Japanese publishers censure Apple over App Store violations
A group of Japanese publishers are censuring Apple after copyrighted material was reportedly scanned and distributed through the iOS App Store. The group points to numerous App Store applications that are illegally re-publishing the works of well-known Japanese authors, including Haruki Murakami and Keigo Higashino.The Japanese group, which includes book, e-book, digital comic and magazine publishers, is requesting a meeting with Apple's Japan unit to discuss this problem with piracy. Heightening the tension is Apple's response to these copyright violations. The Cupertino company says it does not have the resources to scan every app submission for copyright violations. Its current policy is to remove the app when a copyright violation is reported. This apparently is not sufficient for the Japanese publishers who claim this is "a wholly unconvincing explanation."
This dispute is reminiscent of the ongoing legal between YouTube and Viacom over copyrighted material that appears on the popular video website. From the start, Viacom has pushed YouTube to improve its pre-approval screening process to detect and filter out copyrighted material before it is published.
As the iPad and the iPhone continue to gain in popularity, look for this App Store copyright problem to continue. Right now the Japanese publishers are willing to talk, but other publishers may not be so amicable in the future. Let's hope Apple can work out any kinks before it's forced to duke it out in court.
Share
Categories
A group of Japanese publishers are censuring Apple after copyrighted material was reportedly scanned and distributed through the iOS App...
Add a Comment
What do you expect? There hasn't been anything put into the Japanese iBook store so I'm sure people here are going to get their favorites by other means.
Hell I'd love to buy the Japanese versions of Murakami's books so I can improving my Japanese reading ability. If these publishers would get off their ass and start supplying the iBook store with something worth reading I'm sure their sales will go up.
Why on earth should Apple become suddenly responsible for watching for violations on a company's copyright? It is that company's job to watchdog the market for such violations.
Would these companies expect Borders, Barnes & Noble, and Amazon to scan every book submitted to them for sale to see if it contains copyrighted content? Of course not. They could not, and would not cooperate with such demands.
There's no reason that Apple should be responsible for checking app submissions for copyrighted content. Their policy of removing reported, copyright-offending applications is the correct one.
My reply would be exactly the same. Regardless of the OS, the only entity who should be responsible for protecting copyrighted content is the company who produced that content in the first place. It's their job to watchdog the various media outlets for violations, not Apple's, and not Google's.
Would you also be in support of shutting down more P2P file sharing services, because they frequently provide access to copyrighted content? Or would you place that blame with the people sharing the files?
Regarding your examples: Checking for pornography is different from scouring an app for copyrighted content. A quick look at an application submission will tell you if it's pornography-themed. Apple does have the resources to do that, and has explicitly assumed that responsibility.
Because by creating a closed echosystem that they control, they should also reap the downsides of it... they are responsible for everything on there.
Deals of the Day
more deals- Used Apple iPad 32GB Wi-Fi Tablet for $200 + free shipping
- Apple iPod nano Multi-Touch 8GB MP3 Player for $100 + $8 s&h
- Cases for New iPad at HandHeldItems: Extra 20% off, $2 credit, from $3 + $3 s&h
- $15 Apple iTunes Gift Card for $8 for new Saveology customers
- Retro 80's Case for iPhone for $11 + $2 s&h
- HHI 360 Dual-View Stand Case for new iPad w/ $2 credit for $12 + $3 s&h
4 Comments