Mac.com email addresses getting the boot? Signs point to 'No.'

On Friday, we got a rather nervous tip from reader Julian (echoed in this MacStories post) pointing to his Apple Discussions thread about the future of @mac.com addresses. The thread cited a conversation with an Apple support chat representative that seemed to indicate an imminent end-of-life for the vintage mac.com emails, with all incoming and outgoing mail being forced over to the equivalent me.com address.
Since the mac.com domain predated the July 2008 relaunch of Apple's web services as MobileMe by several years, many subscribers have never bothered to update all the various spots where their mac.com addresses are used, and the prospect of being pushed to do so is obviously a bit worrisome. It's not at all clear, however, that this is actually happening, despite the rather sharp level of anxiety.
Why the agita right now? As with most Apple news nowadays, it begins with the iPhone. In a subtle tweak to iOS 4.2, Apple changed the MobileMe account setup to only allow the me.com address if you're activating your mail account 'fresh' on the device.
While anyone who upgraded from 4.1 or earlier without deleting and reactivating accounts is completely unaffected, trying to set up a mac.com account under MobileMe on a 4.2 iPad or iPhone will always result in the me.com equivalent address being used for inbound and outbound mail. (Keep in mind that you will still get incoming mac.com mail regardless of the account setup, as the two addresses are linked to the same mailbox -- JoeyFatone@mac.com is the same as JoeyFatone@me.com as far as inbound traffic is concerned.)
Apple's tech note on the 4.2 account tweak is clear on the simple workarounds for this change: either set up your account on your Mac/PC and then sync it over in iTunes, or set up your mac.com address as a manual IMAP account on your device. The circumstances, however, led Julian to contact Apple's chat line about the possible implications for desktop email use -- and the thread seen on the discussion site ensued, with a chat rep who apparently was not toting an entire bucketful of clue regarding Apple's mail plans. Indeed, a site host with the handle "Eric W." rapidly responded to say, in essence, "that dude does not know what he is talking about."
While it's technically possible for Apple to turn off authentication and outbound mail service from mac.com addresses, there's no obvious reason for it to do so (and, aside from this possibly misleading chat thread, no evidence that it is doing so anytime soon). Even if that were to happen, it's quite straightforward to send email from a third-party account like Gmail and substitute in the 'From:' address of your mac.com/me.com account.
All that is to say, there's no need to freak out and no cause for panic. If you need mac.com addresses on your iOS device, go ahead and set them up as noted above. If you need to send mail from mac.com on your Mac or PC, then as my people say, "Zay Gezunt" -- you should do so and be healthy. If you're worried about web service accounts or other logins that use your mac.com address, don't be; verification emails and the like will still come into your mailbox.
In fact, the only real challenge with moving from mac.com to me.com (aside from changing business cards, etc.) is for services like Yahoo Groups that require messages to be sent from a particular source address; for those, it's easy to log into your service account and add an alternate email.
We'll inquire with Apple's media relations team, but chances are this particular tempest is not worth spilling any tea over.
Share
On Friday, we got a rather nervous tip from reader Julian (echoed in this MacStories post) pointing to his Apple Discussions thread about...
Add a Comment
Finally got @mac.com email to work on iPhone 4 by setting it up as an IMAP email address. However, that doesn't allow my contacts, calendar, notes and find my iPhone to work on Mobileme cloud. Additionally had to add it back as a Mobileme so I could turn on the features that I wanted updated. On the Mobileme account I turned mail off. Not sure if the IMAP address will push my emails to my phone.
February 23 2011 at 2:13 PM Report abuse Permalink rate up rate down ReplyA long time user since iTools and it was free. Got new iPhone for Christmas and I cannot send email from my @mac.com. Tried syncing over iTunes and manually configuring IMAP on iPhone 4. Neither worked. Genius at Apple store said it wasn't possible and nothing lasts forever. Very disgusted especially since my Blackberry had no problem with this!
February 23 2011 at 12:34 PM Report abuse Permalink rate up rate down ReplyMichael Rose said 6:23PM on 1-23-2011
Daniel, did you read the post carefully? There is nothing stopping you from continuing to use your mac.com address if you follow the steps outlined in the Apple tech note.
------
Ok, so the work around is there, but let's remember one thing. Apple had seamless support for Mac.com addresses in place on the iphone up until now. Apple chose to make this more difficult. We pay $150/year for this service. I shouldn't have to select "other" and pursue an alternative process.
I've been slowly giving up on my Mac.com address and now want to cancel my membership altogether. Since there may be a few sites and friends that I have forgotten to tell that I'm switching to gmail I'd like my @mac.com address to just become some free alias attach to my dad's account that he's going to keep open for a while. Does anyone here know if that is possible?
January 26 2011 at 3:54 AM Report abuse Permalink rate up rate down ReplyIf I can't use my .mac email for another 11 years, I'm dropping the service.
January 23 2011 at 11:57 PM Report abuse Permalink rate up rate down ReplyExactly, 'me' is a reference to myself, as in 'it's all about me, me, me'. And while I am not at all repulsed by myself, I am definitely repulsed by the appearance of narcissism this creates, so I hope mac.com lives happily ever after.
January 23 2011 at 10:22 PM Report abuse Permalink rate up rate down ReplyI have had a couple of @mac.com addresses from day one. I have added aliases and been forced to use the @me.com on some of them. I guess Apple thinks the added branding awareness from the @mac.com is of less value since they make more money off their non-mac products. I have a friend who has to use my @me.com addresses cause for some reason the DNS server his mail client uses doesn't think the @mac.com is a valid address! I always have to put a special Reply to: address when I email him. I will be one of those people who think hard about dropping Mobile Me if Apple makes me use only the @me.com address. I already use the faster Dropbox for storage and can park my websites easily on GoDaddy so the need for MobileMe is only cause I'm too lazy to change.
January 23 2011 at 2:31 PM Report abuse Permalink rate up rate down ReplyI used to work for an ISP and this is par for the course.
They changes their domain three times and each time they let users use the old address for a while and eventually forced a switch to the new domain.
Apple appears to be in the process of doing this. Until recently when i used "Mobileme" webmail I could type in my username without the domain attached upon login.
Now unless I type the full address name@mac.com it is changed to name@me.com and it does not authenticate.
Apple changing the IOS to only allow @me.com for Mobileme is another indicator.
like many of the other commenters, I dislike the domain me.com as it does remind me of "Windows ME" more commonly referred to as "Windows, me".
I also dilike the name of the service "Mobileme". When it was announced I reactivated my .Mac account to ensure my address would stay @mac.com.
I was already planning on renewing but it did hasten my resolve. Additionally, I was unaware at the time that the majority of the services provided by the .Mac account were going to be removed under Mobileme.
Now the only reason I keep my Mobileme account is to keep my @mac.com email address.
If they force a change to @me.com, I like others who have commented will discontinue my Mobileme account.
Changing your email address is a pain. I have had to do it 5 times so far. And not all of the web services you use allow you to update your e-mail address, including the commenting system on TUAW.
What is wrong with the company that continues to make billions and trounce everyone else make .mac as "safe" to use as .gmail? I continue to worry that one day I won't have my .mac account, (either by choice, I no longer wish to fund the account, or by them deciding to oust it by the next best thing.)
As for my gmail account, at least I knowâat the momentâthat they won't be charging for it and no matter what ISP I use it will still be there. Not true of either my ISP or .mac, or even .me for that matter!
I wish they'd just bring back mac.com for everyone...
January 23 2011 at 7:45 AM Report abuse Permalink rate up rate down ReplyDeals of the Day
more deals- Apple iPhone 4 8GB for Verizon, AT&T, or Sprint for $50 + pickup at Best Buy
- Unlocked iPhone 4S 16GB for GSM (AT&T, T-Mobile) for $619 + free shipping
- Apple iMac Core i7 Quad 3.4GHz 27" w/ 24GB RAM, 2TB HDD for $2,677 + $29 s&h
- Used Apple Magic Mouse for $36 + $4 s&h
- 9-Piece iPhone Bundle, includes 1,900mAh battery for $8 + free shipping
- Skullcandy Riot Earbud Headphones for $10 + free shipping
39 Comments