Apple to pay $8M in damages over iPod playlist patent suit
An Eastern Texas District Court judge has ordered Apple to pay US$8 Million to Personal Audio LLC, after ruling that the iPod manufacturer infringed upon patents for downloadable playlists. Specifically, the court determined that Apple violated two generic patents with its support for downloading playlists on the iPhone and the iPod.
According to Bloomberg, one of the patents addressed an "audio program player including a dynamic program selection controller" while the other was for "audio program distribution and playback system." Note that, while eight million bucks is nothing to sneeze at, it's less than the $84 million Personal Audio initially sought in 2009.
That initial suit also included Archos, Coby, and Sirius XM, all of whom settled in 2010, after concluding that they wouldn't be able to finance a challenge of the final verdict.
Share
An Eastern Texas District Court judge has ordered Apple to pay US$8 Million to Personal Audio LLC, after ruling that the iPod...
Add a Comment
I sometimes wonder if the judges and jurors in those east texas courts get a cut of whatever gets awarded? There ar so many patents and the trolls need to be cut down.
July 11 2011 at 8:13 AM Report abuse Permalink rate up rate down ReplyDid the term "generic" get lost somewhere in the translation from street speak to legalese? I don't see how any court, with the exception of Eastern Texas, can rule in the favor of a generic patent. It usually encompasses a variety of things, but no one thing in particular. I think I've become more upset with Texas than the patent trolls.
July 10 2011 at 3:23 PM Report abuse Permalink rate up rate down ReplyBecause the costs and risks are high, defendants may settle , as Archos, Coby, and Sirius XM did, even non-meritorious suits they consider frivolous, for several hundred thousand dollars. The uncertainty and unpredictability of the outcome of jury trials also encourages settlement. Eight million is quite hefty.
July 10 2011 at 1:25 AM Report abuse Permalink rate up rate down ReplySomeone should end this startup issues. There is no sense for letting companies write patents on :
a) Clear things that every 3 years kid can invent.
b) Things that are so basic like download data or metadata. No, matter what it is.
If the patent were invented before the wheel. We were still living in caves.
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=dySXl0Oxijw&feature=player_embedded
$8 Million dollars is something to sneeze at. At least where Apple is concerned. How many iPods and other iOS devices have they sold over the years? 500 million is probably a good guess. This is like 1.6 cents per device.
July 09 2011 at 3:03 PM Report abuse Permalink rate up rate down ReplyCrazy...Soon someone will sue Apple for "electronic device" patent...Or generic playing music device...this is trolling..
July 09 2011 at 2:41 PM Report abuse Permalink rate up rate down ReplyTrolling when someone sues Apple but when Apple sues someone they are protecting their rights? Not all patent lawsuits are put forth by patent trolls.
July 09 2011 at 3:04 PM Report abuse Permalink rate up rate down ReplyWhile I agree that not all patent lawsuits are put forth by trolls, from TFA the company involved is "Personal Audio, LLC" and just so happens to reside in the most favorable areas of the country where patent troll companies can thrive... If it looks like a duck... I think I'll go patent the name 'Wayne' move to Texas and file a lawsuit... I'm not trolling, I'm protecting my rights... :)
July 09 2011 at 9:06 PM Report abuse Permalink rate up rate downPersonally, I think you should actually have to produce something in order to protect a patient (not necessarily sell, but at least make something). If you patient an "audio program that transfers playlists to a mobile device" then you need to actually MAKE that in order for your patient to apply. A patient violation would then be considered if the products are similar or the methods are similar (and it should be easier to determine if this is "patenting the wheel").
July 10 2011 at 10:59 AM Report abuse Permalink rate up rate downDeals of the Day
more deals- Acoustic Research Digital Photo Frame with iPod Dock for $50 + free shipping
- Targus Truss Case for iPad and iPad 2 for $15 + free shipping
- Apple iPhone 4 8GB for Verizon, AT&T, or Sprint for $50 + pickup at Best Buy
- Unlocked iPhone 4S 16GB for GSM (AT&T, T-Mobile) for $619 + free shipping
- Apple iMac Core i7 Quad 3.4GHz 27" w/ 24GB RAM, 2TB HDD for $2,677 + $29 s&h
- Used Apple Magic Mouse for $36 + $4 s&h
9 Comments