Skip to Content

iPad Wishlist: Separate user accounts

We have a huge iPad problem in my household, and it looks like we are not alone. The problem is, we only have one. Just one iPad and a handful of rapacious gadget-loving geeks. While the iPad offers the same physical hardware for each user, we would all benefit from some system of user accounts, allowing us to segregate our own personal files from each other, just like we do on our desktop systems.

As our own Victor Agreda put it, "Separate user accounts was probably the first thing I thought of when I brought the iPad home." He, like other users, was hoping to make accounts to limit access to e-mail identities, certain applications, and private files.

Read on for more on why this would be a great idea... and why we may not see it anytime soon.



From a family point of view, adding user-account walls around these items would help parents control which applications their children can access. It also could create unique top score files, especially when said children come to you saying "I think I accidentally deleted the game save file you've been working on for the last month." Reducing the clutter in each person's home screens, presenting only those apps that each user prefers -- this would allow them to organize those apps on a user-by-user basis.

It's not just about parental control though. As Mike Rose wrote a few weeks ago, sharing your iPad with your spouse raises its own issues of comity and cooperation. With user accounts, you wouldn't have to make the hard decisions like "who is the primary user?" Each person could adjust their own application and system settings as desired. Couples wouldn't have to manage expectations about personal data and privacy so explicitly. And you wouldn't have to put up with all those Barry Manilow albums cluttering your perfect acid-washed rock library.

The jailbreak community has, as it often does, moved beyond Apple's current limits. iPhone developer "EvilPenguin" has been working on a way to introduce user accounts onto jailbroken iPhones. The technology remains preliminary; creating a serious account manager can be quite complex.

Many of Apple's iPhone innovations can find an early expression in the iPhone jailbreak world, which often pushes the iPhone OS into new and exciting directions. From voice memo recorders to book readers to iPhone location software, jailbreak technologies often find their way into official releases. Other jailbreak-originated innovations that have now made it into official iPhone OS firmware include copy and paste, spell checking, application folders, rotation inhibition, and multitasking, many of which were developed by Ryan Petrich of Boolean Magic.

Separate user account support remains in its infancy, even in the jailbreak world. The majority of iPad users, those who do not jailbreak, will have to keep waiting. Apple has not announced user account support for its upcoming 4.0 OS release. As Steve would probably say, "Just buy another iPad. Or a Mac. Not a big deal."

Thanks, chpwn, emock, AlJaMa, Optimo, DB42

Categories

iPad

We have a huge iPad problem in my household, and it looks like we are not alone. The problem is, we only have one. Just one iPad and a...
 

Add a Comment

*0 / 3000 Character Maximum

44 Comments

Filter by:
Brian

You are implying that Apple is somehow responsible for your desire, lack of funds needed to procure said desirable object or both. What type of response did you hope to illicit from that comment, if not a smarmy rebuke of your proposition?

Maybe you were trying to stoke the fires of proletariat revolution against Apple for daring to price an object of their labor beyond your reach? Surely, as I'm sure our Dear Leader would concur, Apple has made enough money at this point.

May 10 2010 at 11:08 AM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply
Dousley

Use separate iPads, not separate user accounts. Mobile devices are inherently personal and not shareable. What happens when you and a family member want to take the iPad to different locations at the same time? Shell out for the extra iPads.

May 09 2010 at 6:50 PM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply
Alex

I'm not really sure how Steve's reality distortion field has any effect on the price. Are you suggesting Apple just choose to make less money, or are you suggesting they put less effort into it (R&D) or lower the quality (cheaper, crappier screens)? Or do you think you're entitled to something just because you want it? I'm guessing the latter.

May 09 2010 at 12:46 PM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply
Thairick

To really understand why the iPad creates a new product category and how it could fit into one's life, one needs to have it around for a couple days. When it's there, you use it...and it's sweet!

If I could lock out my email, Evernote, and Safari bookmarks, I would have loaned my iPad out to co-workers and friends so they could "get it". I initially considered keeping my iPad clean of personal info for this purpose.

I agree user accounts would be a welcome addition...Not only to aid my freaky Apple iPad evangelism, but just because it makes sense.

If it's too late to include in OS 4, how about making the new folders lockable? That would help.

May 08 2010 at 1:23 PM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply
billclock

I have the reverse question. I have an iPad and a small investment in iPad apps. If I buy an iPad for my wife, can she sync with my computer and download those apps on to her new iPad as well?

May 08 2010 at 12:57 PM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply
jonathan ober

I have one iPad, bought for my wife early adopter style, and she has pretty much nixed the use of her old laptop (except for uploading 100s of images at a time to her facebook). I get to use it from time to time to play certain games (WeRule & Godfinger and others), browse the web (cause it's better on the iPad than on my iPhone and I dont miss flash), and a few other obscure tasks (like taking it to business meetings when an iPad will suffice).

The problem we are having now is that we are youth leaders in our church and from time to time we have students over to hang out, play games/videogames and just catch up. Students love the iPad and always want to play with it or use it to do home work, my wife is an English Ed major and the last two weeks she has been helping students write papers and study more and more. She sits with the iPad and types, checks facebook, browse the net and look up words as she is there to help them.

Now are problem is everyone wants to use the iPad, my MBP gets hot on the junk :) and is heavier and bulkier to take places or go outside, etc. We are planning on getting a second wifi iPad for me for work (yay tax deduction), but that doesnt solve the issue that we would love to have multiple accounts for emails, app scores, and other programs. I dont mind sharing, it's just I dont want info being erased accidentally or apps erased unknowingly or private info being read.

May 08 2010 at 11:51 AM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply
sherm

Don't be so cheap! The thing is called iPad. If Steve intends for it to be used by more than one person, he would have named it the wePad and not an iPad!!

May 08 2010 at 11:27 AM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply
DBinNYC

Holy crap people. Perhaps this should be at the top of the "do I really need an iPad" check list.

1: are than more than one person who are going to want to use this in my household

Keep piling on features and wants and perhaps you'll realize you're better off without it, or with an alternative device...

May 08 2010 at 8:44 AM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply
Rudy

im not sharing my ipad with ANYONE. i dont really see this necessary anywayd, its a personal device.

May 08 2010 at 3:48 AM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply
Bernard Ramsey

Buy another iPad. It's not a Macbook.

-Steve

May 07 2010 at 11:14 PM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply
1 reply to Bernard Ramsey's comment
pwb

> Buy another iPad. It's not a Macbook.

Sure. One for my wife, two for the kids plus one or two for guests. OK, order for the additional five is away, where should I send the bill ?

I'm not sure you've noticed, but we're talking about $2000 here, minimum, plus taxes. Maybe you have that kind of loose change lying around, but most people don't. And for all of those people a multiuser feature becomes quite crucial, since they don't have that easy way out.

In many families it isn't even about trust, just about not accidentally messing up another one's data (mails, todos, dates, high scores,...). As a temporary stopgap I'd propose for developers to add some multiuser feature in their apps. This already works fine with quite a few games on our iPhones and the kids. It won't help you with the built-in ones, though.

Just my 2 cents (my kind of loose change ;-) ).

May 08 2010 at 12:46 AM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply
Buy an ad here

Hot Apps on TUAW

Tweets

© 2012 AOL Inc. All Rights Reserved.