A better App Store
How could the App Store be made better?
- Some means of trying software before you buy it It's frustrating, to say the least, that the only way to find out what an app is like is to buy it, unlike the 'try before you buy' scenario that's common with Mac apps. Sure, you can read the reviews, but they can't give you a complete reflection of the app's features, nor do they always offer fair comparisons between similar and competing apps. Example: you've bought FileMagnet, then Files comes out. Is one app better than the other? Might one suit your work habits better than the other? Is one a better value, or more stable, or have better features? The only way you can find out is by buying both. (Yes, the Ad Hoc distribution system exists for, well, ad hoc distribution, but it isn't the answer for consumer-level trying-before-buying.)
- Ensuring reviews are fair A lot of TUAW readers have contacted us about the unfairness of App Store reviews from people that haven't actually downloaded and tried the apps concerned. Some people add reviews based on the price (or screenshot) alone. Should that be allowed?
- Add a shopping cart At the moment, when you tap BUY, the next option is INSTALL. How about replacing INSTALL with an alert that says the app has been added to your cart, queue, or list? Then you could continue browsing, and return to the list later to confirm your purchases -- and remove anything that got in there by mistake.
How would you improve the App Store?
Share
How could the App Store be made better? Some means of trying software before you buy it It's frustrating, to say the least, that the...
Add a Comment
Narf.
http://www.betterappstore.com/ that is.
Hey you all, you should really look inside http://www. betterappstore.com/
Best Features: FAST fulltext based search (Apple App Store gives results mixed with music, that suckc), FAST Page reloads.
Some sort of method to allow outside developers to link purchases. So, for example, if The Omni Group wanted to offer a bundle where you buy OmniFocus the desktop application and OmniFocus for iPhone and iPod Touch they could provide a coupon code that is used on the App Store to affect the download.
August 08 2008 at 12:07 PM Report abuse Permalink rate up rate down ReplyWhat would be amazing would be the ability to swap, sell or give your apps away. Obviously currently once you buy an app it is locked through the DRM to your account, so if you don't like it or don't use it then there's nothing you can do with it.
If you could transfer your app(s) to another user then they could enjoy the apps you're not using. Just like people sell old books, CDs and the like. It wouldn't be too complicated for Apple to do, and would be really handy for all the people who've bought apps without being able to try them, and found they're don't like them.
No company would ever want to this. The reason is that it would cause both Apple and the developers to lose a ton of money. This is why videogame publishers HATE stores like GameStop. By selling prepaid games, GameStop makes money and the publishers get absolutely nothing because the game was already sold. If you could simply sell apps you've already downloaded, that takes away any customer from the app store who might have purchased the program. Why would you pay $9.99 for Super Monkey Ball from Apple when you can pay some random guy $4.99? Especially with a digital good, there's absolutely no loss of quality. Plus, the whole thing would inevitably be cracked and you would have even more widespread piracy. It would be great from a customer standpoint bu suicide from a business standpoint.
August 07 2008 at 10:30 AM Report abuse Permalink rate up rate down ReplyOk, so if everyone here agrees that "reviews" by people who obviously didn't buy the app don't belong in the Customer Review section...who the hell is writing all those "reviews"? :p
August 06 2008 at 9:50 PM Report abuse Permalink rate up rate down ReplyWhile Apple should fix these issues, people can help make the system work better without Apple doing anything at all:
1) Everyone should use the "was this review helpful" button, especially to mark bad reviews with a NO. Over time, the most helpful review *will* float to the top three and get read along with the star rating. (I think Apple should allow non-purchasers to review, but offer a "Have No Actual Experience With This" star button for them to use that doesn't affect the star rating.)
2) TUAW and other Mac sites can do *much* more in the way of comparative reviews of paid apps. We depend on you to help us judge between Files, FileMagnet, Annotator, etc. (For instance, today's review of Ecco Notes ended, roughly, "there are a bunch of voice note apps, I've tried some but not all, and this is my favorite." NOT helpful for anyone trying to decide which voice note app to pay for.) Make it a policy to do comparative reviews, or at least to list the competition to help us find similar apps.
Don't treat content like books as applications; it clutters up the store, and makes them hard to find (20 bibles, WTF?!).
August 06 2008 at 4:20 PM Report abuse Permalink rate up rate down Reply-YOU know... I don't think they should get rid of people being able to post 'too pricey', purely because it's valuable feedback for the developer!
However! How about adding a 'feedback' section/button? That'd solve the problem.
-Demo versions would be lovely.
- Getting rid of some of the crap on there. I'm temped to make an app of a piece of feces that you can poke and smudge and sell it for 99p/c. An ironic app!
- Apple, test the apps! The review process is meant to weed out the poor apps. Why isn't it?
- New apps section. Maybe even a section where you can browse 'new apps in past x days/week/month'. I'm tired of sifting through the store!
- This is an aesthetic thing, but since Apple (and it's fans) are all about aesthetics, how about getting some nice icons on apps? Some of the icons have no relevance to the app whatsoever.
I recently wrote a topic about this in my blog, Mobile Evolution: http://creativealgorithms.com/blog/?q=content/what-would-make-appstore-perfect
Some of the items noted have been fixed, but many are still pending.
I would like to see different ways to sort on the device--the iTunes desktop version has a lot more features, but I find I'm browsing more on my device. I would also like to see some policing of competitors posting free promos in their competitors reviews. Some are so blatant it's sickening.
I really like the Shopping Cart idea, especially since there is now a $1,000 app on the store (called "I Am Rich"). I'm still scared that myself, or someone else in my family, might accidentally buy that app.
August 06 2008 at 3:24 PM Report abuse Permalink rate up rate down ReplyHot Apps on TUAW
Deals of the Day
more deals- Refurb MacBook Air Core i5 Dual 1.6GHz 12" Laptop for $750 + free shipping
- Sony Dock 20W Speaker System for iPhone / iPod for $51 + $15 s&h
- Soulo Karaoke App and Wireless Mic for iPhone / iPad for $80 + free shipping
- Verizon Leather Sleeve for Tablets for $4 + free shipping
- Wicked Jaw Breaker Noise-Isolating In-Ear Headphones for $6 + free shipping
- Refurb Apple MacBook Air Laptops: 12" 64GB SSD for $699 + free shipping
Software Updates
more updates- EFI Firmware Update brings Lion Internet Recovery to 2010-model Macs
- OS X Lion 10.7.3 released with Safari 5.1.3, Wi-Fi bug fix
- Aperture updated to 3.2.2, addresses Photo Stream issue
- Apple updates Keynote to address Lion issues
- Google Search app gets new look on iPad
- Apple releases Apple TV Software Update 4.4.3



63 Comments