Aussie drivers: Buy a cradle, or no iPhone GPS for you
Live in Australia? Have an iPhone? Do you use the iPhone's built-in Maps app, Navigon, or TomTom [iTunes links] to navigate? If you answered yes to all three of those questions, then I have some bad news for you: under the Australian Road Rule 8th Amendment, all use of the iPhone in your car is soon to be banned unless you buy a cradle for it, including using it as a GPS navigator. An article from the Sydney Morning Herald initially makes it sound as though you won't be able to use such apps at all, especially after reading this quote from a spokesperson for VicRoads, the traffic authority for the Australian state of Victoria: "A phone will only be allowed to be used for its primary purpose. If it's a phone, it's a phone." But once you read farther down the article states, "Drivers will only be able to use mobile phones if they are placed in purpose-made cradles and operation is entirely hands-free." The language of the amendment itself also supports that interpretation.
So it's not the end of the road for iPhone nav apps in Australia, but if you want to continue using your iPhone for said purpose, you'd better go buy a cradle for it, because the fine for getting caught using your iPhone in the car without one is heinously expensive: AU$234! Even TomTom's iPhone cradle doesn't cost that much.
So far the new rule is only confirmed to be rolling out in Victoria, and not until November 9. But don't be surprised if other states and territories follow suit afterward.
New Zealand has a similar cellphone ban coming on November 1, but the NZ proposal is less draconian than the Australian version: the fine is only NZ$80, and the language in the proposal focuses on use of mobile phones for talking and texting, without making any mention of GPS or other uses.
The Australian law seems a bit of an overreach, but I fully support New Zealand's upcoming ban on talking and texting while driving (especially texting – I can't fathom why anyone would think it's okay to text and drive at the same time). I can't speak for Australia's roads, but the roads in New Zealand definitely require one's full attention. The iPhone in particular requires a lot of visual focus in order to use it as a phone unless you have a handsfree setup, and that kind of distraction from the task of driving could potentially lead to a fatal crash on our narrow, winding roads.
Of course there's a question of just how enforceable these laws will be in either country. Unless you're holding the phone up to the side of your head or using it at night, it's unlikely that a passing police car is going to see that your eyes are focused on what's in your hand rather than what's on the road. That's where common sense has to step in: is that phone call from your boss important enough to risk flying off the road? Probably not.
Thanks to reader Brian Rayner for sending this one in.
Share
Categories
Live in Australia? Have an iPhone? Do you use the iPhone's built-in Maps app, Navigon, or TomTom [iTunes links] to navigate? If you...
Add a Comment
Original Nokia N900 48GB Smartphone & Apple iPhone 3GS - 32GB
The phone ( Apple iPhone 3GS 32GB & Nokia N900 ) is unlocked , brand new , sealed in the box , comes with complete accessories , comes with 1 Year international warranty from the manufacture and the phone will work with any network provider or sim card.
BUY 3 GET 1 FREE
Nokia N900 48GB Unlocked Smartphone ==============350$
Sales Package Contents
- Nokia N900
- Nokia Battery (BL-5J)
- Nokia High Efficiency Charger (AC-10U)
- Nokia Stereo Headset (WH-205)
- Video out cable (CA-75U)
- Cleaning cloth
Apple iPhone 3G S 32GB Unlocked ================300$
Sales Package Contents
Apple iPhone 3G S 32GB Unlocked
Apple Earphones with Remote and Mic
Dock Connector to USB Cable
USB Power Adapter
Documentation
SIM eject tool
Returns Policy
offers a 15 days cooling off period which applies to international orders & 57 days exchange policy only if the product is found faulty or with defects. The defective product will be exchanged for the same product if the steps below are followed:
1) All items must be returned in the Manufacturer's Original packaging.
2) Unopened in the original box also including product manuals & accessories and any related documents.
3) All products must be boxed & packed safely and securely for shipping.
4) It is of utmost importance that all returns must be shipped via traceable means.
5) Please note that the buyer is responsible for the cost of the return postage in any instance.
6) The buyer is responsible for ensuring we receive the item back prior to an exchange.
Availability: Ships in 2 - 3 Business Days
Condition: Brand New
Extended Warranty: 1 year complete international warranty
Phone Status: Unlocked
works with all GSM network world wide
Sales Manager : Ryan Bush
HotMail: phoneltd1@hotmail.com
Gmail: lucaslimited@gmail.com
MSN CHAT: phoneltd1@hotmail.com
So just a thought, if you had an iPhone, and switched it into Airplane Mode, effectively making the phone component inactive, does that then mean you can use it as a GPS machine? :^)
The other option I guess is an iPod Touch, with the Tom Tom app and cradle. There's no phone there either.
What's the difference?
I bought the Griffin WindowSeat and iTrip combination. Great combination for the Sygic Mobile Maps GPS app.
September 28 2009 at 8:04 PM Report abuse Permalink rate up rate down Replythe original article was published in one state bagging the government of another state, you need to understand our local politics.
Not a national government issue, parochial state governments here, with a need to raise local funds through extra 'road taxes'
several local court cases were thrown out where iphone users were accused of making phone calls while driving...their defense?..using the GPS (hand held!!)
which is legal under current laws
so.. make all uses illegal, unless securely in a cradle.
all fair enough...touch a phone while driving, pay the fine!!
I'm sorry, but your assumptions are incorrect. In fact Vicroads categorically state that using a mobile phone as a GPS will be illegal. They state it here:
http://www.roadrules.vicroads.vic.gov.au/14_faq_using_mobile_phones_and_visual_display_units.html
The actual legislation in fact carries a blanket ban on all mobile use for fully licensed drivers, apart from making or receiving calls when the driver is not touching or looking at the phone (ie a bluetooth device or wired headset with remote answering/dial buttons is ok). Learners or probationary drivers are not allowed to use a mobile phone at all. The phone should be in a commercial holder. The legislation does not allow an exception for GPS use of a mobile phone in a holder at all. Phones are covered by rule 300 and dedicated GPS devices by rule 299 and rule 300 excludes mobile phones from the permitted use in a holder for GPS functionality that is allowed for devices covered by rule 299.
Legislation here:
http://austlii.law.uts.edu.au/au/legis/vic/num_reg/rsrr2009n94o2009289.txt/cgi-bin/download.cgi/download/au/legis/vic/num_reg/rsrr2009n94o2009289.txt
Sorry, but what's wrong with socialism and caring for your fellow man? It is not some sort of boogeyman. Liberty is a nice idea but you have to consider that what people want to do is not always in societies best interests, not least because humans are inherently selfish. This is why we have laws and this is a perfectly sensible one, not least because I do not see how you can use a GPS device properly without it being mounted on your dashboard.
Personally, I have an absolute hatred of people who use cellular telephones in the car while driving. It's just an accident waiting to happen...
Sorry, but are you trying to defend bad journalism? Yes, this is indeed a "blog" but I see no reason why we should not expect quality material and are entitled to point out flaws in articles if it will aid the production of better articles in the future. I see no reason why we should expect, or be tolerant of, bad journalism on sites such as this.
September 23 2009 at 3:53 AM Report abuse Permalink rate up rate down ReplyThe new Victorian rule, and the equivalent in South Australia that has been in force for a year, prohibit any use of a mobile phone while driving, with one exception. The exception is making or receiving a phone call when the phone is in a cradle or when you can use the phone without touching it.
Use of a phone includes using any function of that phone, including looking at the phone.
Therefore having your mobile phone in a cradle will not allow you to use a GPS application on that phone while driving. You can't use an iPhone GPS app for driving in South Australia now or Victoria (from Nov 09).
Look who's talking... with the number of road-rage incidents in the USA...
Talking to someone whilst holding your cell-phone in one hand and attempting to drive with the other (elbow sticking out the window) doesn't make for safe driving.
We have already had incidents of coach (bus) and lorry (truck) drivers driving dangerously on motorways whilst using their cell-phones. One driver was so oblivious to other road users, he rammed a small vehicle which then got stuck under his cab and he drove for several miles without realising that there was a small car under him occupied by 3-4 fellow humans whose lives he had just ended due to extreme negligence.
In the wrong hands, a car is as lethal a weapon as a fully loaded gun.
As a driver of over thirty years and a cell-phone user of 15 years, I have always had a full hands-free car kit installed in my car. When upgrading or changing phones, I had to factor in the cost of the car kit.
I wasn't just thinking about other road users, but also the fact that I would also be risking my children's lives. Every road user, including cyclists and pedestrians have the right to not feel threatened or killed by other road users.
If you live in the UK:
visit eBay.co.uk and search for 120383713023 -- looks interesting, but uses cigar lighter socket for power, but shouldn't be difficult to wire it to an inline lighter socket, then to a fused, ignition controlled location in your fusebox. £17.99+free P&P.
NOTE: I have nothing to do with this seller -- I have this on my Watch List but am waiting to see how much the tomtom cradle will cost.
Hot Apps on TUAW
Deals of the Day
more deals- Refurb Apple MacBook Air Laptops: 12" 64GB SSD for $699 + free shipping
- JVC Motion Sensing Clock Radio with Dual iPod Docks for $55 + free shipping
- Apple iPhone Headset with Mic for $4 + $2 s&h
- miFrame Picture Frame Dock for iPad for $64 + $8 s&h
- Refurb Apple iPod nano 8GB MP3 Player for $99 + free shipping, 16GB for $119
- Hannspree Apple-Shaped 28" 1080p LCD HDTV for $270 + free shipping
Software Updates
more updates- EFI Firmware Update brings Lion Internet Recovery to 2010-model Macs
- OS X Lion 10.7.3 released with Safari 5.1.3, Wi-Fi bug fix
- Aperture updated to 3.2.2, addresses Photo Stream issue
- Apple updates Keynote to address Lion issues
- Google Search app gets new look on iPad
- Apple releases Apple TV Software Update 4.4.3



31 Comments