Hands-on with Magic Cube Bluetooth portable laser keyboard

The tech in laser-based keyboards has been around for a while, and when we first saw them we thought, "the future is here!" because what could be cooler than having a laser keyboard on any flat surface? I'll suggest something cooler: a keyboard that works. I spotted the Magic Cube from Celluon at CES and gave it a spin.
The Magic Cube connects to your Mac or iOS-powered device using Bluetooth and features a battery inside to power the laser and optical recognition systems. According to Celluon, you'll get 150 minutes of use from a charge. The device is somewhat large, occupying as much volume as two 1st-generation iPods, only slightly narrower. This gives it stability, but it also means you'll have to have the keyboard projector offset from your iPad or iPhone (why you would use it with your Mac is beyond me). The laser-projected keyboard is about the size of a MacBook's keyboard, complete with rounded keys. Unfortunately, it is a PC-centric keyboard complete with Menu and Insert keys, but that's not a big deal. The big deal is accuracy.
I type pretty fast considering I started typing on a computer when I was six (on an Apple II, thank you very much). If you type fast, you're going to have to slow down to use the Magic Cube. While their literature states it can detect up to 400 characters per minute, you'd have to be some sort of robotic ninja octopus to achieve such precision using this thing.
I found multiple attempts to track my speedy typing thwarted by two things: a lack of tactile feedback and the need to look at the keys while typing. In other words, your fingers will drift and the keyboard will cease to track all your key "presses" accurately. In some cases, the "press" didn't register at all. Others at the booth had similar issues. Check the gallery to see what came out when I tried to type "hi there my name is victor." Perhaps there's a learning curve?
While the Magic Cube is a nifty novelty, I wouldn't expect it to replace the dozens of physical keyboards we saw at CES. You can connect it via USB (PC-only it seems) or Bluetooth, and it comes in a variety of colors, but as a keyboard it just doesn't cut it. In the end, it felt about as useful as those old membrane keyboards (like the ones on the TIMEX Sinclair) with a resulting slowdown in typing and loss of accuracy. Here's hoping some day our magical tech dreams come true -- but until then, save your US$199.99 and spend it on a real keyboard.
Share
The tech in laser-based keyboards has been around for a while, and when we first saw them we thought, "the future is here!" because what...
Add a Comment
This kind of thing really doesn't belong on your desk in your office. It's really only practical in settings like a factory, warehouse, or shop floor where dirt and grime and whatnot would ruin a regular keyboard in a matter of days. Typical usage is assumed to be someone who is not in front of a keyboard all day and only needs to enter limited amounts of data infrequently during the day (ie someone who would be looking at the keys to type much of the time anyway). $200 + batteries for a year would save me much more money in the shop than what I currently budget to replace dead keyboards every month.
January 14 2011 at 6:50 AM Report abuse Permalink rate up rate down ReplyHaving worked in a chemical factory, construction and having friends in a machine shop I can tell you there are less techy but perfectly workable solutions besides this thing, but I can see how it could work.
We used to use a simple clear silicone rubber overlay to the keyboard which did a great job of keeping grime off the keyboard and was dishwasher-safe.
This my friends, is the future. A future where no real hardware isn't needed anymore besides a small device that connects everything and simply uses any surface wall for screen, table for keyboard, to create your virtual computer. That's for those who don't want one implanted in their brains, cause every upgrade means replacement of chips and who wants that. :-)
January 13 2011 at 5:12 PM Report abuse Permalink rate up rate down ReplySummer Glau's character used a keyboard like that in this week's premiere of "The Cape"! I didn't know that actually existed.
Of course, she also had those "Minority Report"-type holographic monitors with gesture control hanging in the air in front of her, so I guess I lumped in the laser keyboard reality with the holo-monitor myth.
They've been around for awhile, but the last time they made the news they were only vaporware because the vendor couldn't deliver a working product, and about a year later once allegedly working, he couldn't deliver in sufficient quantity to ship.
It's still a solution in search of a problem, and an especially poor solution at that.
Time Sinclair 1000, baby!!!! Hmmmm,, I think I should still have mine somewhere.
January 13 2011 at 4:13 PM Report abuse Permalink rate up rate down ReplySo you address the concerns that people have about not having tactile feedback and having to look at the keyboard with the iPad, by creating a keyboard that doesn't have tactile feedback which you have to look at.
Sounds like a great business model to me.
yeah on top of that, this one's even harder to see...
January 13 2011 at 3:25 PM Report abuse Permalink rate up rate down ReplyAbsolutely agree - this has no advantages over using the iPad's software keyboard, and plenty of additional disadvantages:
* It requires its own batteries/power supply
* It is harder to see and slower to use
* Layout does not change contextually - i.e. a fixed keyboard for every application
* It takes a large flat area to set it up - don't even think about taking notes on the train
This is a classic example of the mainstream overtaking a fringe technology and leaving it behind before the fringe technology has matured.
Deals of the Day
more deals- Used Apple iPad 32GB Wi-Fi Tablet for $200 + free shipping
- Apple iPod nano Multi-Touch 8GB MP3 Player for $100 + $8 s&h
- Cases for New iPad at HandHeldItems: Extra 20% off, $2 credit, from $3 + $3 s&h
- $15 Apple iTunes Gift Card for $8 for new Saveology customers
- Retro 80's Case for iPhone for $11 + $2 s&h
- HHI 360 Dual-View Stand Case for new iPad w/ $2 credit for $12 + $3 s&h
9 Comments