Don't miss Joystiq's up-to-the-minute live coverage of E3!

Will the iPhone cannibalize iPod sales? Or vice versa?

Yesterday, Steve Jobs introduced the iPhone. It is clearly the next generation of iPod. It's the full-screen video iPod we've waited for. It's the full-color fully-designed interface we've waited for. It's the fully-connected wifi and bluetooth device we've waited for. And that doesn't even mention the built in speakers and microphone.

So why does it have to be an iPhone? Surely there's a huge market out there who wants all these features but who doesn't want the Cingular piece of the action. Of course, many of you will rightly point out that one can purchase the iPhone, maybe even use the iPhone to good effect, without using the phone itself. The included two year contract is a bit of a stumbling block, especially if monthly charges (which I'm still really unclear about) apply.

So why not offer a phone-less iPod? It doesn't have to wait for FCC approval except insofar as any Bluetooth or WiFi device might need some paperwork done. Why not sell a basic "true fullscreen video iPod" at the $299 price point that removing the phone hardware might allow, to the large market of iPod upgraders who'd jump on buying one like a starving Georgia Tech student on barbeque?

My guess is that introducing a phone-less iPod would cannibalize early sales of the iPhone. Of all the goodies introduced about the phone, it's the phone component that's the least glamorous. Sure, a lot of us would pay a premium to carry fewer gadgets in our pockets. Combining the iPod and the phone and a lot of the PocketPC features makes sense--and I tell you as a PocketPC user, that the iPhone does not score too well on the PocketPC range of capabilities--but it also takes a lot of choice out of the equation for those of us under existing phone contracts who are looking for a better iPod and not necessarily an iPhone.

So when do we see an actual G6 iPod sans the phone connectivity? Your guess is as good as mine.

Related Headlines

Reader Comments (Page 1 of 2)

TUAW Features

iphone app store tuaw tests
Mac 101 ask-tuaw
Mac News
WWDC (251)
.Mac (64)
Accessories (639)
Airport (75)
Analysis / Opinion (1358)
Apple (1659)
Apple Corporate (561)
Apple Financial (190)
Apple History (48)
Apple Professional (54)
Apple TV (162)
Audio (447)
Bad Apple (120)
Beta Beat (152)
Blogging (85)
Bluetooth (17)
Bugs/Recalls (56)
Cult of Mac (873)
Deals (219)
Desktops (115)
Developer (262)
Education (99)
eMac (10)
Enterprise (139)
Features (403)
Freeware (386)
Gaming (376)
Graphic Design (33)
Hardware (1286)
Holidays (37)
Humor (578)
iBook (65)
iLife (235)
iMac (184)
Internet (334)
Internet Tools (1321)
iTS (977)
iTunes (814)
iWork (22)
Leopard (370)
Mac mini (112)
Mac Pro (53)
MacBook (202)
MacBook Air (79)
Macbook Pro (220)
MobileMe (35)
Multimedia (445)
Odds and ends (1450)
Open Source (279)
OS (915)
Peripherals (210)
Podcasting (182)
Podcasts (91)
Portables (197)
PowerBook (135)
PowerMac G5 (50)
Retail (594)
Retro Mac (48)
Rig of the Week (42)
Rumors (633)
Software (4344)
Software Update (417)
Steve Jobs (252)
Stocking Stuffers (50)
Surveys and Polls (97)
Switchers (112)
The Woz (34)
TUAW Business (242)
Universal Binary (281)
UNIX / BSD (61)
Video (905)
Weekend Review (83)
WIN Business (47)
Wireless (85)
Xserve (39)
iPhone/iPod News
iPhone (1620)
iPod Family (2065)
App Store (81)
SDK (19)
Mac Events
One More Thing (27)
Liveblog (1)
Other Events (226)
Macworld (489)
Mac Learning
AppleScript (3)
Ask TUAW (103)
Blogs (85)
Books (26)
Books and Blogs (62)
Cool tools (445)
Hacks (464)
How-tos (486)
Interviews (44)
Mods (187)
Productivity (590)
Reviews (112)
Security (156)
Terminal Tips (59)
Tips and tricks (567)
Troubleshooting (168)
TUAW Features
iPhone 101 (34)
TUAW Labs (3)
Blast From the Past (17)
TUAW Tips (144)
Flickr Find (36)
Found Footage (86)
Mac 101 (94)
TUAW Interview (31)
Widget Watch (198)
The Daily Best (1)
TUAW Faceoff (5)

RESOURCES

RSS NEWSFEEDS

Powered by Blogsmith

Sponsored Links

The Unofficial Apple Weblog (TUAW) bloggers (30 days)

#BloggerPostsCmts
1Cory Bohon844
2Robert Palmer5839
3Steven Sande5423
4Dave Caolo480
5Mat Lu4010
6Erica Sadun333
7Scott McNulty320
8Mike Schramm201
9Brett Terpstra191
10Michael Rose1221
11Giles Turnbull80
12Christina Warren821
13Chris Ullrich30
14Joshua Ellis23
15Kent Pribbernow10
16Jason Clarke10

Featured Galleries

Macworld 2008 Keynote
Macworld 2008 Build-up
Apple Vanity Plates
DiscPainter
Crash Bandicoot Nitro Kart 3D
Macworld Expo 2007 show floor
Apple Texas Hold 'Em
The Macworld Faithful in Line
iPhone First Look

 

    Most Commented On (7 days)

    Recent Comments

    More Apple Analysis

    More from AOL Money and Finance

    Other Weblogs Inc. Network blogs you might be interested in: