Skip to Content

Kindle + iPhone = Opportunities?



Buried in the announcement of the Kindle 2, Amazon also released a small nugget of information that had been flying around the Web for the past few days - that Kindle content will eventually come to cell phones.

So, how would that work? According to the announcement, the new Whispersync technology would allow readers to pause in reading a book on the Kindle and pick it back up on either another Kindle or eventually a cell phone. Not much detail was provided, though Gizmodo did confirm with Amazon's Ian Freed that Kindle content is on the way. Whether it's for the iPhone or Google's Android phone or the Blackberry, we don't know.

On one hand, the announcement is a victory for those advocating that digital content be available on more than one device. Amazon's already broken ground with music, and now wants to spread that to books. With more than 230,000 books currently available in the Kindle format, it's an impressive library to suddenly have at your fingertips.

On the other hand, Apple could see this as Amazon infringing on a potential product that could be sold and keep Kindle content off the iPhone. Yes, there is the Stanza store, but Amazon is by far a more visible and well-known competitor. I hope that this won't happen, as it'll just erode good will toward Apple, but it's by far not the first poor decision that Apple has made regarding what they feel belongs on the iPhone or not.
Personally, I'm actually of a mixed mind on the issue. I've been lusting after a Kindle for months, as my poor fiancé who hears those muttered longings will tell you, but haven't wanted to part with $359 for the device that definitely needed bugs ironed out in its first incarnation. I definitely see the advantages of being able to swap between Kindle and iPhone or just download straight to the iPhone.

But as I've bonded with my iPhone over the past 15 months, I've found that reading books on it wasn't a priority. I tried Stanza as soon as the App Store opened, but wasn't too thrilled with the interface. I settled on Classics, which I absolutely adore, but has a limited library. I tried standalone books available through the App Store and got mixed results.

The biggest problem I have with the iPhone is that the screen is just too small for reading novels. While writing this article, I pulled several books off my shelf - A Japanese light novel, its English-translated counterpart (which is the size of most manga currently available in the U.S.) and a traditional paperback, then set the iPhone next to them. The iPhone is less than half the size of the Japanese light novel, and those are pretty small! As seen earlier in the article, an iPhone is tiny next to a Kindle itself. I find myself reading a couple of pages, but then quickly abandoning the book. I spend more time flipping pages on an iPhone than actually reading the text.

We wouldn't have the Kindle without iPod or the iPhone, that much I'm sure of. I love my iPhone and will advocate it for most of my digital needs - except for books. In this case, I'll take a Kindle.

What do you think about Kindle content possibly coming to the iPhone, or the iPhone as a device for reading books? How would you handle the reading experience on an iPhone? Let us know in the comments!

Buried in the announcement of the Kindle 2, Amazon also released a small nugget of information that had been flying around the Web for the...
 

Add a Comment

*0 / 3000 Character Maximum

24 Comments

Filter by:
ButisitArt

Anyone figure out where the Kindle book files are stored on the iPhone?

March 05 2009 at 12:43 PM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply
Chris Cook

The problem with a Kindle is you have one more device to keep track of and carry with you. I love using my iPhone to read books. It is always with me. I've read about 75 books on it. I have used Stanza. It is ok. But I prefer the ereader software for my iPhone from ereader.com. I can purchase books on the go and download them directly to my iPhone.

February 11 2009 at 12:45 AM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply
1 reply to Chris Cook's comment
Amanda

I was thinking about purchasing a Kindle right up until I got my iPhone about 4 months ago. I have an EEEPC I use to read books and I love it, but it's a bit bulky really (not as bulky as books) and I saw someone with a Kindle and was insanely jealous.

I had to get a new phone so I figured I'd give the ereader software a shot. It's awesome! Heck, I even read almost the entire "A Song of Fire and Ice" series on it. If you can read that on a device, it's golden.

And, I download a lot of books directly from fictionwise.com to the phone, without ever seeing a PC. You can also use ereader.com to host files converted by Stanza and pull them to your phone.

No need for another device to keep up with.

February 11 2009 at 1:44 AM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply
StephanieInCA

The Kindle is great for convenience (although I still think a lot of the downloadable media is overpriced), but I'm surprised more people aren't talking about the potential security/free speech implications of the digitization of books.

http://urbzen.com/2009/02/09/amazon-kindle-privacy-fail/

February 10 2009 at 5:14 PM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply
Rob E.

I love Stanza. Since I got my first iPod, between the availability of podcasts, audio books, and, of course, all of my music, I had taken a break from reading actual print books unless I was planted at home or on vacation for a good amount of time. The iPod provided me with enough entertainment that I let go of my habit of always taking at least one book with me out of the house. Thanks to Stanza and my iPod touch, I can have it all. I don't read for long periods of time on my iPod, but I do dip into Stanza for a couple of hours a week generally. I've tweaked the display settings to make them more comfortable to read and also dark enough to not add too much light to the bedroom when I'm reading after my wife has gone to sleep.
But.
I've played with a Kindle. I've read on it and poked around the interface, and while it's not perfect, I like it a lot, and the reading experience beats the iPod hands down (and, as Cory says, has a leg up on an actual book, as well). I want to buy one, especially now that 2.0 is almost here, but one of my issues is that the Kindle is still not something I'm likely to leave the house with regularly. It's just as portable as a book, but much more fragile, and the financial consequences of breaking it are much more severe than those of tearing a page from my paperback. I could see taking it along when I intended to read, but, unlike my iPod, I don't see it as being always present for those occasions when I happen to find myself with a few minutes to read. That is why Kindle books on the iPhone sound so exciting. I could easily see reading a book on the Kindle at home, reading a chapter or two at lunch or on the bus using my iPod, and then picking up on the Kindle later on. The new design of the Kindle had me about convinced that it's time to start saving my pennies for one. If I can sync books between the Kindle and the iPod, that's pretty much all the convincing I need.

February 10 2009 at 3:35 PM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply
Charles Hoard

I have a Sony reader and an iPhone. For long train/plane travel, you can not beat the Sony (yes, I cheat and recharge it off my PSP AC adapter, but that's for another blog) for reading pleasure. But I have to know and plan in advance to have it around; it is hardly easy to carry as an afterthought.

I always have my phone on me however, and in my opinion the free Stanza software in the App store was my best find of the month. I already use Fictionwise.com as my main book supplier, and when I installed the software on my phone and those books from my Fictionwise bookshelf popped up, with color covers, I am sure i looked my like 8 year old on Christmas.

Which platform you use is a balance of time and convenience, like everything in life, but I strongly agree that multiple platforms is a necessity with any purchase. These guys have a bad habit of trying to protect themselves into the poor house.

February 10 2009 at 1:52 PM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply
Sam


I'm really hoping this is more than just FUD. I've been reading ebooks on my palm/treo for years, and now use Stanza on my iphone. It might not be for everyone, but the convenience of being able to carry a library in my pocket, and have my books on a device I always have with me....no dedicated ebook reader is going to work as well for me personally. It'd be really nice to have access to all the books Amazon has made available for the Kindle...

February 10 2009 at 11:32 AM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply
1 reply to Sam's comment
Quinn Taylor

Sorry, I didn't mean that this article was FUD. I was referring to those who continue to preach that Platform X will dominate because it's easier to program for, or because it has such a large user base. Even more so, those who surmise that Apple is therefore condemned to obscurity and failure.

I suggest reading the recent (lengthy) article on eBooks over at Art Technica (http://arstechnica.com/features/2009/02/the-once-and-future-e-book.ars) for background on what has happened and the forces at work that influence what is likely to happen. In the book market, it's never just as easy as "if you build it, they will come".

Ease of programming is generally the least of impeding factors. We can only hope that content owners continue on recent, more reasonable trends with respect to availability, DRM, distribution, etc.

February 10 2009 at 11:46 AM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply
FenianEMT

I read books on my Palm Treo and on my Blackberry Pearl. I think if the screens on those devices can support it, then so can the iPhone.

With that said, I own a Kindle and have preordered a Kindle 2 (I have no willpower). I love the current Kindle. Given the choice between reading on a Kindle and reading on anything with an LCD-type screen, I'll take the Kindle every time. I actually prefer to read anything but technical books on the Kindle over the paper variety. The Kindle made reading on a gadget the PREFERRED way of reading rather than just an option for when I don't have a paper book on hand.

I am very much hoping that Amazon will release a Kindle app for the iPhone. I'll still read on my Kindle when I can, but I don't have the Kindle with me 100% of the time. I do have my iPhone nearly 100% of the time. And if they can sync the current reading location, then being able to read my Kindle books even when I don't have my Kindle will be awesome. In fact, I could easily see that becoming one of my favorite 3rd party iPhone apps.

February 10 2009 at 11:06 AM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply
David Eckert

iPhone, Android, or Blackberry? Forgetting someone? I'll put money down now that it's coming to Windows Mobile first. Just easier to program for, especially companies that make a lot of Windows software already. Plus, I'll love reading books on my Diamond (640x480, which of those phones above had that high of a resolution again?).

TUAW and Engadget may hate WM phones, but they really do more. In the past they haven't been as sexy, and that's the only reason they got a bad rap now.

/rant off

February 10 2009 at 9:41 AM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply
3 replies to David Eckert's comment
vandil

It doesn't take a rocket scientist to find PDFs of your favorite non-free books online (That's just how the world is now), so I won't get into online book sales.

The problem is displaying them on an iPhone. PDFs and LITs look butt-ugly on Stanza, even if you convert them to epub format. Stanza likes to ignore carriage returns, ALL CAPS, indented passages, and other structures. Of course the books in the Stanza store look great.

When viewing a PDF via Air Sharing, the PDF is displayed with all the original structure, but it is microscopic and zooming the text means you can read like 3 sentences before needing to scroll.

To me, the iPhone biggest problem for eBook reading is its screen.

Keep an eye on those "Book" Apps in the App store -- the ones where its just one book encapsulated in an App. If those sell well, I expect a real book store to be opening within iTunes, selling each book as an App, or better, incorporating that reader into a future iPhone/Touch OS with a larger screen (or a tablet Mac!).

February 10 2009 at 9:35 AM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply
Mr. H

I think you need to give Stanza another try. A lot has happened since its initial release and by adjusting the colors, you can create quite a nice reader. It's not like epaper but a kindle can't play music, make calls and play wurdle... For me it's all about one device that does things well and I, personally think Stanza is amazing.

February 10 2009 at 9:24 AM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply
Buy an ad here

Hot Apps on TUAW

Tweets

© 2012 AOL Inc. All Rights Reserved.