Different name, fashion's the same: Styledash is now the StyleList Blog!

Rogue Amoeba on code signing, iPhone SDK

Mike Ash at Rogue Amoeba has published his fairly extensive thoughts on Apple's code signing policies and plans, as well as how they relate to the iPhone SDK. He makes some solid points and elaborates on thoughts that are being bandied about elsewhere on the 'net. In his critique of some points in the iPhone SDK announcement, his concerns regarding the "banned" iPhone apps are quite valid, in my opinion. Out of the list of apps to be denied (illegal, malicious, unforeseen, privacy, porn and bandwidth hog), he picks out a couple that are of concern.

In regards to the issue of "porn", he notes that "...Apple is making moral judgements of the apps they sign." To me, it seems like Apple chose the safe option and just categorically denied materials that could sully their reputation, which I personally think was a good (if not obvious) choice. But the question arises, as it always does, about the definition of porn and obscenity... and who makes the call. Apple, as gatekeeper, gets to make those decisions for all of us. I can see some torrid debates arising in the future.

Also of particular (and potentially more controversial) concern is the category "unforeseen," which provides a fairly broad scope for Apple to add to the list later. Again, it's likely a smart decision on Apple's part and a good way of sealing off loopholes without making the list read like a legal contract (see "License Agreement"), but leaves open the option for some heavy-handed control over what you can put on your iPhone.

Of course, this initial list is incomplete, with restrictions outlined in the SDK license agreement (as pointed out in Rogue Amoeba's subsequent post). If you take an interest in this debate, be sure to check out Mike's post, "Code Signing and You."

Related Headlines

Reader Comments (Page 1 of 3)

TUAW Features

back-to-school
Mac 101 ask-tuaw
Mac News
WWDC (251)
.Mac (66)
Accessories (652)
Airport (75)
Analysis / Opinion (1424)
Apple (1698)
Apple Corporate (580)
Apple Financial (200)
Apple History (51)
Apple Professional (54)
Apple TV (164)
Audio (450)
Bad Apple (131)
Beta Beat (155)
Blogging (87)
Bluetooth (19)
Bugs/Recalls (57)
Cult of Mac (879)
Deals (225)
Desktops (116)
Developer (282)
Education (110)
eMac (10)
Enterprise (147)
Features (412)
Freeware (399)
Gaming (397)
Graphic Design (38)
Hardware (1308)
Holidays (37)
Humor (589)
iBook (66)
iLife (240)
iMac (185)
Internet (340)
Internet Tools (1342)
iTS (982)
iTunes (823)
iWork (23)
Leopard (376)
Mac mini (112)
Mac Pro (54)
MacBook (206)
MacBook Air (83)
Macbook Pro (226)
MobileMe (47)
Multimedia (459)
Odds and ends (1489)
Open Source (282)
OS (940)
Peripherals (214)
Podcasting (183)
Podcasts (95)
Portables (198)
PowerBook (136)
PowerMac G5 (51)
Retail (612)
Retro Mac (50)
Rig of the Week (42)
Rumors (642)
Software (4459)
Software Update (428)
Steve Jobs (254)
Stocking Stuffers (50)
Surveys and Polls (98)
Switchers (114)
The Woz (35)
TUAW Business (257)
Universal Binary (281)
UNIX / BSD (61)
Video (908)
Weekend Review (84)
WIN Business (47)
Wireless (89)
Xserve (39)
iPhone/iPod News
iPhone (1789)
iPod Family (2118)
App Store (158)
SDK (29)
Mac Events
One More Thing (27)
Liveblog (2)
Other Events (226)
Macworld (489)
Mac Learning
AppleScript (4)
Ask TUAW (107)
Blogs (85)
Books (26)
Books and Blogs (62)
Cool tools (451)
Hacks (472)
How-tos (490)
Interviews (44)
Mods (191)
Productivity (591)
Reviews (114)
Security (167)
Terminal Tips (66)
Tips and tricks (575)
Troubleshooting (173)
TUAW Features
iPhone 101 (36)
TUAW Labs (4)
Blast From the Past (19)
TUAW Tips (150)
Flickr Find (38)
Found Footage (90)
Mac 101 (111)
TUAW Interview (31)
Widget Watch (198)
The Daily Best (1)
TUAW Faceoff (6)

RESOURCES

RSS NEWSFEEDS

Powered by Blogsmith

Sponsored Links

The Unofficial Apple Weblog (TUAW) bloggers (30 days)

#BloggerPostsCmts
1Cory Bohon551
2Robert Palmer5339
3Steven Sande4915
4Mike Schramm250
5Erica Sadun231
6Michael Rose2328
7Dave Caolo210
8Giles Turnbull190
9Mat Lu188
10Christina Warren1328
11Brett Terpstra120
12TUAW Blogger70
13Victor Agreda, Jr.512
14Scott McNulty10
15Jason Clarke11

Featured Galleries

DNC Macs
Macworld 2008 Keynote
Macworld 2008 Build-up
Apple Vanity Plates
DiscPainter
Crash Bandicoot Nitro Kart 3D
Macworld Expo 2007 show floor
Apple Texas Hold 'Em
The Macworld Faithful in Line

 

    Most Commented On (7 days)

    Recent Comments

    More Apple Analysis

    More from AOL Money and Finance

    Other Weblogs Inc. Network blogs you might be interested in: