First Look: Little Mermaid for iPad
Due to appear in App Store this Friday, Juraj Hlavac's "The Little Mermaid" does for Hans Christian Andersen what "Alice for iPad" did for Lewis Carroll. Namely, it transforms the book to a highly interactive, graphically-rich experience for reading.
Watching this trailer, I can't help but wish that there were a little more novelty in this app, or something that differentiated it from the "Alice" experience. There's only so much you can get from "let's shake the iPad" with flickable, tiltable animated elements before it's time to move on to more individualized expression.
The problem is that Alice, while delightful, is a bit of a one-trick pony and that Little Mermaid doesn't build away from that. If all interactive iPad novels devolve to the electronic equivalent of a shaken noisemaker, the genre will quickly saturate into meaninglessness.
In order to keep this genre of application-enhanced e-Books fresh, developers really need to step away from the easy answers of Chipmunk physics (that's the engine that drove Alice -- I'm not sure what solutions were used for the Little Mermaid) and bring artists and educators into the mix. Because what will drive the e-Book application genre is not going to be technology but vision.
Electronic books need more novelty to engage young readers and their parents than simple gosh-wow add-ons. Any application enhancement has to enrich the reading experience. Whether that means adding puzzles to master, language tools to teach, hyperlinks to explore, or embedded videos to watch, there must be a drive to both educate and entertain in those materials.
Little Mermaid looks like a solid and well-designed product, built with love and attention to detail. Unfortunately, we've already seen that product before.
Share
Categories
Due to appear in App Store this Friday, Juraj Hlavac's "The Little Mermaid" does for Hans Christian Andersen what "Alice for iPad" did...
Add a Comment
I think the iPad could be a great platform for the "choose your own adventure" genre of books. I remember reading these as a kid. I could see even utilizing the web to enrich these kinds of books with expanded story lines contributed by other readers and fans. It could become a whole new spin on the MUD/RPG paradigm.
June 22 2010 at 12:32 AM Report abuse Permalink rate up rate down Reply"In order to keep this genre of application-enhanced e-Books fresh, developers really need to step away from the easy answers of Chipmunk physics (that's the engine that drove Alice -- I'm not sure what solutions were used for the Little Mermaid) and bring artists and educators into the mix."
It would be neat if there was some sort of media oriented authoring toolchain that was artist and developer friendly that would allow you to mix animations and images. Maybe we could call it "Flatch" or something similar! It would be perfect for this sort of interactive media type-thing.
Note: I've never actually used Flash, but it seems perfectly suited for this sort of thing. Too bad everybody thinks such things are "crap" unless they are implemented nearly verbatim in native code.
I think it's cool that more "books" are exploring the interactive genre. Plus, the trailer seems to indicate that there will be more than moving and shaking - sound? touch?
Regardless, the app looks like it at least picks up where Alice left off and possibly goes further. I think that's a great thing - books that get kids excited about reading sound like a pretty darn good thing to me. Now I'm curious to check it out...
"Watching this trailer, I can't help but wish that there were a little more novelty in this app, or something that differentiated it from the "Alice" experience. There's only so much you can get from "let's shake the iPad" with flickable, tiltable animated elements before it's time to move on to more individualized expression."
It's a BOOK not a game.
You only assume that the audience this book is aimed to will not be happy to see the Little Mermaid in shakeable form. If that were true, flip book that unfold 3d scenes would not sell in Target anymore.
Ask a child whether they would want another book like Alice.
As an adult, I am not interested in any of these books, unless they produce Aladdin.
Also, they could ask the artist to drop the etched-like drawing style. How about Renaissance style, or anime style?
Deals of the Day
more deals- $15 Apple iTunes Gift Card for $8 for new Saveology customers
- Philips Fidelio Docking Speaker Station for iPhone / iPod for $38 + $6 s&h
- Retro 80's Case for iPhone for $11 + $2 s&h
- HHI 360 Dual-View Stand Case for new iPad w/ $2 credit for $12 + $3 s&h
- HHI ReElegant Smart Cover Companion Case for new iPad from $5 + $3 s&h
- Used Apple iPad 64GB WiFi + 3G for $240 + free shipping
5 Comments