Skip to Content

Dear Aunt TUAW: What's the low down on battery packs?

Dear Aunt TUAW,

Boxcar is killing my battery life (at least, that's what I'm guessing -- I love Boxcar, but since I began getting 20+ notifications a day, I'm seeing the battery drain quite a bit faster). What kind of battery pack can you recommend to help my poor iPhone stay online and available? I need to stay connected.

Thanks in advance from your favorite nephew,

Mikey

Read on for Auntie's reply
My darling Mikey,

I love all my nieces and nephews alike -- but you are all my favorites! As for battery boost solutions, there are basically two kinds of iPhone solutions currently available on the market. You can go for cheap and awkward, or for expensive and well-designed.

That's not to see that the cheap and awkward solutions are unmanageable or wrong, it's just that the cheaper solutions tend to be large battery dongles that extend off your iPhone's connector port at the bottom. If you want a battery solution that fits more like a case, just expect to pay more.

I personally own a pair of Monoprice dongles -- the same ones my colleague David Winograd praised as "such a deal." Costing just over $12 for the 2200 mAh, you can recharge your iPhone while on the go. Attach the dongle, which is about half the size of the iPhone itself, for thirty minutes or so and your iPhone will be fully recharged. You can usually get more than one recharge off the pack.

If you're looking to pay a little less, you can pick up a 1900 mAh unit for nine dollars and change. It won't provide the same boost but it will save you a few dollars.

These low end units share two big problems. First, they change the shape and weight of your iPhone when in use. If you're running low on battery and need to use the phone with the booster plugged in, you'll find that the device becomes much more awkward to use. The longer shape makes it particularly awkward for landscape interaction.

The extra weight is definitely noticable. Yes, you can use the phone with it plugged in (and I find myself doing so more often than I care to admit), but it's not as smooth for use.

The second problem lies with iPod touch units. Using a plug-in booster like the Monoprice units will cover the audio out jack. That means you can recharge or use headphones but not both. I've looked around for a male to female connection cable extension but have not yet succeeded in finding one to buy [they're out there -- both dirt cheap and relatively pricey. –Ed.]. Even if I did, it would be seriously awkward carrying around a dangling battery charger pack.

Bottom-attached packs work best when you plug in the device each time you stick it in your backpack, purse, or briefcase. It ensures that your unit recharges while you're not using it and you always pull out a fully-charged device. There are also some chargers designed to work with your regular sync/charge cable, like the well-regarded 4400 mAh Gum Pro pointed out by our commenters; there are even solar-powered chargers like this Dexim unit, which doubles as an iPhone stand.

You can cut out a bit of awkward if you're willing to spend a little more money. The mophie juice pack air provides "the world's thinnest rechargeable battery case" for $80 (with free shipping). It creates a more case-like solution for powering your iPhone, which at least from a geometric point of view, is really nice. Plus, the juice pack air is officially certified by Apple.

The downsides are the cost (obviously) and the lower boost -- mophie does not guarantee that you receive double the battery life time. With the cheaper dongle solutions, you often get well over twice the life. The 2200 mAh I own is often good for a complete second recharge (note that I do not go to full discharge before recharging), giving my iPhone quite an extended battery life.

Regardless of which kind of solution you end up going with, keep in mind: you're going to increase the weight you're carrying around, you're going to have to be responsible for more stuff, and the shape of the iPhone is going to change -- case form factor or not.

If you're the kind of person who uses the iPhone from a pocket, battery boostage may not be the solution for you. But if you're a purse/backpack/briefcase kind of guy, you may want to look into a booster pack.

Love, kisses & snuggles,

Auntie T.

Dear Aunt TUAW, Boxcar is killing my battery life (at least, that's what I'm guessing -- I love Boxcar, but since I began getting 20+...
 

Add a Comment

*0 / 3000 Character Maximum

21 Comments

Filter by:
Michal

I purchased an energizer Xpal battery pack for the iphone for $20 from newegg and it's a beautiful case and 1500amp battery for the iphone but I noticed you said the monoprice one charges your phone to full capacity in half an hour. Is this correct? I wouldn't mind plugging it in for half an hour and having another full charge rather than keeping a fat case on my phone for a couple hours till it gets a full charge. So if it really just takes 30 minutes to charge the phone from %0 to %100 I'd go for that as well. Is this the case? thanks

January 16 2010 at 7:09 PM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply
driftwood

Now, I don't actually own this so I can't review it, but this is what I've been looking to buy when the money frees up:

"Kensington K33457US Charging Dock with Mini Battery Pack for iPhone and iPod"
http://www.amazon.com/Kensington-K33457US-Charging-Battery-iPhone/dp/B002F9NSOO/ref=wl_it_dp_o?ie=UTF8&coliid=I759HCJSQQOJ2&colid=2CI2DDYNYQ3Y7

It's both a dock for both the iphone and battery backup. I figure, if I'm going to need a dock and an extra battery, why not get them both at once and together?

January 15 2010 at 11:00 AM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply
homan2

Tekkeon MP1550 here, AA rechargables, recharge from mini USB, juice up any device that can charge on a standard USB port. About 20 bucks at Amazon, and your power is limited to the # of batteries that you have (great for DC to LA Civ Rev marathons).

January 15 2010 at 8:19 AM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply
Dewayne

I have seen a lot of these iPhone battery cases pop up. They seem to be everywhere. The one I found and use is called SaFPWR, distributed by Cremindustries.com. Apple certfied, crazy color selections, they make them for iPod touch and they will knock the shipping off of you email them before ordering. What hooked me is the way the tech works. Saves my internal battery from premature death. Yeah, it's gonna eventually die but my 2g is still plugging away with the SAME internal battery!

January 14 2010 at 10:32 PM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply
Eric

I should add that I also have a powermonkey explorer for more robust charging needs but that resides in my backpack. The advantage of this is that I can charge all my devices (Nokia N800, PSP, etc.) and it even has a solar unit to recharge the charger (though it takes ages)

January 14 2010 at 9:45 PM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply
Mark Miller

I've been using an I-UP 5400 mAh backup battery made by LuckyPacks (LuckyPacks.com) for the last couple of months and I love it. It's not outrageously big and it can give me almost 4 extra iPhone full battery charges from a single charge.

It's currently on sale for $59.99, it comes with like a million little adapters, and it even has a built-in LED flashlight which is amazingly strong.

I'd highly recommend it, especially if you use your iPhone as much as I use mine.

January 14 2010 at 9:37 PM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply
JD

I have a Juice Pack Air (my 2nd, read on) and like it very much save two issues, both related.

The good:

1) I find the added weight and size not really noticeable in most usage.
2) While doubling battery life is not a feature, I went from being dead-empty by late evening to having 45+% remaining -- easily satisfying my needs.

The bad:

Both involve the power/recharge plug. While I understand why Mophie didn't implement a standard phone/pod plug, what they implemented has two (major) issues. 1) It's a bit flimsy, apparently bonded to the internal circuit board only and not the surrounding case. An accidental drop of a few inches onto a soft surface while plugged in was sufficient to tear the connector loose from the board, rendering the pack useless. And 2) the plug is very small and, not being bonded to the case, flexes slightly -- that combination makes it very hard to plug in unless you are paying close attention to the plug's alignment. I have excellent vision but can imagine someone with vision less acute finding it nearly impossible to accomplish.

January 14 2010 at 8:48 PM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply
diggsyang

I have two chargers. The Mili powerpack which is okay, but a bit awkward when on the iPhone. However, It can charge othe devices.

I also just picked up the Mili power skin. This is much better. It is a iPhone case and charger, I think slimmer or just as slim as the Morphie. The design is nice and clean and the power button and led lights are pretty cool too. They do not stick out. The connecter is also covered. It ran me about $80 like the Morphie and they are also Apple certified.

The Mili Powerpack has been around for a while, but the Mili power skin is pretty new and a bit hard to find, but it is available on-line.

I recomend the Mili power skin.

January 14 2010 at 7:31 PM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply
MikeWard1701

Great article.

Are there any battery/charging jackets on the market that have a female 30-pin connector in them so you can sit the iPhone/iTouch in a dock whithut removing it from the jacket?

January 14 2010 at 7:01 PM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply
Dale

I have a Mili on my iPhone 3G. It was a Christmas present, and I am very happy with it thus far. I get twice as long on a charge as I did before... the only issue I have is that sometimes you have to slip the phone out and in again for it to recognise the Mili after charging both.

January 14 2010 at 6:29 PM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply
1 reply to Dale's comment
Dale

AND I forgot to mention: it has a mini USB jack for charging, plus a regular-sized USB passthrough so you can charge two devices from a single wall socket... handy when you're overseas with limited adaptors as my wife and I were when I first got it.

January 14 2010 at 6:30 PM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply
Buy an ad here

Hot Apps on TUAW

Tweets

© 2012 AOL Inc. All Rights Reserved.