Italian court denies initial iPhone 4S ban

Samsung has lost another battle in its ongoing patent war with Apple. Its request to have iPhone 4S sales banned in Italy has been denied by the Italian courts. This comes barely a month after France similarly denied Samsung's request for a sales injunction against the iPhone 4S.
Samsung had already tried and failed to block the iPhone 4S release in Italy back in October, so this latest smackdown from the Italian courts comes as little surprise. Thus far Samsung has had no success in its pursuit of sales injunctions against Apple's handset, while Apple scored a temporary victory in Australia by getting sales of the Galaxy Tab banned there for most of 2011.
The ongoing patent dispute between the two companies comes as a result of Apple's accusation that Samsung has blatantly copied the designs of several Apple products, including several models of iPhones and the iPad. The patent wars haven't deterred Samsung from, um, paying homage to Apple's designs, either; as Macgasm points out, the newly-released Samsung Galaxy Ace Plus is a carbon copy clone of the iPhone 3G's design.
[via GigaOm]
Share
Samsung has lost another battle in its ongoing patent war with Apple. Its request to have iPhone 4S sales banned in Italy has been...
Add a Comment
It's not a carbon copy of the iPhone 3G at all. It's the international Galaxy S II model (it's in the screenshot that you posted with this very article) with a curved back. Surely Apple doesn't hold patents on curved plastic backings?
I'm fully aware this is an Apple fan site, and so I expect a certain level of bias. But that last line is the kind of thing I'd expect from a Apple fanboy in the comments section of Engadget.
My thoughts exactly. I love every Apple product I own, but it's the bias and rabid elitism from the fanboys that sometimes make me embarrassed that I own as many Apple products that I do.
Since it is an Apple based blog, I do expect some bias, but sometimes, the levels expressed here are sickening. They bash everyone who does something similar to Apple, but praise Apple for taking other companies ideas and making them better, or that Apple needs to implement others ideas or mimic the over all process. You can't complain about copying and then proclaim that there needs to be copying.
I for one am all about copying and competition because as a consumer that forces everyone to improve. Healthy competition is a great thing for us all. I want to see WP7, Android and iOS all succeed. I will miss Symbian and don't really care about RIM now... but each OS will have features that makes them better than the other, and they will all have weaknesses.
It's not like Apple has never stolen others ideas. Apple is just as guilty as Samsung.
If you can't see how that's a sad, slavish knock off design then I can't help you. Take a look at one in person, it's frankly embarrassing to sell such a derivative handset design. Perhaps in Korea it's flattery to try to knock off your competitors' designs, but it comes off as desperate and creatively bankrupt to me. A respectable company develops its own designs and wants to stand out, so that when you look at it you either say "WOW what is that!?" or once you've seen it you go "There's that Samsung Galaxy XYZ." That is the way the iPhone 4 was. No one could mistake that for a Samsung phone or any other. These recent Samsung phones are designed to look like the iPhone 3G/3GS. For some reason. Surely even Samsung knows that phone has been outdated for years, so I don't know why they chose this design.
January 06 2012 at 5:52 PM Report abuse Permalink -1 rate up rate down ReplyI'm sure the makers of Konfabulator feel the same way. They were doing something awesome, but then Apple blatantly ripped them off when it introduced it's own widgets. Almost exact copy. iOS 5... or should we say Android implementation on iPhone.
Everyone copies... Apple is as guilty as anyone. Like it or not, Apple did not invent rounded corners, touch screens, multi-touch and so on. LG had a nice little touch screen phone out before Apple. Archos was doing some cool similar things before Apple, but the moment Apple does it, it's like everyone who did it first no longer matters, that Apple becomes the great innovator.
Remember what Steve said, good artists create, great artists steal.
It's funny how Apple cries about others copying them, but there currently is a front page article about how Apple needs to copy Amazon and Kindle.
January 06 2012 at 11:28 AM Report abuse Permalink +1 rate up rate down ReplyDeals of the Day
more deals- Acoustic Research Digital Photo Frame with iPod Dock for $50 + free shipping
- Apple iPhone 4 8GB for Verizon, AT&T, or Sprint for $50 + pickup at Best Buy
- Unlocked iPhone 4S 16GB for GSM (AT&T, T-Mobile) for $619 + free shipping
- Apple iMac Core i7 Quad 3.4GHz 27" w/ 24GB RAM, 2TB HDD for $2,677 + $29 s&h
- Used Apple Magic Mouse for $36 + $4 s&h
- Skullcandy Riot Earbud Headphones for $10 + free shipping
5 Comments