TUAW review: Data Robotics Drobo FS NAS
Network Attached Storage (NAS) is gaining in popularity as an alternative to a home or small office server. A few weeks ago, I reviewed LaCie's Network Space 2, which is a non-expandable 1TB storage solution. For those who want a solution that will be expandable in the future, Data Robotics has recently introduced the Drobo FS.Like its predecessors, the Drobo FS has multiple drive bays -- five in this case -- into which you can insert standard SATA hard disk drives. The array can be set up for either single or dual-disk redundancy, meaning that one (single) or two (dual) drives can fail without compromising the integrity of your data. Data Robotics' proprietary BeyondRAID technology makes the array easy to set up and expand.
The Drobo FS is easy to set up. The review unit sent to TUAW by Data Robotics was removed from its box, three disk drives were installed by sliding them into available slots on the unit, the power supply was connected, and a gigabit Ethernet cable run from a router to the back of the Drobo. Upon powering up the Drobo FS, the device showed up under the Shared list in the Finder -- so far, so good.
The Drobo FS shipped with a new version of the Drobo Dashboard software on a USB flash drive, which I installed prior to turning on the device. As you'll be able to see in the gallery at the end of this post, the Drobo Dashboard software is identical to that used with other Drobo devices. The software is straightforward to use, and there were no surprises there. Drobo Dashboard can handle multiple Drobo devices, so if you already have a direct-attached Drobo and add an FS to the network, you can control both from the same application.
Data Robotics touts their DroboApps (Linux applications that run on the Drobo device) as a way of adding functionality to the Drobo FS. As you'll recall from the review of the LaCie Network Space 2, that device can be used as an iTunes media "server" and a bit torrent or FTP client with the click of a button. Data Robotics has a large number of DroboApps available, so I decided to try to install a few to see how they worked.
Installation is fairly straightforward -- all you need to do is enable DroboApps by checking a box in the Drobo Dashboard software, then reboot the device. A DroboApps share appears, and you can install downloaded DroboApps by dragging their tgz archive files into this share. Upon restarting the Drobo FS, the apps are launched. DroboApps are controlled by pointing your web browser to the IP address of the Drobo FS.
My only concern about DroboApps is that they should be much easier to implement and control. One thing I see that LaCie did "right" with the Network Space 2 is to make it drop-dead simple to implement the most popular apps; iTunes-compatible media sharing, Bit Torrent and FTP capabilities, etc... If I could make one suggestion to Data Robotics, it would be to pre-install the top five or so DroboApps on the device, along with simple instructions on how to administer those apps. Providing control through the Drobo Dashboard software would make control even more simple.
The Drobo FS, like most network-attached devices, is limited by the speed of the network that it is attached to. Data Robotics notes that if you have a network capable of handling Jumbo Frames, you can tweak the MTU size up to 9000 to give the Drobo FS a performance boost.
The bottom line on the Drobo FS is that it is truly the next generation of the existing "Drobo plus DroboShare" combination. It provides Data Robotics' expandable BeyondRAID technology in a network-attached version that is well within the financial reach of prosumers or businesses. If you're looking for a way to add shared, expandable RAID storage to a home or office network, consider the Drobo FS.
One final comment: just about every time that we run a post about any of Data Robotics storage products, we get a flurry of comments both pro and con about the devices. During the time that I have tested the devices or used them at a number of client offices, I have never had any issues with Drobo products. Your mileage may vary, and you're welcome to post your opinion in the comments section. Please keep those comments intelligent and civil.
Pricing on the Drobo FS starts at US$699 for a bare (no drives installed) device, and there's currently a Drobo FS configured with five 2.0 TB drives installed for $1,499. Be sure to check out the following gallery for some photos of the Drobo FS, as well as screenshots of the Drobo Dashboard software used to control the device.
Share
Categories
Network Attached Storage (NAS) is gaining in popularity as an alternative to a home or small office server. A few weeks ago, I reviewed...
Add a Comment
Here are some hard benchmark facts about the Drobo FS: http://timon-royer.com/en/75/drobo-fs-benchmark-and-review/
June 04 2010 at 9:22 AM Report abuse Permalink rate up rate down ReplyYou can place it anywhere you have a free LAN jack. Hopefully your network is running with 1 gig connectivity but it runs well at 100 also. I've had mine for almost a month now and I still think it's awsome. I brought it over to a friends house to try it out and he's picking one up as well.
May 17 2010 at 9:08 AM Report abuse Permalink rate up rate down ReplyI have a pre-buy question. I have an apartment in NYC with ethernet ports around the apartment and a box in the closet that acts as a hub for all the ethernet jacks. In this case, does the Drobo need to sit next to my router or can I just plug the Drobo into the hub in the closet and have it access the router this way?
May 07 2010 at 4:24 PM Report abuse Permalink rate up rate down ReplyDROBO-FS
1. It has problems with user level protection under osx. Must use windows to add and remove all users access.
2. It has problems with long file names and adds resource fork files under directories.
3. support states can't use -, spaces or other characters in file name. So what am I going to do rename everything.
4. nice software packages like superduper will not recognize the network drive (drobo-fs). drobo solution, use sparse disk images (terrible option).
5. when coping or doing tasks while extensive read/write to drobo FS, the copies will fail on occasion.
6. ext3 format on drive means you can't use your standard mac disk utility software!
THE DROBO-FS is an immature product and I don't have a warm and fuzzy feeling with it.
I forgot to mention I see a file on the root of my FS called .com.apple.timemachine.supported so it looks like it does support timemachine. I don't have anything on my mac worth backing up so I haven't attemped using it.
April 25 2010 at 11:45 AM Report abuse Permalink rate up rate down ReplyI just picked one up, I had version 1 then bought a version 2, really wanted to make it available to all my pc's so i picked up the drobo share. Drobo share was really too slow for me but it worked well enough. I never had any issues with my drobo's, they all worked as advertised. I just transfered all my data to the Drobo FS and I can say this is the drobo I always wanted. Working great, obviously a huge improvement over the drobo share.
I have a music folder with 800 directories in the root folder and it used to take a few seconds to open on the share and it's now immediate on the FS. I keep my Outlook PST on the drobo, I have about 1200 emails in my mailbox and it was a little slow to open from the share. Now opens like the file is on a local drive.
I have two PC's, two laptops and a macbook. All can access the drobo without a problem. The share worked great as well but it was just so slow. FS runs like the data is local. I have thosands of photo's and can browse them without a problem.
I have a 610N with my main PC (Windows 7 Utimate 64, i7860, 8 gig ram) wired through the router at 1 gig and all other pc's/mac running wireless. Drobo FS has two 1.5 TB drives and three 1 TB drives.
What a disappointing review. No mention of speeds (wired or through a wifi connection) very little detail on how the Drobo works specifically with Macs (Time Machine, iTunes streaming etc) and a bad attitude from the reviewer when answering reader's comments.
TUAW editors, you should be ashamed of yourselves. I rely in your site to test the things I as a Mac owner need to know before buying a device. In this case, you've really dropped the ball.
If this is anything as unreliable as the DroboShare, then stay away from it. I've had nothing but pain and grief with the DroboShare. I can't use it for anything much (it will bomb out in the middle of a SuperDuper backup, for example) and it has already lost my data.
Myself, given the experience with Drobo products, I intend to stay away from them and seek something more reliable.
@michael - for video editing you should look at Drobo S, DroboPro, or Drobo Elite. Network latency will probably rule out using a Drobo FS. For more information, there is an on-demand presentation that describes using various Drobos in video on here: http://www.drobo.com/resources/webinars.php. In it, Rich Harrington of RHED Pixel describes how he has three editors editing multicam projects in Final Cut Pro using a DroboElite.
April 23 2010 at 1:13 PM Report abuse Permalink rate up rate down ReplyDrobo arigato, Mr. Roboto.
April 23 2010 at 11:39 AM Report abuse Permalink rate up rate down ReplyHot Apps on TUAW
Deals of the Day
more deals- Verizon Leather Sleeve for Tablets for $4 + free shipping
- Wicked Jaw Breaker Noise-Isolating In-Ear Headphones for $6 + free shipping
- Refurb Apple MacBook Air Laptops: 12" 64GB SSD for $699 + free shipping
- JVC Motion Sensing Clock Radio with Dual iPod Docks for $55 + free shipping
- Apple iPhone Headset with Mic for $4 + $2 s&h
- Refurb Apple iPod nano 8GB MP3 Player for $99 + free shipping, 16GB for $119
Software Updates
more updates- EFI Firmware Update brings Lion Internet Recovery to 2010-model Macs
- OS X Lion 10.7.3 released with Safari 5.1.3, Wi-Fi bug fix
- Aperture updated to 3.2.2, addresses Photo Stream issue
- Apple updates Keynote to address Lion issues
- Google Search app gets new look on iPad
- Apple releases Apple TV Software Update 4.4.3



49 Comments