Skip to Content

CoPilot Live throws a hat in the navigation ring

Well, another day, another iPhone GPS app is released to the eager hordes. One of the latest entries is CoPilot Live [iTunes link]. Note: CoPilot Live is also available in a version for the U.K. at the App Store.

The North American version is a US$34.99 full featured nav for your car, bicycle, or just walking around. All the maps are built in, so it does not require any data, which is a plus.

There are things I like about this app, other than the low price. The screens look good, and are highly configurable. They give you the option of getting live weather at your current location, or your destination. I'd like to see that on every GPS app. Satellite acquisition was quick, with no glitches. Although some users have reported crashes, I found the app stable and reliable.

The voice instructions are very clear, and you have a choice of several languages with either a male or female speaker. In the U.S. the choices are 'John' or 'Lisa.'

You can zoom in or out of the 3D or 2D maps, and it appeared that as you approach a destination the map zooms in automatically. The app quickly switches to portrait or landscape mode, and you get a full screen, large type indication of the next turn. It pops up for a few moments, then returns to map view.

The app allows you to plan a trip in advance and preview the route. Happily, you can choose a destination from your address book.

Of course, things aren't all rosy with CoPilot Live. Here are the issues I saw in a couple hours of driving around town.First, sometimes the directions lagged, and told me to turn when I was already through an intersection. When I put in my home address, the app could find my street but said there were no house numbers available. Ouch. My street has been there for more than 10 years, my neighbors and I all have house numbers, and every other GPS app has gotten me there just fine.

When I asked for nearby hotels, I got a list of restaurants. When I asked for restaurants, I got a list of hotels. Whoops. The POI list itself was OK, but pretty out of date. Entering a street name was no fun because the keyboard is in alphabetical order. Ewwww.

At one point, doing a POI search, the app reported there were no POIs around, and asked me to click on 'more.' Trouble is there was no 'more' button.

In settings, there are several options, but things like speed limit, lane assist, and safety alerts are grayed out. Similarly, when searching for points of interest, ATMs and commuter rail stations are also grayed out.

Like most of the similar GPS apps, there is no text to speech, at least not yet. Navigon is promising it in an update for their app.

Bottom line, I think this app has a lot of potential. The developer (ALK Technologies) says an upcoming free update will provide a QWERTY keyboard, improved GPS performance, ability to call a POI, and for an additional fee, provide real time traffic.

That is fine, but what the app really needs is a better map database. As of now, it has too many missing streets and house numbers.

The egregious errors need to be fixed, like dead end menus and lists of hotels that are restaurants instead.

Of course, this app is inexpensive, and some are complaining the DRM is a bit draconian. You have to install it through iTunes, and the activation scheme requires you do it over Wi-Fi.

I think the low price could put pressure on the more expensive apps, but so far, the more expensive navigators all work better. We haven't reviewed the much awaited TomTom app yet, but we'll do it soon.

Here are some screen grabs that show the good, bad and the ugly when using this app:



Categories

iPhone App Store App Review

Well, another day, another iPhone GPS app is released to the eager hordes. One of the latest entries is CoPilot Live [iTunes link]. Note:...
 

Add a Comment

*0 / 3000 Character Maximum

18 Comments

Filter by:
Diddle

I bought CoPilot last week and gave it a thorough work-out on a trip from Vancouver to Portland. The maps (for the most part) are up-to-date; my friend's house is in a subdivision which is less than 2 years old and all the roads in the are were available. I did find that many POIs were wrong, missing or outdated.

I haven't purchased the other navi apps to do a side-by-side comparison but from the videos I've watched online, reviews and articles I've read, I'm quite happy with CoPilot over the other apps which are 2-3x the price.

One of the major things for me is the Text-to-Speech which will be coming soon as an add-on (pay?) but will certainly be worthwhile.

I had a couple of problems with the app and there are a few bugs I'll certainly be submitting (such as the software's inability to figure out if you've already been to a stop on a multi-stop route) but from the note in the app store, some of my frustrations (like the alphabetic keyboard) are already being addressed in an upcoming release.

I've got faith in this low-price software and I found it very easy to use. Now if they'd just add a page to control my music ala MotionX, we'd be set!

August 24 2009 at 9:03 PM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply
luxl85

Note: CoPilot Live is also available in a version for the U.K. at the App Store.

Great Now I can add the App to my Iphone. http://www.laptops-battery.co.uk/

August 20 2009 at 2:58 AM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply
Toby

I've owned the CoPilot Truck software, and the CoPilot Truck standalone GPS navigation unit. I will never, ever again purchase any CoPilot hardware or software due to the crashes and malfunctions experienced with both products. I'll gladly pay a higher price with another company's product to be satisfied.

Aside from that, is there any sort of GPS connecter one can plug into the iPod Touch 2G in order to use one of these applications?

August 19 2009 at 4:17 PM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply
2 replies to Toby's comment
lostboy

According to this recent MacRumors post...

http://www.macrumors.com/2009/08/17/tomtom-car-kit-to-be-compatible-with-ipod-touch-and-other-gps-iphone-applications/

... the upcoming TomTom car kit will enable GPS functionality for iPod Touches and 1st-gen iPhones (as well as work with non-Tom Tom software, apparently).

August 20 2009 at 1:00 PM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply
lostboy

According to this recent MacRumors post...

http://www.macrumors.com/2009/08/17/tomtom-car-kit-to-be-compatible-with-ipod-touch-and-other-gps-iphone-applications/

... the upcoming TomTom car kit will enable GPS functionality for iPod Touches and 1st-gen iPhones (as well as work with non-Tom Tom software, apparently).

August 20 2009 at 1:02 PM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply
makpuikan

I have tried CoPilot and I can't find any streets in my community. The map shows my house in the middle of bare (empty) lots, even though this subdivision has been developed for 6 yrs already. Agreed with other owners that their map is old and needs huge update. What a waste of money, I'm now using Navigon and I'm happy.

August 19 2009 at 1:07 PM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply
CaptCaveman

So far I've been disappointed with all the Nav apps on the iPhone. I would have to say that the best out of 4 that I've had a chance to try is Navigon. The biggest disappointment being TomTom. I tried TomTom today. Not having text to speech really hurts. And the constant "turn right, turn right (or left for that matter)" prompts actually had me exiting off the freeway what I guess was one stop to early.
It did pick up that I was on the off ramp quickly. But I just didn't have a chance to look at the phone to see what exit I was supposed to be getting off at. And since I was approaching an exit while it was telling me to exit right, well, I exited.

Also the map seemed a bit... Bare. I think I'll stick with Navigon for now. Also I think its a shame that Garmin is releasing their own phone. So I'm going to guess that they won't be coming to the iPhone GPS party anytime soon if ever.

August 19 2009 at 1:10 AM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply
greenjestur

I had one problem with it acquiring a signal, but when it worked, it worked well. there are definitely signs of it being rushed, and with some future interface improvements it could be a very good value.

August 18 2009 at 9:15 PM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply
Here

If you live in the states, pass it up, maps are 5 maybe 10 years old, like the flow of the software, but the maps are just way to outdated to be worth $35. I made the mistake so you don't have to.

August 18 2009 at 8:49 PM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply
Griffon

I ultimately fired ALK years back from my ipaq. Their DRM is quite obnoxious and seemed to allays live my device in a failed state needing reactivation. Incredible frustrating when you are on the road. It's not that they can't build a good product but they constantly put their needs and fear of piracy over that of their actual paying customers. This dose not make me want to give them more money, since this sounds like a halfway done job.
I wonder when real time traffic will be a free regular feature, it's not like most services couldn't just pull it through the google API right?

August 18 2009 at 7:39 PM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply
grant

i actually prefer this app over the sygic app (i used the one for australia/new zealand). yes, there are quirks and some things are unfinished, but it's more "iphone-like" than the sygic app. the sygic app can't touch-scroll, doesn't pinch to zoom, and its menus are awful. getting a gps lock is terrible, too.

the copilot app for the price works fine, though the keyboard is indeed a problem and the maps must be updated, though i didn't notice a problem in that area driving around the phoenix/tempe/scottsdale region.

their website does mention that TTS and lane assist and other functionalities are available for other devices, so hopefully it makes its way over to the iphone app. i'd even pay a bit extra to get these things...

August 18 2009 at 7:06 PM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply
Steven

I tried CoPilot, and Agree it has potential, but the map is missing a lot of streets. My In-laws street (the very first address I tried!) is not listed, and it's been there for at least 6 years. All other GPS apps, online maps and even my out of data GPS system in my car have no problem finding it.

IMHO, a nav system that is missing streets is not worth the price, even if it is 1/2 Navigon's and 1/3 TomTom's versions.

Also, the alphabetical keyboard drives me insane. What were they thinking?

August 18 2009 at 6:44 PM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply
1 reply to Steven's comment
Craig

I bought CoPilot last weekend, and have found it to be as accurate and easily-used as my TomTom, which I'd passed on to an easily-lost relative. The software is in fact easier to negotiate than the TomTom interface. And really, the maps can't be that old, because they show a highway around here which is only about two years old. The only mishap I've had is probably my own fault. I decided to navigate through the countryside and set the software to avoid highways. Eventually ended up on a rutted seasonal road. On the return trip, I revised the setting to "quickest" and had no problem. I've also tried AT$T Navigator, and while I found the traffic information useful around the NYC area, it was annoyingly laggy.

All in all, I really see no reason to go to a more-expensive piece of software when this works so well, although I do hope ALK adds text-to-speech soon.

August 18 2009 at 7:11 PM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply
Buy an ad here

Hot Apps on TUAW

Tweets

© 2012 AOL Inc. All Rights Reserved.