Bookle: Hands-on with the new Mac EPUB reader app
![]()
During Apple's January education event, one thing that many Apple bloggers were waiting for never appeared -- a version of iBooks for Mac. While that was a surprising omission, at least there's a new and well-implemented Mac book reader app that handles the EPUB format of most iBooks with ease and grace. Bookle (US$9.99) is a collaboration of Take Control Books publisher Adam Engst and Australian developer Peter Lewis of Stairways Software.
Bookle, which is available in the Mac App Store, reads non-DRM versions of EPUB books from the iBookstore. This is one of my few concerns about the app at this point, as many iBooks are copy-protected by digital rights management encryption. As Engst points out in the Introduction of the "Take Control of Bookle (1.0)" ebook that ships with the app, the main goal of this version of the app was to "get a program out quickly that can help you read our ebooks in the here and now." He admits that they may not be able to add support for reading DRM-encrypted ebooks, since "Neither Apple nor Amazon will license their DRM systems, and while Adobe will license Adobe Digital Editions, it's a six-figure cost...".
Getting that out of the way, let's take a look at the app. Bookle's icon is gloriously and beautifully designed (see image at top), which gives you an idea of the attention to detail given to the entire app. Bookle stores the EPUB files in the Application Support directory due to the Mac App Store sandboxing requirements, and books are easy to add to the Bookle library. You can use File > Open, drag the EPUB file onto the Bookle icon in the Dock or Finder, or just double-click the EPUB file.
Once the EPUBs are in the Library, they appear in a sidebar on the left side of the app's window. The sidebar of Bookle displays the list of ebooks and the table of contents of the ebook being read. At the top of the window are buttons to go back and forth in your reading history or up or down in chapters. There are also controls for changing the ebook's font and the font size, as well as setting the background color of the page.
As with many Lion apps, Bookle supports full-screen mode. I found this to be overkill on a 27" iMac, but it works very nicely on a smaller screen such as that on an 11" MacBook Air. If you close a window or quit the app, Bookle brings you right back to the last page you were reading when you open the book again. Bookle also has support for multi-touch gestures. Swiping two fingers left or right changes chapters when using a trackpad. There's also support for text-to-speech, so if you'd prefer to have an ebook read to you by your Mac, that's easy to do.
If you want to do side-by-side reading of two texts, all you need to do with Bookle is open each book in a separate window. I found this to be useful while making a comparison of two editions of one ebook, and I think it could also be very helpful if you're reading an ebook in one window and an explanatory text in the other window.
I mentioned earlier that I had a few concerns about Bookle -- one glaring omission is the inability to search a book for a specific word or phrase. I'd also like to see the ability to add bookmarks and make notations included in future versions of the app.
I'm sure that some TUAW readers will balk at Bookle's $10 price tag when Calibre is available for free. Frankly, I find Calibre to be a bloated (210.8 MB compared to Bookle's 4.1 MB) and poorly-implemented app that's horrible to use, and for reading ebooks it actually launches a separate ebook app called E-book Viewer. Bookle looks good, and is an excellent 1.0 implementation of a Mac ebook reader. I can't wait to see what the team of Lewis and Engst is able to add to Bookle in future versions.
Share
During Apple's January education event, one thing that many Apple bloggers were waiting for never appeared -- a version of iBooks for...
Add a Comment
This looks amazing! It will especially be great for those who have trouble reading iBooks on the small iPhone screens.
February 13 2012 at 10:52 AM Report abuse Permalink rate up rate down ReplyHave to chime in in agreement with the pro-Calibre crowd. I don't think Calibre is great as an e-reader, but then I have never wanted to read an epub on my computer. Calibre is bulkier because it's a workhorse, and I use it to collect my ebooks because once in Calibre, I can easily edit metadata and move the books to multiple devices in multiple formats. I'm sure Bookle is fine, and if I wanted to read epub files on my desktop, I would probably consider a dedicated, slimmer reader like Bookle to be well worth the money, but it wouldn't be an alternative to Calibre, because Calibre does a lot more than just display epubs.
February 13 2012 at 9:40 AM Report abuse Permalink rate up rate down ReplyHmmm ... I'm not quite happy how bookle only displays 1 page on the mac at a time (when the wide screen is perfect for 2), aligning picture-pages top-left. Also flipping the pages is not very intuitive for me (scrolling only, no apparent cursor-key support). Agree with "sip" that I would like a refund / won't use bookle in this version and can't recommend it.
I also bought/tried BookReader, and the UI/presentation seems much better to me. In a reader app, presentation matters a lot to me. However BookReader had problems with correctly aligning multiple picture-elements on a page for me, so I can't recommend it as well.
I'm happy with Calibre, but I wish I could find a way to disable its annoying page change animation. That sort of thing is a flaw in lots of reader apps. I haven't tried BookReader, but the fact that the author emphasizes its "realistic" page turns puts me off.
February 13 2012 at 7:13 AM Report abuse Permalink rate up rate down ReplyI bought this application -- pity you can't get a refund from the Mac App Store.
If you use iBooks on the iPad, the only alternative for Mac OS is an app called BookReader, also available from the Mac App Store. I use this on the MBAir when the wife or grandkid demand the use of the iPad.
(I have no connections to the BookReader application)
epubreader is a free addon for Firefox that reads epubs, lets you select the font, size, text and background colors, and even does double column formatting. Did I mention that it was free?
February 12 2012 at 9:44 AM Report abuse Permalink rate up rate down ReplyWhy not compare it to three free ebook readers: Adobe Digital Editions, B&N Nook for Mac, and Kindle for Mac? (You can very easily convert an EPUB to a MOBI for use with the Kindle app)
February 12 2012 at 4:12 AM Report abuse Permalink rate up rate down ReplyComparing Bookle to Calibre is like comparing a screwdriver to a machine shop. Of course it is bigger, it does 10000 things the screwdriver can't!
If you want to compare it to something similar, compare it to the Nook app or to Stanza or even Tofu, which are all free dedicated ebook readers.
Agreed. Calibre is a database/converter/news aggregator that can handle any ebook format you throw at it. Compared that that, this new app is a one-trick pony with a pretty interface.
February 13 2012 at 2:28 AM Report abuse Permalink rate up rate down ReplyAdobe Digital Editions is a 6 figure license cost? That's crazy considering how weak the encryption is and the fact that Adobe doesn't seem very eager to patch it.
February 11 2012 at 10:32 PM Report abuse Permalink rate up rate down ReplyI think they were comparing the DRM from Adobe® Content Server 4. It is only 5 figures though.. Plus a per-license royalty + required maintenance. Digital Editions is the reader for Content Server 4 output. It is a horrendous program though.
I'm surprised nobody has brought up BookReader, which does the same thing as Bookle, and has been around for years..
Calibre, on the other hand, does something Bookle is unlikely to do any time soon - convert between most of the common e-book formats, and with the help of some easily found plugins, strip off that inconvenient DRM. Use each for what it's best at - Calibre for producing usable ePub files, Bookle for actually reading them.
February 11 2012 at 7:55 PM Report abuse Permalink rate up rate down ReplyCalibre allows you to read them too and it will track your location so you start in the same place when you return.
February 11 2012 at 10:24 PM Report abuse Permalink rate up rate down ReplyDeals of the Day
more deals- Acoustic Research Digital Photo Frame with iPod Dock for $50 + free shipping
- Apple iPhone 4 8GB for Verizon, AT&T, or Sprint for $50 + pickup at Best Buy
- Unlocked iPhone 4S 16GB for GSM (AT&T, T-Mobile) for $619 + free shipping
- Apple iMac Core i7 Quad 3.4GHz 27" w/ 24GB RAM, 2TB HDD for $2,677 + $29 s&h
- Used Apple Magic Mouse for $36 + $4 s&h
- Skullcandy Riot Earbud Headphones for $10 + free shipping
13 Comments