Filed under: Analysis / Opinion, Software, Odds and ends, Freeware, Internet, iPhone, iPod touch, First Look
TUAW First Look: Comcast Mobile for iPhone and iPod touch
Cable, broadband, and phone giant Comcast has joined the ranks of companies jumping on the iPhone bandwagon with a helpful and free new app: Comcast Mobile [App Store].Let's get one thing out of the way right now; this app will not let you stream video from your Comcast set-top box to your iPhone. So what does it do?
- Provides a unified inbox for Comcast email and voicemail
- Lets you sync your SmartZone contacts with your iPhone or iPod touch
- Shows call logs for Comcast Digital Voice, and allows call forwarding and control of voicemail.
- Gives you detailed TV listings in The Guide, complete with reminders and favorites
- Allows viewing of On Demand movie trailers
I had a chance to work with a pre-release version of the app loaded on an iPod touch, and I was impressed with the stability, speed, and functionality of Comcast Mobile. Read on for more details about the app.
Logging In
To use Comcast Mobile, you need to be a customer, preferably a "triple-play" customer with High-Speed Internet, Voice, and HD Cable. I don't use Comcast's voice service, but I do have the other two services and I still found Comcast Mobile to be useful.
Using your comcast.net email address and the password used to log into the webmail site, you enter the pertinent information into a settings page. You can choose to save your password for an instant login.
The Home Screen
The home screen for Comcast Mobile has large buttons for the five major functions; Inbox, Address Book, Digital Voice, The Guide, and One Demand. You can also access an information screen with links to an FAQ list and Getting Started Guide, a Contact and Feedback list, Discussion Forums, and the ever-popular Terms & Conditions.
The information screen was having some issues during my test; since it links to the Comcast website, it gave me a notice at one point that my browser wasn't supported. One of my complaints about the FAQ list/Getting Started Guide page was that it wasn't formatted for the iPhone or iPod touch -- it's just the regular Comcast customerCentral web page, so you need to scroll back and forth to view the information. I was a bit concerned by the "We're still working on content" filler page that was up just a few scant days before the expected release of Comcast Mobile.
The Settings screen is also accessed from the home screen, and features a number of choices for configuring your iPhone or iPod touch for optimum use of the site.
The Inbox
The unified inbox is the same inbox that Comcast customers can access online through www.comcast.net. The two inboxes, iPhone and online, are always kept in sync. While having access to voicemail and email in the same inbox might be attractive to some users, others may wish to access their Comcast email accounts from the iPhone's Mail app. Comcast could have considered using Apple's Mail app and provided a way to listen to Comcast voicemail in that app. Vonage VoIP customers, for example, can listen to their voicemail messages in the standard Mail app.
The Inbox has five separate tabs; one contains both email and voicemail, another only email, yet another only voicemail, another for folders that the user creates, and the last for searching the Inbox for specific messages. To read an email, you simply tap on it. Once you have opened an email, a series of icons at the bottom allow you to refresh the inbox, move the message to a new folder, trash it, forward or reply to it, or write a new email. In the Inbox, you can also select multiple emails for deletion.
Address Book
The Address Book in Comcast Mobile synchronizes initially with the SmartZone address book on the online Comcast site. When synced, any items in the online address book are synced to the Comcast Mobile and iPhone address books. Likewise, any contacts added to the iPhone or Comcast Mobile address books are synced to the online book.
Digital Voice
Tapping the Digital Voice button opens a completely different inbox, one that handles only calls made on Comcast's Digital Voice product. There are four tabs in this section of Comcast Mobile, one to see all phone calls made or received, one to see only outgoing phone calls, another to see missed calls, and a final tab for voicemails only.
Tapping on a voicemail plays it back. You can mark the message as unheard if you wish to be reminded to listen to it again. Voicemails appeared in Digital Voice and in the Inbox within seconds of being recorded. The Digital Voice area is also where you can set up call forwarding for your Comcast Digital Voice account. This is very useful for forwarding your account to your iPhone when you're away from home.
The Guide
I found The Guide to be the most useful section of the TV Listings. In fact, I wish that Comcast would simply use online listings such as this and get rid of the large paper guide they send to my home monthly. I usually toss it in the recycle bin anyway since it's full of gushing news about celebrities that I neither follow nor care to follow.
The first time you open The Guide, you're asked to enter your zip code. This ensures that you see the proper channel listing and times for your area. The listing is in order by station number, and shows what is currently on each station as well as what will be showing in a half-hour. To see future listings, you simply flick the listing to the left.
All shows that are on HD channels show up with a small blue HD icon next to them. Tapping any of the show listings pulls up program details. On the program details page is a button for other showtimes, and tapping on it lists all of the upcoming times that the show will be aired. You can tap a button to add a program to a list of favorites, or tap another to share an upcoming show with a friend via email.
One of my favorite features is the ability to set reminders about upcoming shows. Any show that is set in the future can be set as a reminder on the program details page. You can set an alarm to sound at showtime or at 5, 10, or 15 minutes in advance.
The search function works fairly well, although I found myself sometimes getting odd results. For example, searching for Lance Armstrong not only gave me some correct hits (e.g., "Tour de France: Astana Profile"), but some that were way off the mark (e.g., "This Girl for Hire", a movie starring Bess Armstrong, who also shows up in "Jaws 3-D"). I tried a search with the name in quotes ("lance armstrong"), but that returned no hits at all. Still, the search will always return more results than just the correct ones, so you should be able to find just about everything you're looking for.
On Demand
I'm sure that many Comcast customers were hoping that On Demand would actually provide streaming movies, but that was not to be. What it does is give you is those preview videos that are in heavy rotation on Comcast Channel 1, enticing you to watch free On Demand movies or pay for the latest releases.
The videos are formatted for the iPhone screen and both look and sound great. There's a Cover Flow-like interface for new releases at the top of the display, followed by a series of buttons leading to detailed descriptions for other movie trailers sorted by genre.
What Comcast Mobile is missing
As a Comcast customer, there are a few things that I'd like to see added to the app in future releases.
First, it would be nice to be able to go to an online customer service site formatted just for the small screen size of the iPhone and iPod touch. This could be constructed similarly to AT&T's myWireless app, which provides a mobile portal to any and all account information. You can view and pay bills from the app, and even purchase or upgrade services.
Next, I know that Comcast's existing set top boxes / DVRs probably don't handle Wi-Fi or Bluetooth connections (the one I have certainly doesn't), but it would be wonderful to have the ability to use Comcast Mobile as a remote for all things on cable. In other words, let's not just use the iPhone as a way to see what's on TV and get a reminder, but to actually control the set top box! As I noted earlier, Comcast is planning to add a way to set your DVR in the next release of Comcast Mobile.
What about streaming video from my set top box or DVR to my iPhone? I'm paying for the content, so it would be nice to use that content even when I'm not at home sitting in front of the HDTV.
Finally, since the online Address Book has the ability to let you send ecards to people in your list, why not add that function to Comcast Mobile?
Summary
All in all, Comcast Mobile 1.0 is a surprisingly useful and fun app for the iPhone and iPod touch. I don't watch much TV, but I found myself using The Guide to find out what was coming up on my Comcast digital cable. I personally wish the Comcast digital cable on-screen guide was as easy to use as the one found in Comcast Mobile.
Comcast has done a wonderful job of taking the functions built into their Digital Cable, High-Speed Internet, and Digital Voice offerings, and tailoring them to the multi-touch interface of the iPhone and iPod touch. I look forward to using both this initial offering and future updates to Comcast Mobile. Now if they could only work with Apple to transform the AppleTV into a much better "cable box" and media center...
Be sure to check out screenshots of Comcast Mobile in action:


![TUAW [Cafepress]](http://www.blogsmithmedia.com/www.tuaw.com/media/tuaw-cafepress-promo.png)


Reader Comments (Page 1 of 1)
Dave G said 7:07PM on 7-15-2009
Way cool app but I'll be most impressed when the remote dvr recording is up and running on the next release.
Reply
Steven Sande said 7:12PM on 7-15-2009
Agreed. I don't know how many times I've been away from the house and wished I could set my DVR for a show I'm about to miss. Seeing the DirecTV ads showing off the ability to remotely program the DVR makes me extremely jealous...
TUAWSteve
Michael Rose said 7:46PM on 7-15-2009
For what it's worth, the Dish Network web DVR control works really well on the iPod touch and iPhone. You can actually change the channel in near-real-time, an activity which has been banned by my spouse. Ahem.
Ryan said 3:10PM on 7-16-2009
I was extremely excited to see this app show up. When I found out that it lacked DVR programming controls, my excitement turned to groanings....
I've even thought about changing to a different provider, but I just don't trust other internet services. Comcast has been very fast and reliable for me.
Any suggestions?
Craver009 said 6:28PM on 7-17-2009
I was a DirecTV user and let me tell you that, their DVR schedule on the iPhone app sucks really bad.. It does not handle conflicts very well.. and the user interface is really lame and mediocre.. Their guide is a UX disaster if i may say so. Comcast has demonstrated how a product should look like and behave even it does not have a 'a' feature.. I mean cmon.. when iPhone first launched.. It did not 100 things ..which are coming up .. still they sold 10 million of them in the first product launch.. A product release does not mean it has to have everything. I would not even compare a DirecTV or a Dish, or as a matter of fact AT&T to this app... This is a perfect convergence of multiple services comcast has to offer.. DirectTV should first look at what all they offer.. Where's the email..where's the On demand .. A free Address book sync engine... Forget it...
David Winograd said 7:15PM on 7-15-2009
This app has some very nice aspects to it, but being a Directv customer, there's nothing like scheduling a recording to any one of our four DVRs from anywhere.
How far we've come from my first Betamax.
Reply
CaptSaltyJack said 7:27PM on 7-15-2009
Agreed.. remote access to my DVR is all I care about. Is it really a confirmed future feature?
Reply
Alexander Stone said 7:35PM on 7-15-2009
Having the TV schedule grid on hand is the only feature I would use, here. And I already use TV Forecast for that. I imagine, like the rest of you, this won't be extremely useful until they get the DVR remote control up and running and maybe even let me control the box from the thing (replacing the ugly comcast remote with my iPhone :) )
Reply
Cameron said 8:20PM on 7-15-2009
Anyone else surprised that Comcast is offering something for free? Not only that, but saying that they will be ADDING features to something, rather than taking features away while increasing the price?
Reply
Bill Waggoner said 9:31PM on 7-15-2009
It appears that you need a comcast.net account to use the app. Even if you only want to look at TV listings.
Reply
Craver009 said 6:00PM on 7-17-2009
But one thing is for sure That comcast is way ahead in innovating and extending their core services to mobile than any other Tom dick and harry telco.
I as a comcast triple play user find a lot of value in this and woudl never switch to a directv or a shitty vrizon service
SPkl said 11:33AM on 7-16-2009
i have installed this application. It's extremely good to see the Address book module in landscape view. enjoyed !!!
Reply
pdcryan said 11:57AM on 7-16-2009
Anyone know if you can actual play your voicemail through the app, or just see a list of messages? I'm impressed so far - but don't have any voice messages to test it out yet.
Reply
Antonio said 10:20PM on 7-16-2009
I love the Uverse app, glad to see more companies doing the same as ATT and DirectTV
Reply
Craver009 said 6:09PM on 7-17-2009
I was a DirecTV user and let me tell you that, their DVR schedule on the iPhone app sucks really bad.. It does not handle conflicts very well.. and the user interface is really lame and mediocre.. Their guide is a UX disaster if i may say so. Comcast has demonstrated how a product should look like and behave even it does not have a 'a' feature.. I mean cmon.. when iPhone first launched.. It did not 100 things ..which are coming up .. still they sold 10 million of them in the first product launch.. A product release does not mean it has to have everything. I would not even compare a DirecTV or a Dish, or as a matter of fact AT&T to this app... This is a perfect convergence of multiple services comcast has to offer.. DirectTV should first look at what all they offer.. Where's the email..where's the On demand .. A free Address book sync engine... Forget it...
Reply
SeeJ said 7:23PM on 7-17-2009
"I found The Guide to be the most useful section of the TV Listings. In fact, I wish that Comcast would simply use online listings such as this and get rid of the large paper guide they send to my home monthly."
www.tvplanner.net
Also, there's another Comcast app that just does TV Listings, although it looks like it was unfinished or something. It's very minimalist and some of the buttons in it are missing their labels. That one is just called TV Listings.
Reply
AlyciaW said 11:15PM on 7-20-2009
Under "The Guide," it shows a number ("1") as if I have a message or alert or something. I can't figure out how to clear this number. I expand "The Guide," but all I see are the TV listings.
Has anyone else encountered this? Did you figure out how to clear it?
Reply
vlis said 10:18AM on 7-22-2009
If you have two email accounts with comcast, anyone know how to get them both on the app? Right now, I only can get one
Reply