Dear Aunt TUAW: Does size matter (when it comes to iPads)?
Dear Aunt TUAW,I am planning on getting an iPad WiFi+3G when they become available, but I am still undecided on which (storage) size I should get. I currently have a 16GB iPhone 3GS which comfortably, for now, holds all my media needs. While I have a lot of music and photos and some video I don't feel the need to have it all on my phone at one time.
Looking at what I store on my iPhone I think an iPad 32GB would more than fit my needs -- but will my media files be larger on the iPad with the larger format of the device? I don't expect that my iTunes songs will take up anymore than they do on the iPhone, but will the format of pictures and video take up more storage space? With AT&T increasing the download size limit over 3G it got me wondering if 32GB on the iPad will be more like a 16GB iPhone.
At this point I would be deciding between the 32GB and 64GB. Just wondering if the $100 price difference would be better spent buying the 32GB and putting the $100 toward a year's worth of 3G connectivity?
Love, kissies & hugs,
Your nephew, RJ
Dearest RJ,
16GB data? Buy the 32GB model, unless you can easily swing the 64 GB one. Then go for that.
Auntie has a pretty firm policy on this kind of thing: always buy the most storage you can afford unless the storage on offer is insufficient, whether truly insufficient or plausibly insufficient. Here's how it works. Let's say you have about 30GB of data. There's a 32GB item for sale and a 64GB item for sale. Which should you buy? Auntie's advice is to always buy the 64GB item. There's plenty of room there for you to grow over time, and overbuying your storage ensures that your device will remain useful as your data demands grow.
Now let's say, we're in the same situation but with 16GB and 32GB units instead. Here's where Auntie goes mental.
In that scenario, my advice is to buy low, just getting the 16GB model. "OMG, Auntie," you're saying to yourself. "How can you give such poor advice? The 30 GB of data I currently use as of today will fit comfortably on that 32GB unit! What the...um...heck?"
Here's the reasoning behind that advice: Buying any iPhone/iPod/iPad unit with just 2GB to spare is asking to pay extra for not-enough-room misery. You're going to ebay-and-upgrade within six months anyway, right? So why not just save the money and wait until something decent actually comes out? That's why I stayed to 4GB and 8GB iPhones until my beloved 32GB 3GS finally debuted. The money I saved helped underwrite the equipment I actually wanted. Of course, I'm now thisclose from running out of room on my newish 64GB iPod touch. And my 3GS? Sadly, overburdened already. (Although, to be fair, it's had a really great year -- and I've loved the storage space that it added to my life.)
It's the same way with the iPad. Top of the line 64GB simply isn't going to cut it for me under any plausible near term usage scenarios. With movies and books and lots of other iPad-ready great digital resources that go way beyond normal iPhone use, my storage requirements are constantly moving upwards, not downwards. I'm buying the 16GB model until at least a 128GB (and, preferably a 256GB) model shows up.
Is this biting off my nose to spite my face? (And, by the way, that's physically harder than you might imagine unless you have a very flexible nose and jaw, but I digress.) No, it's keeping my eyes on what I really want instead of settling for not-quite-good-enough. Over time, prices drop. Storage increases. So long as I have an entry-level iPad to get started with, I'll be fine -- at least until my dreamPad finally debuts.
If you do have the spare cash on-hand and don't have to count pennies, well, buy the best unit available. With that kind of cash flow, you don't have to worry about asking Auntie T. questions about which unit offers the best value. But if you're like me, a tech addict on a tight budget and unwilling to compromise on quality, you may consider buying down instead of up until the right model comes along.
Love & hugs,
Auntie T.
Share
Source: http://tuaw.com/tag/aunt+tuaw
Dear Aunt TUAW, I am planning on getting an iPad WiFi+3G when they become available, but I am still undecided on which (storage) size I...
Add a Comment
And the entire question would be moot if featuresnazi Jobs had
allowed the inclusion of a built-in SDHC slot.
For me, the answer to "which iPad?" is "none of the above". I'm going to
wait until Apple gets its collective head out of Jobs' nether regions
and produces the device that folks really want.
Dear Auntie T,
Can I borrow 2 grand please.
The argument for the low end,
its cheaper,
you plan to get a better one when apple makes one like with a camera, and you then have a spare for an extra room. My original iPhone is merely an alarm clock at this point.
You are really not ever going to consume 16 gigs of media between possible sync charge cycles
In order of consideration...
I'm considering the 32 just because I could sync it without an issue using the same setup I use for my 32 gig iPhone 3gs.
I'm considering the 64 because iPad apps might be larger in nature.
I'm considering the 16 because it is cheap, and I might want to wait for an iPad with a Camera. Cheapest now as spare when Better Revision comes along.
I might go with the other choices if forced to by availability. I think many would have this decision tree complicated more if ALL varieties were available at once, if the 3g models were available on the same day.
I really don't see me ever using the 3g service from ATT, but I am such a hound for GPS apps I am considering the cellular iPad. It would be nice if the cheaper iPad could do GPS too. And I'm not especially keen popping 15 bucks for the mere privelege of using the GPS.
Apple is actually using the correct naming conventions. And I'm not sure what you're asking here... are you talking file size or storage size? Because EVERYONE who produces storage uses the base-10 standard for sizing. 64GB = 64,000,000,000 bytes
March 04 2010 at 12:31 PM Report abuse Permalink rate up rate down ReplyYour comment "biting off your nose to spite you face" is not only factually wrong but inappropriate. The correct verbiage is "cutting off your nose to spite your face."
The origin of this comes from when the Viking hordes led by Atilia the Hun were ransacking Europe. The Church told the Nuns if they were raped they would go to hell. If however they cut off their nose and were raped, God would forgive them and they would be allowed in heaven. Hence the phrase. Of course as one can surmise, no doubt the Vikings just flipped them over and went on about their business.
So unless you're a Nun fearing rape from an invading Viking horde, the comment is totally inappropriate.
I hadn't realized that the origin of a phrase had to forever remain the only possible usage of the phrase... good to know.
(Note to self - The Groovemaster says figures of speech are bad)
FUNNY FUNNY...thatâs great...I love to get the origin for some of the adages people use thruout the years...
thanks for that funny bone time
If you are a true apple fan, you must get a 3G 64gig top of the line ipd
March 04 2010 at 12:09 PM Report abuse Permalink rate up rate down ReplyIt's not the most important thing, but it's worth considering resale value. This site http://www.nextworth.com/ is one of many that buys used iPhones. If you look at, for example, 8 and 16 GB 3G iPhones, there's a $48 difference in price--compared to the $100 price difference at the time of purchase. Not a huge deal, but something to be aware of. People who buy used are often looking for "cheap" more than "good" or "big" and are unwilling to pay extra for space they don't want or need. Just like any other upgrade--you could spend $1,000 or $10,000 on rims for your car, but when you sell it you can't expect to recoup all that cost--whoever buys it just wants WHEELS, period, and doesn't care how fancy they are.
On a related note, if you're the kind of person who "gets on the treadmill"--you buy an Apple product, then sell it and upgrade when the product is revised--then going with smaller is better, both because of the resale value mentioned above, and because you're less likely to fill it in the short amount of time you own it. If you have 8 GB of data now you might fill 16 in a year and 32 the year after that, but if you're only going to have it for one year, go small. PLUS, the next ones will be bigger anyway. I bought a 4 GB iPhone (the smallest and cheapest available) shortly after it came out, sold it a year later and got an 8 GB 3G (the smallest and cheapest available), and then sold that another year later and got a 16 GB 3GS--again, the smallest and cheapest available. So I doubled my space each time without even trying and without spending any extra.
If the Zoomit SD Card Reader works with the iPad, I may end up with the 16 GB iPad and put movies and music on an SD card.
http://magicaltablet.com/2010/02/08/zoomit-lets-you-read-sd-cards-on-your-iphone-will-it-work-with-ipad/
I've only had an 8 GB SSD in my netbook and it's been fine - especially since most of my stuff is in the cloud.
Some of the custom book and magazine apps (Vook, Wired mag, etc.) may create a storage burden but I'll figure that out as I go. Hmmm. Maybe the 32 GB model is the way to go... ;)
So nobody except "ishcabittle" has pointed out that the device is really an appliance, not a storage device. To store all my music, pictures and videos even my MBPro doesn't have enough storage with the internal drive. Wouldn't you keep most of your storage on an external appliance that is meant for storage? Then you would only keep the most recent/relevant stuff on the iPad. Especially with respect to video. So to me there is little difference between 16 and 64 when 64 is still not enough.
Hot Apps on TUAW
Deals of the Day
more deals- Refurb Apple MacBook Air Laptops: 12" 64GB SSD for $699 + free shipping
- JVC Motion Sensing Clock Radio with Dual iPod Docks for $55 + free shipping
- Apple iPhone Headset with Mic for $4 + $2 s&h
- miFrame Picture Frame Dock for iPad for $64 + $8 s&h
- Refurb Apple iPod nano 8GB MP3 Player for $99 + free shipping, 16GB for $119
- Hannspree Apple-Shaped 28" 1080p LCD HDTV for $270 + free shipping
Software Updates
more updates- EFI Firmware Update brings Lion Internet Recovery to 2010-model Macs
- OS X Lion 10.7.3 released with Safari 5.1.3, Wi-Fi bug fix
- Aperture updated to 3.2.2, addresses Photo Stream issue
- Apple updates Keynote to address Lion issues
- Google Search app gets new look on iPad
- Apple releases Apple TV Software Update 4.4.3



26 Comments