Skip to Content

Google Wave development discontinued, Waveboard sinks

Shipwreck imageAfter much public and private debate over its actual utility, Google Wave, as you've probably already heard, is dead. Google posted a notice yesterday announcing that, due to a lack of public acceptance for the realtime collaboration platform, they are halting development. "We don't plan to continue developing Wave as a standalone product," states Google, "but we will maintain the site at least through the end of the year and extend the technology for use in other Google projects."

Very few people are surprised by this news, and Wave has been roundly criticized for being poorly executed. Many (including myself), however, are disappointed. One Mac developer, in particular, is saddened by this development.

Dirk Holtwick, author of a Wave client called Waveboard, got the news while on holiday this week. It goes without saying that a developer with commercial applications for Mac, iPhone and iPad which rely on Wave is disappointed by this announcement. Holwick shared with TUAW his own criticism of the "buggy first experience" that Wave provided most users, but also his admiration for technology that was "great, and ahead of its time." Read on for more.


The current incarnation of Waveboard is a wrapper around Google's web-based interface, with added features to make using Wave more familiar to Mac and iPhone users. Dirk tells us, though, that he had started the development of a native application for iPhone and iPad using the Google Wave API. He was given no hint by Google staff that development had been halted. "I [wish] they would give it a second chance," he says, "I have the feeling it would have a great future in the long term."

Personally, I had just begun to (finally) get people to start collaborating with me in Wave, but experienced the same immediate drop in excitement from friends and clients that seems to have been the common reaction. I believe it was a great idea, but I agree that the execution ended up requiring a good level of commitment on the part of users to make it work.

Google has assured users that, by the end of this year, all data collected in Wave will be made portable for "rescue." They've also hinted that many of the mish-mashed technologies found in Wave will appear in other Google applications, which we've already seen begin to happen in Google Docs. Other portions of the technology have been or will be open sourced.

My condolences to Dirk, and a melancholy "so long, it was good to know you" to Wave.



Categories

Software

After much public and private debate over its actual utility, Google Wave, as you've probably already heard, is dead. Google posted a...
 

Add a Comment

*0 / 3000 Character Maximum

12 Comments

Filter by:
mike

If you are looking to replace Wave, WizeHive is a great Enterprise level collaboration and project management tool. We have thousands of happy users, using WizeHive to collaborate on ideas, files, tasks, projects and customers. We've been used by TechCrunch and other major technologyr organizations. We are running a WaveGoodBye promotion where you can get WizeHive for free. We also have upgraded versions that allow you to run online contests and other business processes. Come check out our WizeHive Blog for details.

August 05 2010 at 10:12 PM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply
cjschris

[sadface]

August 05 2010 at 4:21 PM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply
TheCastro

I agree with a troll?

August 05 2010 at 3:59 PM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply
macserv

Good bye and good riddance to an ill-defined and unnecessary waste of Google's resources. Don't get comfortable, Buzz— you're next.

August 05 2010 at 3:55 PM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply
1 reply to macserv's comment
FightTheFuture

i'm a Google freak - i have Google stock, i live on gmail. but there's a ton of high profile services that i simply don't use, Google Voice being one of them - and now that you can't share Google Docs links to others who don't have gmail accounts, i had to stop using that and use drop box.

i wonder how many people put Google on a pedestal for their services, but never really use them.

August 05 2010 at 4:51 PM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply
Paul

Problem with wave was just a lack of any integration with existing apps and email. Can't expect everyone to work so hard to drag everyone else on board to use something. I tried, and I like the idea. Just that wanted it to integrate my emails and social networks. Then it would be perfect.

August 05 2010 at 3:47 PM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply
jonathan ober

better headline - Google Wave Goodbye :P

I used it for like ten minutes, didnt get it and havent used it...now to get that stupid Google Buzz gone too.

August 05 2010 at 3:27 PM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply
Jason

I completely agree that Wave is "ahead of it's time". It's definitely not a legacy technology, but we have no idea how far "ahead" it is.

If it's so far ahead, surely no company in their right mind would let it hobble forward until it's accepted?

Wave is a framework, and should be treated as one. On it's face alone, it's nearly worthless. As the backend to something else (Google Docs Collaboration is absolutely spectacular), it's a serious winner.

Google's failure to realize this amuses me. The STANDING OVATION it got at I/O 2009 is amusing too.
I'm not calling Developers stupid, because I already made my point.
Wave is not an app all it's own, it's a wonderful framework for collaboration, and bolsters established webapps (and apps in general) significantly.

I think Google presented one thing, and Developers saw another. The amount of work put into Wave itself was in the wrong direction. It should never have been an App all it's own.

August 05 2010 at 3:02 PM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply
1 reply to Jason's comment
ben

It's kinda like Basecamp (project management) on steroid but more in the direction of average consumer that no one is sure why it's created or how to use it.

and of course the biggest fail is it's horrible performance.

August 05 2010 at 3:08 PM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply
David Wertheimer

Wave was a really unique product, but I think there were two major faults with it:

1. Little integration into the email paradigm. In fact, Google fatal flaw was insisting that waves were a completely separate paradigm from emails. Yet their own Gmail already had many of the features they tried to brand as "revolutionary" (combining by thread, message board style layout, etc.). Compared to some other email clients, these might have been new; to heavy Gmail users, the comparative advantage simply wasn't there.

2. Lack of focus. The first thing people wanted to know about Wave was "what is it and what does it do?" It wasn't really email, nor IM, nor a shared document. It was a little bit of everything. But what could you use it for? Again, that's tough. Sure you could use it for collaboration on a paper, but the format wasn't exportable elsewhere...so Google Docs was already better to use than wave. You could use it to chat quickly with people, but that's what IMs were for. Again, the comparative advantage over other currently-existing technology wasn't there.

August 05 2010 at 3:00 PM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply
1 reply to David Wertheimer's comment
Quinn Taylor

The best use I found for it was asynchronously coordinating meetups among a bunch of people. For example, I and a group of friends at my company meeto for lunch on Fridays, but we work in a lot of different buildings, and email was cumbersome, even with a mailing list. Plus, Wave allows gadgets, so we'd add a poll people could vote on where they want to go. Much faster, and people jump on Wave only if they want to go, so we don't fill up people's inboxes. I'll miss that convenience...

I have to agree, though, Wave's performance has been pathetic (always pegged my browser), and it was riddled with ridiculous limitations, such as not being able to remove someone from a Wave once added. And it wouldn't work properly with Google Groups. Seriously?

August 05 2010 at 3:42 PM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply
Jason

Did you completely miss the discussion of the iOS app?

August 05 2010 at 2:58 PM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply
Buy an ad here

Hot Apps on TUAW

Tweets

© 2012 AOL Inc. All Rights Reserved.