Filed under: Cult of Mac, Odds and ends, iPhone
Denver man hacks thumbs for more efficient iPhone use - literally [Updated]
Keyboards on handheld devices and smartphones have often been debated in terms of how much work they actually let you get done. Tiny displays, limited functionality, itty-bitty keyboard buttons and now the iPhone's entirely virtual keyboard whose keys can be hard to hit for some people have given folks something to talk about. Taking matters to a level that I believe is unheard of in the technology world, however, 28-year-old Thomas Martel in Bonnie Brae (a Denver, CO neighborhood) decided to solve his large handed problem by surgically altering his thumbs to make it easier to use his iPhone.Through a procedure called "whittling" which the North Denver News described, an incision was made into each of Martel's thumbs. The bone was shaved down, muscles were realigned and his thumbnail was modified to help bring it all together. His new 'streamlined' thumbs may look out of place in relation to his other fingers, but Martel says all the time and frustration he'll save should make the surgery pay for itself in ten to fifteen years. Of course Dr. Spars, the man who helped develop the procedure, is excited about this new avenue for plastic surgery; it aint just for makin' pretty faces anymore - now you too can have your very own iPhone-optimized thumbs for the low, low price of... well the North Denver News article doesn't say. My guess on the procedure's price though is somewhere in the range of 'a heckuva lot', given that time and frustration are tough things to add up over fifteen years. Depreciating values and market shifts in the value of frustration alone are enough to make one's head spin.
What about you, TUAW readers? Anyone planning on hacking their thumbs for more better iPhone usage? How about whittling out a spot in a thigh so the phone rests a little better? I'm thinking about bypassing an armband case altogether and simply chopping out a chunk of my arm for taking the iPhone running. Maybe I'll see what Dr. Nick's prices are like this week.
[Update 2: As some commenters have pointed out, this story has finally been officially claimed as satire by North Denver News. I guess the same ol' lesson that I have had to learn myself applies: if a news outlet typically known to print true stories (no matter how quirky they may be) tries to pull off satire, they need to let readers know up front (i.e. - a tiny link that's added at the bottom of the article just above a paid advertisement post-publication doesn't quite cut it). In summary: no one had their thumbs surgically altered to work with an iPhone more efficiently; nothing more to see here folks.]
[Update: As these stories sometimes go, it appears that this might not all be true. Richard Martin at InformationWeek did some digging for Dr. Spars and James Benfly, the author of the article at North Denver News. Benfly hasn't returned any of Martin's calls, and Martin finds it a bit suspicious that there is no phone book listing for a Dr. Robert Fox Spars in the Denver area. While I too found it a little odd that Denver North News is using what looks like a default template for the open source Joomla software to power their site, a friend did some checking and found four Thomas Martel's in the Denver area. I also don't find it at all strange that Dr. Spars isn't listed in the phone book, because he could very well be listed under his practice's name which Denver North News didn't list in their article. Still, it was worth mentioning that folks are punching some potential holes in the story. I'll see if I can follow up to get any more solid information.]
[via iPhone Alley]


![TUAW [Cafepress]](http://www.blogsmithmedia.com/www.tuaw.com/media/tuaw-cafepress-promo.png)


Reader Comments (Page 1 of 2)
Joel Bruner said 11:07AM on 8-11-2007
First Comment... and really the only comment that can be made: Ewwwwww!
Reply
Steve said 11:07AM on 8-11-2007
A little fact checking with some of your sister sites would show that this story has already been called into considerable doubt.
As per Engadget - http://www.informationweek.com/blog/main/archives/2007/08/thumbs_surgical.html
Reply
dylan said 11:20AM on 8-11-2007
shenanigans :)
Reply
makesense said 11:38AM on 8-11-2007
apple products make users do the darndest things, usually narror their mind, now narrow their thumbs
Reply
Matt S. said 1:16PM on 8-11-2007
The name "Denver North News" drew my suspicions. I've lived in Colorado for most of my life and, as far as I know, Denver only has two newspapers: The Denver Post and The Rocky Mountain News.
Reply
Ryan said 1:21PM on 8-11-2007
There are also no muscles in your hands.
Reply
Catt said 2:09PM on 8-11-2007
Sounds like a load of tripe to me...
Reply
MrShabby said 2:16PM on 8-11-2007
Quite possibly the most retarded thing I've ever heard.
Reply
Matthew said 3:04PM on 8-11-2007
"As these stories sometimes go, it appears that this might not all be true."
No shit. Really?
Reply
icruise said 2:55PM on 8-11-2007
Can we try to use just a little critical thinking before posting stories like this? Do you think it's actually possible to have "thumb reduction surgery?" Do you think the AMA would allow a plastic surgeon to perform a surgery like this? Do you think that there was time for this technique to be developed, and for the man in question to have it done and be healed completely in the 4-5 weeks since the iPhone has been out?
Did it ever occur to you think this was someone's lame attempt at saying that the iPhone's buttons were too small?
Reply
Slevin said 3:15PM on 8-11-2007
Ryan,
actually you are wrong. As someone who took gross human anatomy there are muscles in your hands. While the muscles to open and close the palm of your hand to make a fist are located in the forearm the muscles to move the fingers are located in the fingers.
Reply
Eric said 3:55PM on 8-11-2007
It is fake. There is a link at the end of the article to another article from the Editor saying the article is a "satirical social commentary."
http://northdenvernews.com/content/view/925/2/
Reply
Adam said 12:44AM on 8-12-2007
As per above, your starting to post some ridiculous stories. This and the wowinsider Blogsmith blog are sliding down hill as the 'hooligan' blogs on my RSS feeds. Taking care to post quality vs quantity is always recommended when it comes to pleasing your readers.
And with something this far out in left field - how could you possibly not check your facts first?
*shakes head.
Reply
south said 12:44AM on 8-12-2007
seriously, though, i do cut my thumbnails in a way that leaves them a bit longer on one side and thus easier for phone typing. i live in a country where the iphone isn't available, so maybe if they ever release it here i can go back to having normal fingernails again.
Reply
garrick said 12:52AM on 8-12-2007
God, Chartier. What's the first rule of journalism?
ATTRIBUTION ATTRIBUTION ATTRIBUTION.
You should have fact-checked this BEFORE making a fool of yourself. Again.
Reply
David Chartier said 1:17AM on 8-12-2007
Guys, I did check out the article before posting, and I found this already written about at numerous sources. I looked over the North Denver News site and found that it was an existing, legitimate news site. I also saw the InformationWeek post and didn't agree that not find a doctor listed in the phone book and a reporter not returning calls immediately could be grounds for a story to be false or, in this case, merely satire. Doctors often aren't listed in the phone book, and a reporter not making or returning phone calls on a weekend doesn't sound that crazy to me.
It wasn't until later today that North Denver News finally updated their original article with a tiny link at the bottom about it being satire, and chastising the rest of the tech world for running with this story when they didn't give us any warning in the first place. Heck, even Engadget got bit by the bug, as they've had two updates themselves: http://www.engadgetmobile.com/2007/08/10/man-has-thumbs-altered-to-improve-iphone-dexterity/
As I stated in my second update, and it's a lesson I've had to learn myself in the past: a site like The Onion or BBSpot that is known for doing satire gets away with saying anything being that's what they do, and that's why we love them. A site that posts legitimate news and other trinkets of industry interestingness such as North Denver News or ourselves can't get away with satire like that. The audience comes to their site for actual news and other tidbits, so something like this gets taken seriously by peers.
Ultimately, it seems like the world is going to continue, and we're all going to live, right? I checked facts (not simply speculation) the best I could before posting, North Denver News finally cleared everything up and I updated the post as soon as I caught it. All's well.
Reply
Martin said 9:20PM on 8-12-2007
Fox Spars = Fox pass = faux pas with bad pronunciation? Kinda cute.
Reply
David Chartier said 9:03AM on 8-13-2007
#17: Haha, never thought of that. Good eye.
Reply
Bob R said 2:20PM on 8-13-2007
Please see http://www.snopes.com/humor/iftrue/iphonethumb.asp
This paper is satirycal...
Reply
chewbee said 2:15PM on 8-13-2007
It's always a good idea to do a gut-check, too. As Gruber put it, "Unsurprisingly, the story was a complete hoax."
Reply