You're the Pundit: Is in-app purchasing out of control?
When it comes to forecasting the next big thing, we turn to our secret weapon: the TUAW braintrust. We put the question to you and let you have your go at it. Today's topic is in-app purchasing, or IAP for short.
We've been having a house debate recently about the proper role of IAP in game marketing and development. Some companies have been treating their customers as cash cows using IAPs. We find that attitude unacceptable.
That said, many games (including Tiny Tower, Battle Nations and others) use IAPs responsibly and well. We feel IAP by itself isn't bad, but some companies (and let us be clear, those are actually the minority of companies) put in-app purchases over game play instead of the other way around.
Our group take is that IAP, economically speaking, rewards bad game design. Developers can make more money from games with a high initial fun factor followed by a long, dull grind that players already in the groove will then pay out to avoid.
If you're paying to avoid game play or to add cheats that put you at an advantage over other players, then in-app purchases are hiding bad game design. Similarly, if you're paying to "accessorize" your world ("collect all 12 fish"), we feel that IAP is taking advantage of customers.
When IAP works in games, it branches, extends, or expands gameplay rather than cheats it.
So is IAP out of control in App Store? Should Apple be cracking down on the more predatory uses of IAP?
You tell us. Place your vote in this poll and then join in the comments with your take on this.
|Leave things as-is and let the market decided what\'s valuable and not.||379 (25.0%)|
|Apple needs heavier review oversight, and should have some kind of consumer appeal process for predatory IAPs.||581 (38.3%)|
|Leave Apple out of this. Industry standards should establish what uses of IAP are appropriate and what are not.||163 (10.7%)|
|The problem isn\'t IAP. The problem is badly designed games.||349 (23.0%)|
|Something else. I\'ll tell you in the comments.||45 (3.0%)|
Subscribe to Newsletter
Software Updatesmore updates
- Spotify update adds equalizer, refreshed Artist page and more
- Fantastical 2.1 for iOS adds new snooze, search and notification features
- ExpanDrive 4, more services and faster sync
- Apple adds iTunes Extras to Apple TV
- Spotify updates with new iPhone controls in time for summer BBQs
- iTunes U update will bring course creation and student discussion to iPad app