TUAW Hands-on: POWER A turns your iPhone into a universal remote
There are a few options for turning your iPhone into a home entertainment remote control, but I recently got a chance to try out the POWER A, and it's become my current favorite. The hardware portion of the POWER A package has been available for a while now, but the iPhone App that accompanies it has a new version due out any time now. It was submitted to the App Store on Monday, but I got a chance to try it out with a review unit and put it through its paces.
The hardware portion, which works with the iPhone 3G and 3GS, is great: it's a low-profile, hard plastic case that fits around the iPhone. Unlike other solutions which leave a dongle sticking out of the iPhone, it gives you a smooth, solid body with nothing to break off. It uses next to no battery power, and the increase in the phone's form factor is minimal.
The case comes in two halves which slide onto either side of the phone, connecting in the middle. It even comes with an additional, non-IR half, just in case you like the case so much that you want to use it even when it's not functioning as your universal remote.
The IR blaster is positioned on the dock end of the iPhone, and the resulting upside-down-factor is compensated for in the software by auto-rotating your screen when it launches. Despite the appearance of frailty that might be perceived in its translucent plastic, it's been a very sturdy piece of hardware that has held up quite well to my clumsiness (and my dogs' curiosity).
While vital to the package, the hardware is nothing but pretty without the software ...
If you plug the hardware in without downloading the app, it's kind enough to pop up a modal dialog that offers to take you directly to the App Store and point you to the free download. The currently-available incarnation of the app is a satisfactory bit of software, but the soon-to-be-available (submitted for approval on Monday) version is a huge improvement. I was part of some extensive beta-testing for it, and the dev team has been great about fixing small bugs and taking my suggestions to heart.
Where the previous version provided you with a pre-defined key layout and allowed you to quickly assign functions to each button, the new version, by UMEE, allows you to create locations (different rooms), add devices from presets based on manufacturer, and edit every aspect of the layout. When you add a device, it gives you a ready-to-go remote that works right away. However, you can add and remove buttons, assign new functions and position anything anywhere. It's great out of the box, but entirely flexible. What's really handy about it, though, is that you can easily assign functions from different remotes into one layout, having the channel pair control your cable box, while the volume pair controls your receiver. It's not an entirely unique concept among universal remotes, but it's certainly a great feature.
The ease of setup -- and the speed at which it can learn an entirely set of new IR commands -- is astounding. I'm able to add a new device and have it pre-configured in seconds, and I can create a general layout and learn every button on it from the original remotes in less than a minute. Slick. Learning new buttons is accomplished by putting it into learn mode and pointing your existing remote at the IR end of the unit. You can tap a button on the POWER A and then tap its correlating button on your remote, but for real speed you can just let it auto-highlight buttons in sequence, advancing each time it learns the IR code you press.
I've said it before, but it bears repeating: I've never found a touch-screen remote that really compares to having real, honest-to-goodness buttons; tactile controls are vital to me. However, the iPad is certainly starting to change my mind about that, especially as I gain some muscle memory for typing on it. The same goes for touch-screen remotes, and the POWER A team has done a good job of compensating for the lack of tactile response with audio feedback, which makes using it without looking at it a little more intuitive. It also has configurable gesture support, allowing two finger swipes in different directions to control various functions on each device.
Overall, the POWER A remote has been very impressive, and is well-suited to my needs. I imagine that it would fare quite well even in a more advanced setup than my cobbled-together home entertainment system. The POWER A hardware is available at the Apple Store, as well as online at the POWER A website. It retails for $59.99US, which I find to be very reasonable in the realm of universal remotes (at least among the ones that are actually useful). The accompanying software is a free download from the App Store, and the new version has been submitted and is just subject to the whims of the App Store approval process now. It's been fun to test this one out, and I'm thinking I'll be purchasing the test unit rather than returning it ... we've become rather fond of each other.
Share
Categories
There are a few options for turning your iPhone into a home entertainment remote control, but I recently got a chance to try out the POWER...
Add a Comment
Can you use the "POWER A" case / device with the powermat?
June 26 2010 at 4:48 PM Report abuse Permalink rate up rate down ReplyWhat I want to know is whether or not your iPhone can be charged with the Power-A case attached? That to me seems to be the one big flaw with many of these universal remote solutions. If I'm going to repurpose an iPhone 3G to become nothing but a full time universal remote, who wants to pull out the dongle or take off the case every time you need to charge it? That's the one advantage I see to the Red Eye Mini implementation, which controls the IR blaster through the headphone jack. Of course the RE Mini is begging to be snapped off by my 3 year old or an inadvertent drop to the floor.
Give me a solution that I can leave attached, is sturdy enough not to break, and leaves the dock port open for a charging stand sitting next to my (wife's) chair, and I'm in!
Yes but how soon will they have an IR case for the iPhone 4? I almost bought this after reading the article but then remembered I have an iPhone 4 that's waiting to be picked up in just under a week.
June 17 2010 at 5:36 PM Report abuse Permalink rate up rate down ReplyI own a PowerA and the old app version is really lame, so the new release may help. The real issue that I have with the PowerA is that it's IR signal strength is poor. I have to be within 10 feet and directly pointed at the receiving device IR input. It's not acceptable, and that is a hardware problem. I also want to use my iPad as a remote.
I have since purchased a Re Universal Remote from www.newkinetix.com. It works at 40ft and has much more advanced features in the App. It has a database built-in so setup is easy. Then you build multi-device remotes for controlling activities like watch TV or watch a move. You can add unlimited macros for automation of activities, build favorites lists, and customize the remote layout. The Re even supports bump for sharing setups with other iPhone, touch or iPad users at home.
The holy grail would be a remote app that can send commands via IR, WiFi, and bluetooth all from the same screen.
Example:
IR - Line of sight for receiver volume, TV power
WiFi - control equipment in media rack closet, eg HTPC, TiVo
Bluetooth - Because Sony is Sony - PS3
Bonus:
RS-232 - I don't need it, but for professional HT installations, 2 way serial control is a must
If someone could come up with all those features supported in a single app, and short a bunch of AMX and Crestron stock before sending out the Press Release, they could make a fortune :)
Love this - I gotta get it. Really, what will they think of next?
June 17 2010 at 2:19 PM Report abuse Permalink rate up rate down ReplyYou don't mention macros in your article, so I assume it doesn't do them?
My Harmony 880 is getting a bit old and starting to flake out on me; I'd totally repurpose an old 3G for this if it did macros.
Crestron makes a better iPhone app for this.
June 17 2010 at 1:31 PM Report abuse Permalink rate up rate down ReplyThis is ridiculous. What they should have done is an IRBlaster that you put in front of your TV or on your coffee table that would communicate via wifi (or bluetooth) with the iPhone. No need for this bulky case!
Also if the IRBlaster would be wifi enabled you could sent command to it via the Internet.
http://www.tuaw.com/2009/12/02/redeye-universal-remote-for-your-home-entertainment-center/
I actually prefer this solution, but RedEye sounds like it would fit your needs just fineâ¦
@Brett Terpstra
Ah! yes your are right the RedEye is what I had in mind thanks. A bit expensive, so I think I'll keep my Logitech Harmony remote for now.
Also if I'm not home how will my girlfriend change the channel if she doesn't have an iPhone! Hey wait a minute, GF can't change the channel, this is a good thing!!!! :)
What I'd love to see is this type of product but with wireless control. Place the device where it can see the tv (and receiver/dvd player, etc.); have the signal sent from the iPhone to the device via Bluetooth/Wifi, then have the device blast the IR signal to the TV. This way you get the benefits of replacing IR remotes, but you don't have to attach a case/dongle and don't have to point your iPhone.
June 17 2010 at 12:25 PM Report abuse Permalink rate up rate down ReplyGet a RedEye (wifi -> IR blaster), or check out this thread at AVSforum for additional options:
http://www.avsforum.com/avs-vb/showthread.php?t=1084846
Hot Apps on TUAW
Deals of the Day
more deals- Used Apple iMac 17" Core 2 Duo 1.83GHz for $430 + $28 s&h
- Lounge Deluxe Stand for iPhone / iPod touch for $28 + $8 s&h
- Brookstone Surround-Sound Earbuds for $14 + $7 s&h
- Refurbished Skullcandy Tokidoki Smokin' Buds Mic'd Headset for $5 + $2 s&h
- Stitchway Backup Battery for iPod / iPhone for $5 + free shipping
- Used Apple MacBook Pro 2.4GHz 15" LED Laptop for $1,030 + $29 s&h
Software Updates
more updates- EFI Firmware Update brings Lion Internet Recovery to 2010-model Macs
- OS X Lion 10.7.3 released with Safari 5.1.3, Wi-Fi bug fix
- Aperture updated to 3.2.2, addresses Photo Stream issue
- Apple updates Keynote to address Lion issues
- Google Search app gets new look on iPad
- Apple releases Apple TV Software Update 4.4.3



26 Comments