Skip to Content

Road Tested: The Withings Scale, an Apple accessory you can stand on



In the Apple accessory ecosystem, there are thousands of different items for the Mac, iPhone, iPod, and iPad. Out of that huge world, I can think of only one accessory that you can actually stand on -- The Withings Connected Body Scale (US$159.00). I've had the pleasure of using one of these internet-connected scales for about a year now, and I find it to be a help in my daily battle between being a foodie and trying to maintain a decent weight.

Although the Withings Scale can be used with any computer, I like to think of it as an Apple accessory, since I can use my Mac, iPhone, and iPad in various ways to check my diet progress. Withings provides a free iOS app (WiScale) that gives you password-protected access to your weight information, or you can visit the main Withings website to view the same data on your free account.

The scale measures and calculates your weight, fat mass, and BMI (Body Mass Index), and then it transmits that information to the Withings servers via a Wi-Fi connection to your network. Within a very short amount of time, that information can either be accessed privately via a variety of methods or can be sent to the world via Facebook, Twitter, or a blog widget.
The scale looks like it could have been designed by Jonny Ive as an accessory for an iMac. It's a sleek slab of black glass on top of a base with curved sides, so it appears to be hovering. The display is easy to read and can be adjusted to show your weight in pounds, kilograms, or stones. It uses 4 AAA batteries, so there's no power cable running to the scale. I've found that I get great battery life since the scale shuts itself off after use, then turns itself back on when you step on it.

Setup of the scale was easy when I first did it in December of 2009, but now it's even easier. At the time I set up my scale, you needed to connect it to a computer (Mac, Windows, or Linux) at least once via an included USB cable. The USB connection was used to feed the Wi-Fi network parameters (SSID, password, etc...) to the scale. Now, however, the WiScale app can be used from any iOS device to set up the scale.

In terms of network compatibility, the Withings Scale works on 802.11b/g standards and works perfectly with Apple's AirPort devices as a result. It supports WEP, WPA, and WPA2 security modes, which should keep your curious neighbors from packet-sniffing your weight every morning.

As I noted earlier, sharing your weight -- if you want to do that -- is quite easy. You can set up Twitter tweeting ("Whoa, Steve gained 4 pounds overnight!"), Facebook updates, and there's a widget available for most blogging tools that will display your weight. Although I'm not that open, at least until I lose some weight, it's nice to know that I can use these common methods as a way of shaming myself into losing more weight or letting my friends provide motivation.

But the true power of the Withings Scale is apparent when you see how many iOS apps can actually tap into your weight measurements. By my count, which is probably quite low, you can track your progress in the Daily Burn (free), Runkeeper (free or Pro version for $9.99), iBody ($9.99), Weightbot ($1.99), Fit Orbit (free), and Cal2Go ($3.99) apps. I had purchased the awesome Tapbots Weightbot app before I got my Withings Scale, and I was thrilled when I didn't have to manually enter my weight readings anymore. Withings notes that the scale also works with Microsoft HealthVault and Google Health.

When you stand on the scale, it takes about 20 seconds for it to take your weight and determine your fat content, after which the information is sent off to the Withings site. One thing I noticed is that, if you have two users who are approximately the same weight, the scale has problems determining who is currently standing on it. My wife and I ran into that issue recently; she's doing a great job losing weight, while I'm doing an equally good job maintaining my current high weight, so on the occasions when she uses the Withings Scale, it sometimes mixes up our readings.

This isn't an Apple accessory that's going to appeal to everyone, but if you're serious about reducing or maintaining your weight to improve your overall fitness, the Withings Connected Body Scale is certainly a great way to automatically integrate fitness information into a growing number of iOS and Web apps.

Categories

Accessories Mac iOS

In the Apple accessory ecosystem, there are thousands of different items for the Mac, iPhone, iPod, and iPad. Out of that huge world, I...
 

Add a Comment

*0 / 3000 Character Maximum Comment Moderation Enabled. Your comment will appear after it is cleared by an editor.

11 Comments

Filter by:
John

There is the eScale from BodyTrace as well, that one is $70. Its a different concept though, its GSM... www.bodytrace.com

September 16 2010 at 4:45 PM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply
macbitz

Have been using one of these for about six months and it works a treat. Calibrated it against the scales at my doctor's surgery and it's pretty accurate.

Many electronic scales can suffer from poor consistency, and my previous Salter scales would change by up to 0.5Kg when stepping on them repeatedly. The Withings does quite well, not had variations of more than 0.3Kg.

September 16 2010 at 5:50 AM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply
Richard

I have this scale. You mean I have to stand on it to weigh myself. I thought holding the Iphone was good enough ;-) But seriously, it is fun but sad to see my weight going down and down but then up and up and knowing that gravity is a constant but my diet is not.

September 15 2010 at 5:52 PM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply
carrespondence

I'm sure it's cool, but $160 for a scale?

September 15 2010 at 12:40 PM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply
2 replies to carrespondence's comment
homan2

It gets worse- if you lose weight you'll end up spending several times that in new clothes, and probably end up going out more to social events- many of which cost money as well. It's a slippery slope.

September 15 2010 at 12:47 PM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply
carrespondence

Well put, THJ! Lol.

September 15 2010 at 12:53 PM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply
Herchu

Curiously, I'm just about to pick up this scale from the shop in a couple of hours. Glad to know that the review is very good!

September 15 2010 at 12:15 PM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply
nc

i havent lost any weight contrary to my wife but still a great gadget!

September 15 2010 at 11:39 AM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply
Adam S

I've lost 37 lbs since May, and this scale was a big part of it. I used to weight myself once a day and then I'd record it on paper, or in a website. But with the scale, I get on, and the app on the iPad (which is awesome and has more features) or the iPhone (which is actually more informative) do the rest automatically via push.

And the weightbot integration is awesome, which allowed me to import old measurements easily. I love my withings and recommend it to anyone considering one.

September 15 2010 at 11:27 AM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply
Norman

I have this product for about a month now, and some bad things that i read about it seem to be true. If you step on the Withings 3 times in 3 minutes, you will get 3 different weights. My withing is not on a carpet but on plain tiled floor (sorry if that is the wrong way of saying that it is a normal bathroom floor, i'm no native speaker). So the argument "maybe it is not positioned right" isn't working cause the scale doesn't move around.

Besides that, it helps me to get some "you shouldn't have done that" or "aaah, eating less pays out" feelings that i would never have if i would try to write down all that stuff on paper. I tried it once, and i know noone that doesn't someday stop to write it all down.

So besides the flaw that your weight moves around 1-2 kilograms just by stepping on the scale again (doesn't happen always, sometimes its quite accurate if you step on it a few times) i still think it is a great, but expensive product. Seing the pricepoint it is sad that the scale has the flaw with the changing weight.

September 15 2010 at 10:49 AM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply
DonQuixote

I LOVE this scale. Thanks to some better habits and it's connectedness, I'm down 11 pounds for the month.

September 15 2010 at 10:28 AM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply
Buy an ad here

Tweets

© 2012 AOL Inc. All Rights Reserved.