Camera+ pulled from App Store for 'volume button as camera shutter' workaround
From the "It Was Only a Matter of Time Department" comes news that Camera+, the top-rated photography app from developer tap tap tap, has been pulled from the App Store, most likely for violating Apple's developer agreement. Apple previously rejected an update to the Camera+ app which would have allowed users to use one of the iPhone's volume buttons as a mechanical shutter button while using Camera+. This is a feature many iPhone photographers have wished for -- tapping the screen to take a picture is far less stable than pressing a physical button -- but Apple cited "user confusion" in rejecting the Camera+ update which included the feature.tap tap tap posted (and later deleted) instructions on Twitter that allowed users to enable the "volume button as shutter" functionality via a back door workaround. This is most likely what got Camera+ kicked off the App Store; other apps with "hidden features" or "easter eggs" like this have been banished from the App Store before, like a flashlight app that allowed users to stealthily enable internet tethering.
Apple's well within its rights to react in this manner when developers put "hidden" features in their apps. On the other side of the mobile pond, Android users are currently getting hit by a trojan posing as a media player app which then sends unauthorized SMS messages to premium-rate numbers. While Apple's "user confusion" excuse for not letting Camera+ use the volume buttons as a shutter doesn't necessarily fly (how often are you going to mess with the iPhone's volume while taking a picture?), tap tap tap's "workaround" was out of line, at least in principle -- if Apple's not going to let a flashlight app secretly enable internet tethering or allow apps with blatant malware on the App Store, then it shouldn't come as a surprise that "hidden" functionality, however innocuous, will get your app banished.
Hopefully this ban is only temporary until Camera+ gets updated without the "workaround" in place -- or, better still, Apple could recognize that many users have triple-digit IQs and stop citing "user confusion" as an excuse for denying useful functionality. Either way, I hope Camera+ comes back eventually.
Share
Categories
From the "It Was Only a Matter of Time Department" comes news that Camera+, the top-rated photography app from developer tap tap tap, has...
Add a Comment
Hey guys, I have a problem. I downloaded Camera+ the night before it was pulled from the App Store. But then yesterday, upon moving around apps into folders and what not, I accidentally deleted Camera+ off my iPhone. I also didn't get a chance to back it up yet either, so it's not on my computer. I tried searching of ways to get it back, no luck.
I was reading this thread and I see that many people have bought the Camera+ app from the App Store. I was wondering if anyone can send me the .ipa? My theory is if I paid for it, and someone sends me the actual app, I can install it on my computer, and activate it using my Apple ID.
So if anyone could just send me the actual app, it'd be greatly appreciated. Thanks guys!
Steve Jobs is an arrogant putz.
August 12 2010 at 6:07 PM Report abuse Permalink rate up rate down ReplyI enabled it. And I am sooooooo not confused. I'm happy. Listen up Apple, your users aren't as beligerantly stupid as your antenna engineers are.
August 12 2010 at 3:54 PM Report abuse Permalink rate up rate down ReplyI have had each of the last three iPhones (missed the first because I was under contract with Verizon and a crippled RAZR...still don't know why people want Verizon so bad when they weren't any better for me than AT&T has been), and the iPhone has replaced my need for a camera. When our family needs a "real" camera, my wife has a Canon DSLR. With all sincerity, for the majority of my camera needs, the iPhone works well, and the iPhone 4's camera is only better.
Camera+ is a great app in that it combines the functions of several different iPhone camera/picture apps into one location. I'm not a big fan of their pre-camera roll "lightbox," or the fact that you can't choose a service to upload your pictures to (they are highlighting their own service). So I would use Camera+, but most of the time I'd simply open Apple's own Camera app.
That was until Camera+'s latest update. Two features now make Camera+ better than the stock Apple camera app. First, Camera+ now allows you to adjust both focus and exposure in two spots...making for MUCH better pictures. Second, I didn't think the volume button feature was that big of a deal...then I tried it. Touching the iPhone 4 volume button makes taking a picture so much better. Tapping the screen never felt right. I understand Apple wanting minimal buttons on the outside of the device. Both of these features should be bought by Apple from Tap Tap Tap and implemented into the next iOS. By the way, I hope Tap Tap Tap received some money from Apple based on the eerie resemblance of iBooks to Classics...
Hmm... couldn't someone create a photo app that could listen to the audio input port via the headphone connector for a pre-defined "click" from an external dongle that's just a button mounted on a headphone plug that generates the sound through induction? I doubt Apple could prevent developers from merely listening to audio input...
August 12 2010 at 12:02 PM Report abuse Permalink rate up rate down ReplyI don't know of any apps, other than Apple's own, that provide functionality via an external button through the audio port (Pandora Radio might, but I'll never know since it doesn't work in New Zealand). Assuming Apple opened the API for audio port input to developers (and if they haven't already, they probably won't), they'd still be able to block apps on UI guidelines based on their somewhat lame "user confusion" reasoning.
August 12 2010 at 1:36 PM Report abuse Permalink rate up rate down ReplyDave - if you update your app, anything that is not present in there will be deleted in the code. No code to support it - no way for the functionality to work.
August 12 2010 at 11:38 AM Report abuse Permalink rate up rate down ReplyGot it. And I will not 'update' to the crippled version.
Yes. Your apps don't evolve and gain pieces of functionality. You are deleting and replacing an app each time you update.
August 12 2010 at 11:30 AM Report abuse Permalink rate up rate down ReplyWarning: this comment is in support of Apple's decision.
1. User confusion - I've used Sony-Ericsson and seen Nokia cameraphones with dedicated shutter buttons where the volume keys were used it zoom. Think about it and the +/- symbols make sense for that operation. The iPhone's missing that dedicated shutter button an that's what causes the confusion.
2. Defending the principle - This is like copyright where every offense needs to get the banhammer early on. Apple is showing that it's willing to treat everyone from individual developers to major App Store development houses with equal veracity, at least for now. Apple's marking their territory in a big way by making examples of deviants.
Camera+ should just have a Dev mode with some user-requested features available as an in-app purchase with plenty of warning.
Glad I downloaded it already. I really love being able to take a picture with the volume buttons.
August 12 2010 at 11:03 AM Report abuse Permalink rate up rate down ReplyHot Apps on TUAW
Deals of the Day
more deals- Verizon Leather Sleeve for Tablets for $4 + free shipping
- Wicked Jaw Breaker Noise-Isolating In-Ear Headphones for $6 + free shipping
- Refurb Apple MacBook Air Laptops: 12" 64GB SSD for $699 + free shipping
- JVC Motion Sensing Clock Radio with Dual iPod Docks for $55 + free shipping
- Apple iPhone Headset with Mic for $4 + $2 s&h
- Refurb Apple iPod nano 8GB MP3 Player for $99 + free shipping, 16GB for $119
Software Updates
more updates- EFI Firmware Update brings Lion Internet Recovery to 2010-model Macs
- OS X Lion 10.7.3 released with Safari 5.1.3, Wi-Fi bug fix
- Aperture updated to 3.2.2, addresses Photo Stream issue
- Apple updates Keynote to address Lion issues
- Google Search app gets new look on iPad
- Apple releases Apple TV Software Update 4.4.3



56 Comments