Filed under: Software, Universal Binary
iPhone / Android Developer
Bump Technologies, Inc. - Mountain View, CA (2 weeks ago)
See More Relevant Jobs ›Filed under: Software, Universal Binary
Bump Technologies, Inc. - Mountain View, CA (2 weeks ago)
See More Relevant Jobs ›Want to drag a file to another folder and copy it instead of moving it? Press the Option key when you drag that file and it'll be duplicated rather than moved entirely.
Programming Manager, AOL Tech
Editor
Editor
Editor
Editor
deals apple tuaw ipad macbook opinion hgg Movies AppStore podcast tablet IpodTouch talkcast rumors itunes ibooks video touchscreen games DailyDeal ATT holiday AppReview retail review mac tips app android app-store facebook GPS IphoneOs Apps jailbreak rumor accessories ipod steve-jobs software iphone release hardware SteveJobs MacbookPro sales apple-ipad AppleStore google legal

All contents copyright © 2003-2010, Weblogs, Inc. All rights reserved
The Unofficial Apple Weblog (TUAW) is a member of the Weblogs, Inc. Network. Privacy Policy, Terms of Service, Notify AOL
Reader Comments (Page 1 of 1)
Mark said 1:18PM on 9-05-2006
DO NOT USE THIS!
The source code is stolen. See discussion on Digg: http://digg.com/apple/New_torrent_client_for_OSX_Released_Bitrocket
Reply
Justin Mazzi said 1:20PM on 9-05-2006
Transmission is open source under the MIT license. He just needs to credit m0k.org where credit is due.
Reply
Justin Mazzi said 1:24PM on 9-05-2006
Here is the license. http://www.opensource.org/licenses/mit-license.php
Reply
Mark said 1:27PM on 9-05-2006
I understand the license... but the fact is that he hasn't given credit where credit is due.
By 'stolen' i don't mean physically or electronically taken what is not free, but i mean used without permission or credit.
As far as the developers' credibility... look at their name: Clone Software, Ltd. http://www.clonesoftware.net/
Their site is a blank wordpress blog with a fancy theme.
Reply
Scott McNulty said 1:29PM on 9-05-2006
It seems to me while they may be jerks for not crediting the orginals coders, they are following the license which doesn't require permission or credit.
Reply
Jonathan Entwistle said 8:06PM on 9-05-2006
@mark
you are correct DO NOT USE THIS. This is the sort of easy licensing that means that power never gets put back into the community. Cut and Run!
Reply
Mark said 1:30PM on 9-05-2006
Interesting...
When i first visited the site, there was no mention of libtorrent.
http://bitrocket.org/forum/index.php?showtopic=3
i found this forum post where the developer acknowledges the fact and states the he has added the information to the site (which is now there).
Ok. crisis averted.
Reply
Nate said 1:35PM on 9-05-2006
The author of this app has a history of these code-stealing shenanigans (read digg link above). Use this if you want, but be forewarned.
I won't touch this until he releases the source code. Call me paranoid, but I don't really trust an app developed by someone who blatantly steals code and violates licenses...
Reply
Mark said 1:39PM on 9-05-2006
...and names his company "Clone Software"
Reply
Nate said 1:39PM on 9-05-2006
http://transmission.m0k.org/cgi-bin/trac.cgi/browser/trunk/LICENSE
He may be using libtorrent, but I'll bet anyone he's using at least some Transmission code as well.
Reply
Will said 1:42PM on 9-05-2006
BitRocket and Transmission are both banned on user-only bittorrent websites anyway. Nobody's bothered to try and correct the announce interval issue.
Reply
Jolix said 2:23PM on 9-05-2006
BitRocket does not use one single line of transmission code. BitRocket is open source as of tonight, being hosted by google. Anyway, check out the code when it is up and all of the accusers can, well you know. ;)
Reply
Jolix said 11:30AM on 9-06-2006
Source code for BitRocket is available at bitrocket.org
Reply
Liam Parkinson said 3:47PM on 9-05-2006
who cares if he uses a open source to create the app, its a good app that works great for me
Reply
Nate said 5:40PM on 9-05-2006
You know something, Jolix... No one would have accused you of anything had you stated what code you were using to begin with.
Reply
Nate said 5:40PM on 9-05-2006
Just checked out Rev. 11. It does not build. You didn't include the Growl headers...
Reply
SW said 5:20AM on 9-06-2006
@Jonathan Entwistle
Utter rubbish. This is the kind of licensing that is truly free.
Reply
Michael said 2:43PM on 9-06-2006
Jolix,
Just wanted to get off the sidelines and lend my support. Opening up your code for inspection let alone brining it to OSSish is a grand gesture (and one that I am glad you made regardless). I just wanted to make sure you do know that you have supporters and to not be too discouraged by the attacks... they will go away.
Reply
x said 4:34PM on 9-18-2006
This is from the guy who "made" Xfactor and publicly humiliated a user of his software on the now defunct forums because he was being a jerk. That instantly made me stop using his horrible program and tell other people about him.
Reply