iPhone service challenges show how Apple can go the extra mile
For years, my Apple stuff has been super reliable, more than any other brand I own. So it came as a bit of a surprise when my trusty iPhone reported 'call failed' as I tapped a number from my address book. I assumed it was an AT&T cell problem, so moved out of the area and tried again. Same result. I looked at the iPhone screen and saw I had a full signal and 3G, so I tried yet again. This time I noticed that the call started, the signal dropped to zero (even the AT&T logo vanished) and the call failed again.Assuming cell tower gremlins, I didn't think too much about it, but as a precaution returned home and restored and re-synced my phone.
Next day I made another call or two with no problems, then patted myself on the back for dealing with the problem on my own. Then the same symptoms returned. Not only were outgoing calls failing, but incoming calls failed in the same way.
A trip to the Apple Store was in order, so I made an appointment and sauntered on in. The tech was helpful. Tried the usual tricks like restarting the phone, resetting network settings etc, but nothing solved it. We switched SIMs with another phone, but no joy there. He suggested I call AT&T and have them 're-provision' the phone. Did that but no dice.
It looked like it was finally time to replace the phone, so he pulled my serial number and had a kind of funny look on his face. He asked for reinforcements, and soon a manager joined my tech as they looked increasingly bewildered while viewing my account details.
They asked me if I had had problems with the phone before? I said no, it has been great. They asked me if I ever had a new replacement shipped? No again. Had I ever failed to return a replaced phone? Nope.
I started to feel slightly guilty about all this. It was like something out of Kafka. Perhaps I had done these things and blotted them out of my mind, but the reality was it seemed like they were talking about someone else. They said their records showed I had many problems with the phone, and that Apple has dispatched a new one, but I never sent the old one back, and even worse, that would make replacing my phone problematic at best.
I was flabbergasted, but the manager guy said he was going to the secret Apple back room and would return soon. While waiting, my mind spun up a hundred scenarios, all ugly. Could I possible have forgotten all these problems? Was I a victim of identity theft? What would I do if they said they wouldn't replace the phone? Etc, etc.
After about 40 minutes he told me had made several calls and determined that someone else with my name in another state had created the long trail of problems that had somehow wound up under my name and iPhone serial number. One can only wonder how that could have happened.
The story ended happily, and the Apple store guys really went the extra mile to get to the bottom of this, rather than just dust me off and say 'tough luck'. I wonder how many retail chains would do the same?
Lessons? Computer systems and people aren't perfect. Somehow my name and iPhone were attached to someone else, and without a lot of determined effort I would have been sunk, probably forced to buy a new phone and left to try to repair my incorrect service record. I don't know if the help I received from my Apple store was typical, but a great effort was made to trust me and get to the bottom of the problem. If it is typical, it helps explain the high rankings Apple gets for customer service. My nightmare ended happily. May all your nightmares be little ones that are easy to fix.
Share
Source: http://www.apple.com/retail/
Categories
For years, my Apple stuff has been super reliable, more than any other brand I own. So it came as a bit of a surprise when my trusty iPhone...
Add a Comment
I've had great service at an Apple Store as well. My iPod Touch refused to charge anymore. It was dead and intended to stay that way. No matter what the Guru did, he couldn't recover it.
So, he popped out a replacement. Then, he noticed the engraving on the back of my original Touch. Without even mentioning it to me, he spoke to a few people. They all nodded, whispered, and made cryptic hand gestures. Finally, my Guru returned finished the return process and sent me out the door. Apple's policy says that engraved items can only be repaired, not exchanged.
That's why I like Apple. I always get good service and the staff always has the ability to bend the "rules" to make a customer happy.
My recent experience with Apple retail store service was mixed. In the end though Apple and the retail store stepped up and made everything right, thus restoring my faith in the company. Fully story on my blog http://joeferrante.net
January 08 2009 at 12:57 PM Report abuse Permalink rate up rate down ReplyHad the same thing happen to me. Went to the Apple store, gave them a rundown of the issues and what I have done so far. After a few clicks by the genius, they gave a me a new one. Great service. I love Apple.
January 08 2009 at 11:01 AM Report abuse Permalink rate up rate down ReplyIve had the worst experience with Apple customer service. Last summer my MacBook was overheating way to much and I made an appointment at the genius bar and they had told me that they found nothing wrong with it. So after sending it in for repair three times and returning to the genius bar again they still saw no problem and I knew there was a problem. So i emailed Steve Jobs explaining the issue I got a phone call the next day from an Apple executive customer support person she helped me through the tough times and after about three days she ended up replacing my MacBook for a brand new one. But in the beginning I had the worst experience with Apple customer support until I went the extra mile not them.
January 08 2009 at 2:45 AM Report abuse Permalink rate up rate down Replyhttp://support.apple.com/kb/HT1778
January 08 2009 at 9:20 AM Report abuse Permalink rate up rate down ReplyYea sorry dude I saw that page a million times and my MacBook was overheating considerably. It was well above normal temperatures it got so hot that it had left a mark on my desk....I'm not an idiot dude
January 08 2009 at 12:37 PM Report abuse Permalink rate up rate down ReplyEven their phone support is incredible, although the wait is a pain. My iPhone is having trouble, but I can't go without it. Apple has great support and needs to get their stores in more places, the Midwest is just empty.
January 08 2009 at 1:23 AM Report abuse Permalink rate up rate down ReplyI had my iPhone (1G) replaced for this same problem this past weekend. Would drop calls like nothing. At one point it took 15 attempts to make a call, all with the serivce showing full bars. I have had no problems with my replacement (so far. It is my 4th iPhone). It is not always AT&T, although their cell service is spotty and random at times. Apple though has replaced my phone three times total, all for various reasons (screen problems, shutting off itself, call dropping). Although the reliability of the iPhone is the lowest of any phone I have ever owned, Apple is always willing to help/replace when necessary, which I can't say of other cell phone manufacturers.
January 07 2009 at 10:04 PM Report abuse Permalink rate up rate down ReplyI just had this happen to me with an AppleCare repair on my iMac. Problem is...no Apple Store in Arkansas. :( Had to work with Apple over the phone. The problem stemmed from my AppleCare agreement being registered to a totally different computer. Had to email them a copy of my original receipt and recently got a certification letter from Apple for my AppleCare. It all ended well, but made for a less-than-easy time getting my iMac's SuperDrive replaced.
January 07 2009 at 8:44 PM Report abuse Permalink rate up rate down ReplyTo the person who had their credit card used: FedEd (contracted shipper for all things Apple) requires a signature for release of package - either in person or via a call tag left on your door. Unless you pay extra for an exact (2 hour window) delivery time the people who ordered the computer would have had to hang around your house all day waiting... would have been pretty obvious. I do seasonal work for FedEd and if the driver thinks something is up he can refuse to deliver. I almost did on two occassions.
I had Apple initially refuse warranty care on my iPhone in April. They initially said there was a crack on the screen. Turned out to be nothing and the camera they used to take picture for proof had the flash go off an it turned out to be a flare. Then they said it had been immersed in water. I denied (had actually dropped in 2' of water minutes after taking it out of the OtterBox case - doh!) I denied it, of course. They examined closer and the moisture indicator - headphone plug - had only halfway changed colors. Whew! Got off on technecality! They sent replacement to me.
Few years before: iPod with sad iPod image. Cary Apple Store Genius replaced with refurb, no questions. Even told me how to get music off bad one (could connect and sync, not listen) via iTunes spelled backwards.
Compared to previous PCs... I'm sticking with the Apple!
Wow,
I can't peopel are defending a multi-billion dollar company like Apple and bashing my service experience. It was atrocious. The phone has the SAME defects as the other two that were replaced. Expecting people to not carry phones about themselves and use them in different weather conditions is the "asinine" thing. My phone works perfectly fins, except for the SCREEN defects, IN THE GLASS. Nothing to do with water, you jerkwads.
I had to make a "reservation" for service. I show up at the appointed time and did not get helped for over an hour because they walk-ins ahead of me. WTF!!?
Then they acknowledge the defect in the phone, but refuse to replace my 600 dollar investment because of some nitpicking thing. All the while, pawning me off to the phones to get a refund on a warranty I was sold, and told would cover everything for two years. The phones claimed they were refunding my warranty costs, but I have yet to have it appear on my credit card, so I am the asinine one?
I have a Dell laptop with complete care. I dropped a starbucks latte in it, and guess what, Dell still serviced the machine.
Apple "offered" to remedy my situation by foisting the 3G product on me, and requiring me to activate for 2 years and get this.. get a "special" price of 199.99.
They smoke crack there, that's for sure.
The cherry on top of all that, I saw two customers with laptops, > 2500 investments that were refused service because they were "abused".
Apple is the one abusing you guys.
And Jim: you DO know that they can definitively tell if your iPhone has been wet, right? No "deciding" required. You were busted.
January 07 2009 at 5:11 PM Report abuse Permalink rate up rate down ReplyHot Apps on TUAW
Deals of the Day
more deals- miFrame Picture Frame Dock for iPad for $64 + $8 s&h
- Refurb Apple iPod nano 8GB MP3 Player for $99 + free shipping, 16GB for $119
- Bling Diamond Snap-On Shell Case for iPhone 4 / 4S for $2 + $2 s&h
- Hannspree Apple-Shaped 28" 1080p LCD HDTV for $270 + free shipping
- Philips wOOx Alarm Clock Radio for Apple iPod / iPhone for $60 + free shipping
- iWatchz Elemetal Collection Bracelet for iPod nano for $75 + free shipping
Software Updates
more updates- EFI Firmware Update brings Lion Internet Recovery to 2010-model Macs
- OS X Lion 10.7.3 released with Safari 5.1.3, Wi-Fi bug fix
- Aperture updated to 3.2.2, addresses Photo Stream issue
- Apple updates Keynote to address Lion issues
- Google Search app gets new look on iPad
- Apple releases Apple TV Software Update 4.4.3



50 Comments