Skip to Content

The Bookmark App: Audiobooks finally done right

The Bookmark app [iTunes Link] has solved a number of problems I've always suffered while listening to audiobooks on an iPhone. It isn't pefect yet, but what is currently in the app store is the best implementation of digital audiobook listening I've found. It's earned a place on my home page and that alone is quite a recommendation. I'll get to a play-by-play in a bit, but first a bit of context is in order.

I have always been a fan of audiobooks. Long before the inception of the iPod, I was a constant Books on Tape customer. I'd choose a book and in a few days, receive a sizable box filled with anywhere from two to over forty cassette tapes. It was worth it to me to go through all the hassle of keeping the tapes in order and carrying a stack of them with me to play on a portable cassette player when I wasn't listening in my car.
When the iPod came out, I found Audible.com and life became much easier. I always carried at least a dozen books with me on my iPod Classic. The books usually downloaded in one or two big files making a book easy to manage. A few years later, Audible.com started embedding chapter markers in their books so jumping to a particular chapter was a snap, but I always had a problem with the iPod losing my place in a book. It could have been due to syncing, or being knocked around, but it was constant and always annoying.
When I bought my iPhone, I found the way the iPod module handled audiobooks had changed. Instead of downloading a few big files, what wound up in the library was a separate file for each chapter. So, for example, Fool by Christopher Moore, which my iPod Classic saw as one file with twenty-six chapters, appeared to be twenty-six files on the iPhone. That would have been fine, except for the fact that the iPhone was no better than my iPod Classic in losing my place seemingly at random. Worse, I never knew which file I was on when my place got lost.

Read on to see how Bookmark has solved this dilemma for me.

The Bookmark app solves this problem and does a whole lot more. For the very reasonable price of $2.99 any iPhone or iPod touch running iPhone OS 3.0 or better can get a full and multi-featured audiobook subsystem, and although it still needs some features, it's wonderful.

Instead of showing a bunch of chapter files, it brings back the long files downloaded from Audible.com. The app is meant to work with Audible or Librivox .aa or .m4a files. Librivox provides free public domain audiobooks.
Bookmark does many things, but to me the best part is setting it up to remember the farthest that you've reached in a book when exiting the app. When you restart, you are back in the same place. No more lost places. That alone is worth my $3.00, but that's just the start.

At any place in a book you can add a bookmark which will get you back to wherever you set it. The bookmark allows you to type information into it, acting as a reminder, and even email the bookmark to yourself (the default) or to anyone else, containing the name of the file and start time as well as any personal information you typed in. This is useful if, like me, you listen to books on a variety of devices; Mac, iPod Classic and iPhone. You can have as many bookmarks as you like per audio file. Free form notes can also be written and retrieved within the app. Additionally there is a time ribbon that lets you jump backward or forward in the file in increments of thirty seconds, or one, five, fifteen or thirty minutes.

Online is a complete tutorial showing you how everything works, from acquiring books to running all the features, but I found an undocumented treasure. If you're using Bookmark, and exit the app then go to iTunes to listen to some music on your iPhone, the next time you run Bookmark, regardless of what you were listening to in iTunes, you are back in your book at exactly the right place. It gets better. If you are listening to two or three books at a time, it remembers where you were in each book individually. With all this functionality getting lost in a book or a number of books is a thing of the past.
But for all the goodness there are a few problems. It handles each file separately, so at the end of a file, it stops. This is workable if you have a book with two seven hour files, but if you ripped an .mp3 with a ton of smaller files, every few minutes you'll have to go in and choose a new file making the app just about useless. Luckily, the developer is working on this and has indicated that soon all little files with the same book name will somehow get joined. Vague? Yes, but it's a known problem and will be solved in a revision coming in October or November. For now it's suggested that you use a program like Audiobook Builder for Macs or Audiobook Converter for Windows to convert groups of small files into one big file.
Bookmark doesn't work in the background, so you can't listen to a book while running another app. This is a major disadvantage, but not being a developer I don't know if it's possible to fix. Bookmark also ignores embedded bookmarks within the file, preventing you from being able to skip to the next chapter.

Even with these limitations, I can't recommend this app highly enough. It's as if the developer read my mind and gave me exactly what I wanted. That, for me, is a first. If you listen to audiobooks frequently, or have an Audible.com subscription, this is one app that you need. You can forget about the technology and just enjoy listening to a good book, and If that's not worth $2.99, I don't know what is.
Here's a video demonstrating the features of Bookmark.


The Bookmark app [iTunes Link] has solved a number of problems I've always suffered while listening to audiobooks on an iPhone. It isn't...
 

Add a Comment

*0 / 3000 Character Maximum

46 Comments

Filter by:
tamara

Just got ipod touch for audiobooks & I can't see anywhere to bookmark. It has chapters listed but there is no way to bookmark where you are. So if I shut off the ipod & turn it back on to listen later, its start back at the begining.

December 29 2010 at 4:56 PM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply
Gerald

Not available in Australian iTunes. That's a shame is looks great compared to other available apps. When I'm driving my car and miss a bit of the story or if my ipod bounces out of the FM transmitter cradle fumble and skip or accidently move the timeline.

December 10 2010 at 11:26 AM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply
Wry Cooter

The thing is, audible book bookmarking on the iPhone is inconsistant. Sure, it remembers the place if I simply stop listening and do something else on the iPhone, but where the wonkiness appears is SYNCING the iPhone, it will sometimes wish to jump to an earlier bookmark, or forget your place entirely.

And I'm not sure what variation is causing the bookmarks not to hold. The way I stop listening to Audiobooks on the iPhone? The particular File Format downloaded from Audible or iTunes? (I have audilble books through both, it seems that the ones direct from Audible might hold their bookmarks better. Is is iTunes pointing towards another Audible File Format?) Or it could just be what iTunes decides to sync during syncing; I most frequently sync for Podcast updates.

I'm about to Sync the iPhone, and this time, I used the notes app to write down exactly where I was in the book (bought on iTunes). We will see if any bookmarking holds where it should. It is often the case that a previous bookmark might come up instead. Maybe it is something like App Upgrades that sometimes pull an iPhone Back Up that is messing up the iPhone audio bookmarking, pulling up some previous spot in the book where I have stopped.

In a 28 hour book, bookmarking is important. It is an issue.

I have yet to see a proper troubleshooting of the problem.

November 27 2009 at 12:23 PM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply
1 reply to Wry Cooter's comment
cdbeshore

I second everything that bud says. It is a constant source of frustration when listening to podcasts and audiobooks. I am sick of it. I don't know where the problem originates, but I can't believe this has not been addressed by Apple.

December 30 2009 at 10:51 AM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply
deb.sites

I use an ipod nano and make my bookfiles be tagged as audiobooks. I put my book into a playlist and don't mind having tons of little files around but would love to have the little dot next to the file to indicate I have NOT listened to it (or in progress in half-full dot) like the podcasts do. I frequently go to sleep listening to a single cd playlist from a book, so having just one big file isn't as helpful for me as I have to "back up" but having that instant dot indication would be nice. i wouldn't even mind it on the songs but books would be helpful. does anyone know how to make this happen? the last played date doesn't show up on the ipod.

October 19 2009 at 3:38 PM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply
Rob E.

Correction to the article: "For the very reasonable price of $2.99 any iPhone or iPod touch running iPhone OS 3.0 or better can get a full and multi-featured audiobook subsystem, and although it still needs some features, it's wonderful."

I downloaded it yesterday without reading the sidebar in the ap store because it hadn't occurred to me that there was a substantial enough difference between iPod Touch Gen1 and Gen2 where this application is concerned, but apparently there is. The application won't install on my 1st Generation iPod Touch, and, reading the application store's page, it does say "Compatible with iPhone and iPod Touch (2nd generation). Requires iPhone 3.0 or later." Although when I went back to get the exact text just now, I see that the top of the product description says, "Have a 1st gen iPod Touch? We're looking into compatibility and hope to approve it for your device very soon."

So hopefully they'll get it working, but for now 1st Gen Touch users need not apply. Still perplexing, though, since the iPod Touch came out after the 1st gen iPhone, which does not seem to have compatibility issues.

September 15 2009 at 5:07 PM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply
Paul Kierstead

Here is MY problem:

I use my iPhone for audio books in my car a lot. It uses an iPod integration kit. This means I can no longer access the song selection controls in the iPod, since the iPod player is locked out when docked. Now what track gets played could be the last one that got played, or it could be the first in my song list; the latter is guaranteed if I have synced, and otherwise a bit of a crapshoot (a friend says it happens when the iPod app gets kicked outta memory due to low memory condition).

So, if my Pod is docked in something like a car where the iPod app is locked out (and I can't pause, BTW), and I select this app an play a book, will it stop the iPod app playing? This along would be a great help, since it is an easy way to select an audio book to play (my g/f does it, so no comments on driving while ipodding). The car controls for song selection are insanely difficult to use.

September 14 2009 at 4:55 PM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply
Rob E.

I have frequently lost my place in an audio book. Originally, using a 5G iPod, it seemed to be a bug involving file sizes that had me constantly scrubbing back to where I left off. My iPod Touch handles my bookmark better, but not perfectly. I still have found the iPod losing my place, which, I think, often has to do with syncing between and listening on multiple devices. Sometimes I think iTunes regresses the file to an earlier version when I plug in a device that wasn't the one I was using most recently.

The file display in the iPod Touch vs. a click-wheel iPod is certainly different, but I find both have their advantages. It's easier to hop around the book or go to specific section using the chapters on the Touch. It's also easier to scrub around looking for a particular spot. Scrubbing on my 5G is very tricky if I'm trying to find the right point in a 5 hour file. But the click-wheel style display does show exactly how far into a file I am, which I like. You can get that information on the Touch, but it takes a little more effort. If I had to choose, I'd choose the Touch style of display, but what I'd really love to see is if the Touch could incorporate that piece of information that shows your place within the whole file.

Also, I recently considered using the audio version of a book for my book club. I abandoned this idea because there was no good way to mark passages and get back to specific parts. This application seems like it would be the key to that.

Not being able to run in the background is a shame, but I realize that's Apple's decision. It might be a deal breaker on this application, though, but its other features sound so promising that I will probably have to try it out.

September 13 2009 at 4:00 PM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply
duke

i've been using audible.com for over a year, downloaded about 25 books to itunes library then to itouch and have never had one instance of losing where i was on the last listen, on both itouch and laptop. i can leave the site, go to games and play while book still is being read, or shut down a game still hearing book, or shut down laptop or itouch and start up returns to same place.
the idea of being able to keep notes could be useful, but 2.99 for this feature isn't worth it.

September 13 2009 at 2:06 PM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply
jbrown510

Does this let you adjust playback speed with more granularity than .5x/1/2x? It looks like it might, but maybe that's just for scrubbing. There are a couple audio books I'd really like to of been able to playback at 1.25 or 1.50x, but find 2x too fast.

September 13 2009 at 2:00 PM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply
1 reply to jbrown510's comment
David Winograd

No, speeds can't be adjusted in this app. The bar referred to only lets you go forward or backward.

September 13 2009 at 2:25 PM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply
Mitchell Scott

Great, but the UI is kinda ugly.

September 13 2009 at 1:06 PM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply
Buy an ad here

Hot Apps on TUAW

Tweets

© 2012 AOL Inc. All Rights Reserved.