Skip to Content

Survey: Consumers are replacing other computers with iPad

So, now that both versions of the iPad are out and available, it's probably time to ask the question: does a device like this replace another computer, or is it an entirely new category? Back during the announcement, Jobs was adamant that it was definitely a netbook replacement ("Netbooks aren't better than anything," he said then), but could it even replace notebook computers? According to a new survey, 44% of iPad purchasers say they won't be buying a notebook because of the device. That's not the only computing category taking a hit, either. The same survey found that 41% said they didn't need an iPod touch because of the iPad, and 27% said they wouldn't even need a desktop computer.

Now, obviously a survey is a temporary screenshot of people who have just spent $500 on a computer. Just because people say they won't need a new computer in a few years doesn't mean that they won't. Likewise, netbook sales are supposedly dropping off already. After reaching a high last year, they crashed in January after the announcement and then again when the iPad released. The statistics student in us points out that cause doesn't necessarily imply effect, though (and sure enough, the iPad wasn't actually announced until 17 days after the NPD data citing the netbook drop in interest). This is early, early research, and the actual effect the iPad will have on other markets isn't clear yet.

As a trend, however, it certainly appears that the iPad will do its best to take a bite out of as many computing markets as it can (and possibly even some of Apple's own device markets). While anecdotal data tells us that the iPad is still mostly a "satellite" computer rather than a full-fledged workstation, this customer survey says that all sorts of users are ready to jump ship on their older technology.

[via MDN]

Categories

iPad

So, now that both versions of the iPad are out and available, it's probably time to ask the question: does a device like this replace...
 

Add a Comment

*0 / 3000 Character Maximum

40 Comments

Filter by:
Jesse

I think some of you may be missing the point. Multiple computer households. I have two macs, and an iPad. We have decided that now we only need one mac. The iPad is sufficient to eliminate the "extra" comptuer, while still having a macbook to sync with and perform full-computing tasks with.

May 10 2010 at 11:11 AM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply
Maggie

My iPad has replaced my netbook, not my PC.

May 10 2010 at 5:30 AM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply
Chris

With the exception of iWork for iPad, the iPad is largely a media consumption device. You won't find it a suitable replacement for an Apple laptop running OS X other than for the most superficial tasks. For instance, a programmer or web designer or even musician is not going to get enough out of it to get rid of their laptop. I really do hope that they build a 3G/4G modem into the next MacBook Pro and offer an excellent deal on mobile internet like they currently have for the iPad. That's what would be ideal for me.

May 09 2010 at 4:59 PM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply
woody

It looks to me like Apple has pretty much given on OSX on laptops and desktops in order to be a mobile consumer electronics company.
I guess this is admission that they lost the Windows/OSX war.

May 09 2010 at 12:29 PM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply
wosuh

Has anyone noticed that you can attach files to your emails? It never crossed my mind when I was using my iPhone. Of course you can send photos and things from an app, but I sure don't want to send three files in three separate emails to my client.

Ever since I got my iPad, I found myself looking at net books - sure the iPad is magical, but not very practical.

May 09 2010 at 10:57 AM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply
cmsb55

I can actually see myself doing something like this to an extent. The iPad is good for simple things, but I think I would only use it while away from home. I am simply too used to being able to multitask to be restricted to doing one thing at a time (as I type this, I have several tabs open on Firefox and I'm watching a Southpark on the other half of the monitor). It would be fine for simply taking notes, light browsing, and such when away from my laptop, though.

May 09 2010 at 8:11 AM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply
Eric

Until there are some really good "cloud" storage options (beyond MobileMe or DropBox) 64GB is not going to las long in a media rich environment. But for the day to day stuff I use a laptop for the iPad works just fine.

May 09 2010 at 7:06 AM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply
simguyanime

Within a week, I've stopped using my desktop. Once all my music and whatnot were synced , I just didn't need my desktop anymore. I'd rather do all the things I do with it in the living room than in my tiny office. The experience of interacting with my data on a device as truly elegant as this has almost completely dissolved the need for a desktop.

Sure, you need a computer to activate it, but in all reality, most people who are going to get an iPad already own a computer.

And given the choice between buying a laptop and an iPad, I would choose an iPad hands down. I've never owned just a laptop, it's always been a second device. And for the price, I'd rather my iPad because of the fact that a year from now I'm not going to be hassled by slowdown, my ipad will run just as fast day one as it will three years from now.

May 09 2010 at 12:25 AM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply
hardmanb

As Mikeheld said, the title was poorly worded.

My wife, daughter and I have five Macs in the house, some 7 years old and still working.

What it means is that while my wife still swears by her MacBook Pro (primarily due to her hooked-up extensive music system), my daughter and I will be using our iPads and forgoing our laptop model updates.

May 09 2010 at 12:07 AM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply
Average White Boy

I just replaced my Alienware Area 51 ALX desktop running Windows 7 Ultimate with a brand new 64 GB 3G iPad. What a difference in speed. The iPad feels much faster. The iPad is twice as useful as the A51 is. The iPad does so much more that no wonder it's amazing and magical. The iPad boots up in an instant and saves on electricity. Forget about lugging the A51 around because it must weigh 40 pounds or so.

Windows desktops will be a thing of the past thanks to Apple and Steve Jobs. I urge everyone to toss out their Windows desktops and buy an iPad because they are the future of computing. Dell could never sell a million Area 51 desktops in a month. The consumer has voted for the iPad with their wallets. Goodbye, Windows, hello iPad.

One slightly used Dell Alienware Area 51 ALX, fully equipped, priced to sell. First $500 takes it. Call (213) 957-2113

May 08 2010 at 11:44 PM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply
Buy an ad here

Hot Apps on TUAW

Tweets

© 2012 AOL Inc. All Rights Reserved.