Filed under: iPod Family, iMac, Apple, iPhone
The new iMac and iPhone, separated at birth?
During the deluge of news coming out of Apple today I paused for a second and thought, 'Hmm, the new iMac kind of looks like a big old iPhone.' Luckily I was not the only one to notice this. The good folks at Signal v.s Noise (the blog from 37signals, the makers of Basecamp amongst other things) also noticed. They point out that the previous incarnation of the iMac took its design cues from the iPod. Consumer electronics shaping the design of a consumer computer, makes sense to me.Does this mean that those fabled touch screen iPods will look like iPhones? Wouldn't surprise me a bit.
I would like to know what you think of the iMac's new look. Sound off in the comments.
![TUAW [Cafepress]](http://www.blogsmithmedia.com/www.tuaw.com/media/tuaw-cafepress-promo.png)
Reader Comments (Page 1 of 3)
Raffi said 7:37PM on 8-07-2007
I don't really like the black on titanium thing that they have going on there. It just doesn't work for me, or maybe that's because I have a black macbook with a white apple. It just looks ... off.
Reply
nano said 7:39PM on 8-07-2007
Hate this silver look. It's too "American" like it wants to look like a car or something.
Reply
Bill Olson said 7:40PM on 8-07-2007
I need to see it in person (should have in the next couple of days) but I like the looks from the pictures I've seen at Apple's website.
I'll just have to stick with my white 24" iMac for awhile longer.
PS: WHY, WHY, WHY are the bluetooth keyboards not exactly the same (except for the USB ports of course) as the wired keyboard? #@$*&#$*&#. I realize that there must be people screaming for the bluetooth one to be less wide so they can use it in cramped spots. But why not have two of them? One wide and one not. Not I won't be buying either of them and sticking with my current iMac keyboard.
Reply
required said 7:47PM on 8-07-2007
the logo is horsey, otherwise it looks nice, maybe someone will sell something that can mask/tone down the logo
Reply
David Chartier said 7:50PM on 8-07-2007
No, I think this means the new iPods will look like Mac minis, so the Mac minis will get redesign as Mac Pros which will cause the entire universe of Apple products to implode...
this could be dangerous.
Reply
DBrim said 7:59PM on 8-07-2007
I'll start off by saying that I am definitely not a fan of the chin, personally. If I were to design the iMac, I'd eliminate the chin entirely and make it thicker.
However...
The chin serves a purpose. It's the way that it's identified as an Apple product, not just another competitor. The ability to recognize an Apple product from a mile away has always been one of the most things in the company design philosophy, it seems. This iMac certainly fits the bill for that.
If you really really wanted to keep the chin, though, I would have made it black, with a metal apple. That would look nice.
My biggest real pet peeve (I can get past the chin) is the lack of option for matte displays. I hate glossy displays, and as a photographer I would never go out and buy a glossy display. I sincerely hope that this does not indicate future trends in Apple.
Reply
Steve Simitzis said 8:02PM on 8-07-2007
I personally love it. My first reaction was "ooh, an iPhone on a stick". I also like that they're moving away from plastic.
Reply
Nathan C. said 8:22PM on 8-07-2007
i was so excited for the new iMac because i waited to buy an iMac so a year now for leopard. But when i saw the new design i was CRUSHED. There hasnt been a single apple product that i didnt say WOW that looks awesome! How did they come up with that design? This has to be the first apple product that i think is ugly. I know its hard for me too, never have i used the adjective ugly with an apple product before. I guess im going to take advantage of stores clearing out the old sexy white iMac =).
Reply
Timothy Chaten said 8:28PM on 8-07-2007
I love this new iMac: an iPhone converted to an iMac :)
Everything from the screen (the iPhone has the same wonderful glass screen) to it coming with a cleaning cloth. This is a wonderful design and am looking forward to seeing it in person.
I am furious however at the lack of an option for a full sized bluetooth keyboard. I use the apple bt constantly and was hoping for a nice new thin bt. The work I do requires the use of a number pad! So this is terrible! But I love the new iMac. It is wonderful and amazing, not quite sure what the Core 2 Duo Extreme is how does it differ from the Core 2 Duo?
Reply
NK said 8:34PM on 8-07-2007
Nice to see Scott back to blogging! I had assumed that he was depressed without an iPhone and had to sit high on a mountain top to reflect.
Reply
iGO said 8:57PM on 8-07-2007
It should have been ALL black. Then that stupid border would just blend in. As in the past with Apple, I hope that by the time Leopard starts shipping, these new iMacs will get those quiet little upgrades that just irk early adopters, like an all black option and a full size wireless bluetooth keyboard. I'm buying one for sure, the 24"- 2.8Ghz, when Leopard and the iLife 08 are bundled in.
Reply
Jay said 8:57PM on 8-07-2007
The new iMacs are ugly. They'd be fine without that black rim around the screen. The aluminum is nice, I even like the black back. Just not the big black bezel.
And here I was, all set to go out and buy a new iPod. I guess I can dream for early September?
Reply
Andrew said 9:17PM on 8-07-2007
I agree with Nathan C. This is the first ugly Mac product I have seen. If they had gone ALL aluminum or ALL black, it could have been stunning. As it is, it's like an iPhone with a silver beer belly.
Abysmal!
Reply
Stephen Macklin said 9:28PM on 8-07-2007
I think it looks like a 1972 vision of what a computer would look like 30 years in the future. Didn't they have something that looked like this in Logan's Run? Or was it THX1138?
Come to think of it, it might have been Sleeper.
Reply
Reg Muffet said 9:29PM on 8-07-2007
Will have to see it in the flesh.
In general I do find metal finishes to look more stylish and professional than plastic.
(Which is why I was hoping for a 12" PowerBook G4 replacement aka "ultraportable" today, to substitute for my 13" black MacBook, which is just a few inches too wide and looks cheaper than it should. Maybe by MacWorld SF 2008.)
Hopefully the new design will improve the iMac. I haven't much liked any of the designs since the deep indigo blues and ruby reds of the 1999 era iMacs. They had character.
(It all went wrong after flower power and blue dalmation!)
Reply
Jon said 10:30PM on 8-07-2007
They look superb in the flesh - so well designed.
Pics here from the 5th Avenue Store this evening
http://theappleofmyi.com/blog/?p=1054
Reply
Ryan said 11:35PM on 8-07-2007
I think it's ugly, the black ring is absolutely hideous. That ring is just wasted space, why not eliminate that and make the screen bigger, or make that black ring aluminum like the rest of the body.
All aluminum or all black would be better, but a choice would be the best. I hate the glossy display and hope they give the matte option. I have always hated glossy displays, and as a graphic designer i'll never purchase a computer with a glossy display.
The keyboard is terrible, from the pictures ive seen the aluminum looks cheap and the white keys are ugly on top of it. Why would you take the numpad off the wireless version? Apple really screwed this one up.
Reply
Micah Vanderlinden said 11:44PM on 8-07-2007
I am happy to see a new iMac, the aluminum looks good. I do not NOT like that the only option is glossy! Glossy?!?! I thought it was a mistake to put it as an option for the laptops. Have people ever tried to look at a glossy screen in the sun!?!? This was a large mistake and it puts off people interested in the fine details concerned with video and photography. Well we stick with the pro line anyways. I guess this iMac was really meant for a consumer crowd who just wanted a new shiny toy.
Apple, please offer an option without the gloss like is available for the MBPs.
P.S. The black outline detracts from the whole design. It looks like the screen should extend further but just doesn't.
Reply
Micah Vanderlinden said 11:54PM on 8-07-2007
It even has a glare in the new rotating iMac commercials at the end! Who do they think they are fooling?
Reply
Jim of Davao said 11:59PM on 8-07-2007
So people are putting off from buying the new iMac because of the design? They don't care it's much faster and better than the old ones? That's messed up.
Reply