
The DroboShare is a great device. I can connect up to two Drobo units to it and it allows me to run applications, like BitTorrent, DLNA streaming server, iTunes streaming server, etc. on the Drobo itself. I can then connect the DroboShare to my Airport Extreme and have a single-drive data-protected, standalone NAS with BitTorrent, DLNA and iTunes streaming capabilities. I can offload all my data, movies, music, documents, TimeMachine backups, etc. to the Drobo and all this information will be available to all the machine on my network.
I should also mention that DroboShare doesn't work with DroboPro, which is strange since DroboPro is much more expensive than Drobo.
Any troubles getting TimeMachine to work?
September 05 2009 at 12:31 PM Report abuse Permalink rate up rate down ReplyI still can't get over the fact that Data Robotics doesn't allow at least read only access to their support forums to non-drobo users.
As a potential purchaser of a Drobo, I want to read about the type of problems people are having and how Data Robotics responds. Instead, Data Robotics hides their problems unless you have already made a purchase.
Frankly, I find that unacceptable and a little shady.
-kpluck
I own a Drobo, and find this weird as well. At least read access.
September 05 2009 at 12:26 PM Report abuse Permalink rate up rate down ReplyI don't know... I've been using the original Drobo for a year now and it works like a charm. I can't see going with any other solution (unless fiber was required or some other special requirement). I've had a drive fail and never had an issue with the Drobo. I simply went out and purchased a new drive and plugged it in. Everything just kept working. Plus, Mark is simply a good guy. Yeah, that's not a great reason to buy Drobo stuff, but at some point, it's good to see the good guys come out on top! :) I'll never touch a TerraStation again (utter junk). I'm looking forward to a reason to purchase the Pro. Highly recommended.
Rob
Hot Apps on TUAW
Deals of the Day
more deals- JVC Motion Sensing Clock Radio with Dual iPod Docks for $55 + free shipping
- Apple iPhone Headset with Mic for $4 + $2 s&h
- miFrame Picture Frame Dock for iPad for $64 + $8 s&h
- Refurb Apple iPod nano 8GB MP3 Player for $99 + free shipping, 16GB for $119
- Hannspree Apple-Shaped 28" 1080p LCD HDTV for $270 + free shipping
- Philips wOOx Alarm Clock Radio for Apple iPod / iPhone for $60 + free shipping
Software Updates
more updates- EFI Firmware Update brings Lion Internet Recovery to 2010-model Macs
- OS X Lion 10.7.3 released with Safari 5.1.3, Wi-Fi bug fix
- Aperture updated to 3.2.2, addresses Photo Stream issue
- Apple updates Keynote to address Lion issues
- Google Search app gets new look on iPad
- Apple releases Apple TV Software Update 4.4.3



41 Comments