Skip to Content

Analysis of iPad 2 display shows performance similar to iPhone 4

The iPhone 4's Retina Display rightly gets praise for its high pixel density. Since its release, many iPad owners have longed for Apple to bump up the display resolution from 1024 x 768 in order to provide a similar viewing experience on Apple's tablet. When viewing an iPad's display next to an iPhone 4's Retina Display, the iPad appears excessively pixelated, particularly in text-heavy apps like iBooks.

Pixel density aside, recent analysis by Dr. Raymond M. Soneira of DisplayMate Technologies shows that the iPad 2's display stacks up well against the iPhone 4 in most other measures. According to Dr. Soneira, "the display on the iPad 2 delivers almost identical performance to the impressive iPhone 4 Retina Display," for the values he measured. Dr. Soneira compares the iPhone 3GS, iPhone 4 and iPad 2, and he analyzes values such as brightness, contrast ratio, black levels, and viewing angles to give us an idea of how Apple's newest device stacks up. In most respects, the iPad 2's display does indeed perform similarly to the iPhone 4, and both devices have measurably superior display quality compared to the iPhone 3GS.

Although the iPad 2 display's 132 ppi doesn't compare favorably to the iPhone 4's 326 ppi, Dr. Soneira calls the pixel density on the Retina Display "overkill" anyway. He believes some of the iPad 2 display's shortcomings could be addressed in software; Dr. Soneira says "anti-aliasing on the iPad 2 is far from state-of-the-art and degrades the perceived sharpness of text and graphics." Indeed, comparing the anti-aliasing on an iPad display versus a notebook display with a similar pixel density shows the iPad suffers from greater pixelation.

Some iOS developers, such as Firemint and Chair Entertainment, have already taken advantage of the iPad 2's better graphical performance, and using techniques similar to the ones Dr. Soneira advocates, these developers have delivered superior-quality graphics in their apps even though the display resolution remains the same. With its limited RAM and less powerful A4 processor, it's possible the original iPad lacked the processing power necessary to support anti-aliasing similar to that accomplished on Mac displays, but the iPad 2 should be able to do so.

Perhaps improved anti-aliasing for the iPad 2 is something we should add to our wish list for iOS 5.

[via AppleInsider]



Categories

iPad

The iPhone 4's Retina Display rightly gets praise for its high pixel density. Since its release, many iPad owners have longed for Apple...
 

Add a Comment

*0 / 3000 Character Maximum Comment Moderation Enabled. Your comment will appear after it is cleared by an editor.

5 Comments

Filter by:
Dave.Minerath

Slightly off topic but since it was mentioned in the article...

The Retina display resolution is certainly not overkill...it's a gorgeous display, and the feature that kept me away from the iPad 2. Without it, I have no reason to upgrade from the original iPad.

March 16 2011 at 9:21 PM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply
1 reply to Dave.Minerath's comment
mabhatter

I think splitting the iPad to a different size display would have been a mistake. First, that's 2048 x 1536... That's more pixels than any other display the sell bar the ACD @ 25 x 19. Second, it's a bastard size, and while Apple could do it they'd lose commodity pricing... Not that they don't pay up front anyway.
Third, and most important, it would have made all the iPad 1 apps, and the universal apps, and the old iPhone apps look even more crappy. The fuzzy upsampling didn't work well and upset devs. iPad and iPhone/touch are close enough apps can share most assets. I dread when iPhone 3GS drops off this summer. My feeling is that Apple is already trying to stop selling 3GS because it's holding universal apps back.
Effectively in June Apple will have all their idevices on the A4/A5 platform and Devs jobs will get easier.

March 16 2011 at 10:16 PM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply
Jules Stoop

When advocating sub-pixel anti-aliasing for iOS-devices, nobody seems to realise the device can be rotated do either portrait or landscape positions. This markedly complicates things and - at least - makes for fonts looking completely different depending on orientation. Knowing Apple, that's not a solution they'd like.

I think waiting for a double density display actually is the more economical road to take.

Calling the iPhone 4's resolution overkill, is just a sign of poor eyesight.

March 16 2011 at 9:03 PM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply
woebot

They compared the iPad 2 to two iPhones, but not to the first iPad? I think everyone assumes they're the same, but Anandtech reported seeing multiple vendors and slight differences. They say the iPad 2 is a little brighter, with worse black levels, and has less contrast.

http://www.anandtech.com/show/4215/apple-ipad-2-benchmarked-dualcore-cortex-a9-powervr-sgx-543mp2/4

March 16 2011 at 7:57 PM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply
1 reply to woebot's comment
Mystic

@Singapura: I read that you think this blog is pro Apple, which is so completely off the mark. So I decided to look at your previous posts, and yup my suspicions were correct, you're just a dumb @#$@%@ anti-apple zealot fanboy.

Go post on a website whose products you like instead of wasting your life posting how much you hate something!

March 16 2011 at 10:05 PM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply
Buy an ad here

Tweets

© 2012 AOL Inc. All Rights Reserved.