Vlingo 2 adds more voice power to iPhone
In the burgeoning market for iPhone voice recognition apps, the free Dragon Dictate clearly holds the top spot. In fact, this paragraph was dictated using DragonDictate (with some minor edits after the fact). However, the application doesn't always shine when it comes to getting your text quickly and easily into different places where you might want to use it. You can send an e-mail or a text message if you want to, but you can't update your Facebook status or send a Twitter message without copying and pasting. Performing a search requires an entirely separate app.
To make your dictation process easier -- at least when it comes to getting your text to go where you want, when you want -- there's the latest update to the Vlingo app, which we first reviewed last June. Vlingo 2.0 is trying to up the ante for text recognition by putting all the 'next step' options in one convenient place.
You can search (Google, Yahoo, or Bing), find map items, dial your contacts (with optional contact name upload to Vlingo's servers to improve recognition) and update your Facebook or Twitter status. For email or SMS, you have two in-app purchase options to extend the free app's capabilities; it's $6.99 for either SMS or email action, $9.99 for both.
Vlingo has gotten a thorough UI overhaul in this new version, and it's quite a bit easier to use than it was. The dictation button can be used in hold-down or tap-to-talk mode, and the app can be set to recognize speech on launch for maximum speed. You can specify what action you want by speaking it: "Email Joey, Subject how about some coffee, Message Got time to meet me at Starbucks? You're buying!" will create and address an outgoing email for you, all in one step.
That one-stop-shopping for creating emails is definitely more streamlined than Dragon's implementation, and it also exposes one of Vlingo's handiest features: a record button in the confirmation/edit screen for each of the destinations, allowing you to append or insert new dictation where you need it. Important safety note: while Vlingo isn't intended for use while driving or during other attention-critical tasks, it's probably less distracting to speak a few sentences than it is to type them.
Unfortunately, there are one or two drawbacks to the Vlingo fandango. First, there isn't a raw 'notepad' mode, where you can simply dictate text with the intention of copying it to another app. Of course, if you have the $6.99 email module, you can use that for free text entry, but in the free app there's no direct way to do it except by speaking a Facebook update and then copying instead of sending it (which works fine, by the way).
The second drawback is more consequential, and hopefully one that will be fixed over time; the recognition simply isn't as good as Dragon's, at least at the start (in one instance, it misheard "2.0" as "to porno," which is certainly spicier). Vlingo's VP of Consumer Business, Hadley Harris, told me that the app does learn and improve as you use it, both for individual accuracy as it's corrected and globally as new words are added to the back-end recognition engine.
The good news is, the base app is free, and it's worth a try to see if it meets your needs as well or better than the Dragon suite, Siri or any of the other voice apps. I'm not sure the email or SMS buy-ups are as good a deal, but that will depend on your individual needs and usage profile.
TUAW is commonly provided with not-for-resale licenses or promo codes to permit product evaluations and reviews. For more details, see our policy page.
Share
Source: http://vlingo.com/
Categories
In the burgeoning market for iPhone voice recognition apps, the free Dragon Dictate clearly holds the top spot. In fact, this paragraph was...
Add a Comment
I USED to love this app.
March 10 2010 at 5:20 AM Report abuse Permalink rate up rate down ReplyI have this app on my Blackberry Storm, and it works wonders. You just say "text ___" and then I wait and then I say my message, sometimes I edit (infrequently) and then I say "send" and the text is sent. Much better then using the touch screen. I think it works the same for the iphone and ipod touch (for emails)
March 08 2010 at 3:34 PM Report abuse Permalink rate up rate down ReplyWhat are the steps required to use the SMS feature with this app? I'm interested in knowing if it's an improvement over Dragon Dictate where you're required to do the following:
1) Open the app.
2) Press the record button.
3) Say the message. (App detects the ending automatically)
4) Confirm the accuracy of the message.
5) Press the "Send to" button.
6) Press the "Text Message" button.
7) Choose the contact to send to (assuming it's high enough in the list of recent contacts).
8) Click the text field.
9) Click the text field again.
10) Click "Paste".
11) Click "Send".
Honestly, this lengthy process isn't much of an improvement if I'm trying to respond to a message while in the car. I'm curious if Vlingo has figured out a better way to handle this, but I don't want to pay for something that doesn't do it any better than Dragon Dictate does. This is my understanding so far:
1) Open the app. (Recording starts automatically)
2) Say "Text [person] [message]".
3) Press the "Stop" button.
4) Confirm the message.
5) ???
Can anyone help me understand what the rest of the process is?
I understand that the steps are as follows:
1 - Open app
2 - ???
3 - Profit!
Personally I think the in-app purchase price is waaaay to expensive. Pretty disappointing about that. I expected there to be in-app purchasing, but much cheaper. I'd feel comfortable doing $1.99-2.99 for SMS/Email and maybe $4.99 for both.
I hope they lower the price assuming enough people agree with me.. then I'll be completely on-board! Vlingo has been on my home screen since it's launch on the iPhone, so I have always been a huge supporter... but for now, I'll let Dragon Dictate keep doing what it does amazingly and for free ;)
just tried it out, maybe it was my english accent but it didnt work correctly once swapping "this app is crap" for "this is correct"
March 04 2010 at 6:37 AM Report abuse Permalink rate up rate down ReplySadly this app provides practical NO privacy..
"We collect information that you speak or type into a vlingo text box.." or "We collect names of individuals and companies that appear in adress book.."
http://www.vlingo.com/privacy.jsp
March 04 2010 at 10:02 AM Report abuse Permalink rate up rate down ReplyDoes this app work with a bluetooth headset? Like the ICON?
March 04 2010 at 1:58 AM Report abuse Permalink rate up rate down Reply@ Michael Rose
Thanks for the in-depth review but let's be honest. Your main objective was to post that screen grab so you could brag about 4 bars of ATT service am I right? ;-)
If you were to see my iPhone screen, you would see that it has been forwarded for over a year while impatiently waiting for ATT to release the Microcell into the Colorado mountains.
Ha! You found me out.
Actually I just swapped out that image, because the one I originally had may have given a false impression of how good/bad the recognition is.
Hot Apps on TUAW
Deals of the Day
more deals- Refurbished Skullcandy Tokidoki Smokin' Buds Mic'd Headset for $5 + $2 s&h
- Stitchway Backup Battery for iPod / iPhone for $5 + free shipping
- Used Apple MacBook Pro 2.4GHz 15" LED Laptop for $1,030 + $29 s&h
- Refurb MacBook Air Core i5 Dual 1.6GHz 12" Laptop for $750 + free shipping
- Sony Dock 20W Speaker System for iPhone / iPod for $51 + $15 s&h
- Soulo Karaoke App and Wireless Mic for iPhone / iPad for $80 + free shipping
Software Updates
more updates- EFI Firmware Update brings Lion Internet Recovery to 2010-model Macs
- OS X Lion 10.7.3 released with Safari 5.1.3, Wi-Fi bug fix
- Aperture updated to 3.2.2, addresses Photo Stream issue
- Apple updates Keynote to address Lion issues
- Google Search app gets new look on iPad
- Apple releases Apple TV Software Update 4.4.3



12 Comments