Skip to Content

The Reader's View: Best of your feedback, comments and opinions

Welcome to The Reader's View, a new weekly TUAW column that will feature insightful and well-written commentary by you -- our readers.

The comments are the one place where our readers can get on their virtual soapboxes and tell the world what they're thinking. Not all comments are created equal, however, and we want to recognize and celebrate the ones that rise above the rest by showing thought, knowledge, and constructive/considerate feedback. Enjoy this week's cream of the crop, and remember that you also have the opportunity to have your comments showcased here.

First, our giveaway of a limited edition set of Beatles MusicSkins required that readers leave a comment telling us who their favorite Beatle was. This, of course, brought up some fun memories and commentary from kathycorby: "Bet I'm one of the few who saw the Beatles in person, Milwaukee, 1963 (I think), first US tour. Of course, by the time I stood near the back of the auditorium screaming and weeping, I already knew it was Paul, Paul, just forever Paul....."
To the post about Celebrity Cruises adding an "Apple Store" to the new Celebrity Eclipse, quinton provided some nice input about other cruise lines that are using Macs: "Celebrity and Royal Caribbean have already been using Macs aboard their ships for years. Currently the first ship in the Solstice class (the Celebrity Solstice) has Mac Minis running a modified custom media center OS in every stateroom on the ship (Eclipse is Solstice class). Royal Caribbean has done the same. I have personally used the services and they work great. A bit like Front Row but even cooler. Over a hundred new release movies are free to watch on demand (like iTunes.) In addition, you can order room service, view your account, and track the ships location on a map. What I wonder is, is Apple working with Celebrity to integrate these systems and design the software, or is Celebrity doing this on their own. The former seems much more likely. The ships backbone for the equipment is run on Xserves as well."

Navigation app / service provider TeleNav told TUAW about how GPS and search services apparently helped a lot of guys on Valentine's Day. For TUAW reader Phil H., an iPhone really kept him out of trouble: "Oh my god did my iPhone save the day here. First it helped me find a show to go to, buy tickets on the go. Get the showtimes. Get me directions to the theater so I got there just as the show was starting. Find a parking garage which is impossible to do in downtown Philadelphia. Then I used it to get directions to get from the garage to the theater. Used it as a light to see the playbill :) Then found directions to the Hard Rock cafe which was like 5 blocks away. After [we were] done [with] dinner, used it to hail a cab so I didn't have to walk at midnight and get mugged. Then used it to get directions on how to get out of the maze of downtown streets. Didn't really realize how much it helped until now. Thank god I have it!"

Auntie TUAW always helps out her nephews and nieces, and David F. was nice enough to respond to her post about buying a 3G iPad vs. the Wi-Fi model: "...I'm really glad I went the iPhone route because I was thinking about a touch. You would be surprised at just how handy 3G access is. Especially when it is in your pocket every minute of the day.

Now iPad is certainly a different animal that will result in profoundly different usage patterns. Frankly I suspect that is why Apple pushed for the no contract plans as pay as you go is likely to be a better arraingement for many. The common example being someone taking off on a trip and buying a months 3G coverage.

As a side note one place I see iPad winning big is with travelers, especially once the better GPS mapping apps hit. Vacationers are only the tip of the iceberg here, truck drivers and other on the road professionals will be quick adopters. Air crews would be in that list too. All of these people would need 3G access.

Apple certainly has a winner in iPad but I suspect it will win in ways that aren't expected by the general Mac Community."


We'll be back with another edition of The Reader's View next Saturday here on TUAW.

Original post photo credits: http://www.flickr.com/photos/sabine01/ / CC BY-NC 2.0

Welcome to The Reader's View, a new weekly TUAW column that will feature insightful and well-written commentary by you -- our readers....
 

Add a Comment

*0 / 3000 Character Maximum

10 Comments

Filter by:
Chris

TUAW did indeed do an article about this (it pertains to seven laptop manufacturers). I cannot find the article (too many pages ago), but basically it has a graph of seven laptop manufacturers with Asus as best, HP as worst, and Apple in or near the middle with Dell finishing just after Apple. I can say this is true, and that I am qualified to make the statement having owned several and used many other Apple and Dell products. Apple used to make a more reliable computer, but that ended with the PowerPC days. The prices have come down somewhat, but it is still very overpriced for all of their stuff being made in cheap Chinese factories. You could easily spend over $6k on an Apple computer (if maxing out your computer options), yet you can only get a 3 year warranty maximum on any product. Apple nickels and dimes customers more than even Dell would dare to do, however. It is pretty interesting that Apple is still selling $60 hard disks for $200 (and with only one of the three years of warranty you would normally get). You could pay just $5 extra for a better quality disk with five year warranty, but apparently Apple cannot make a product that is designed well enough to reasonably be expected to last for five years even if your life depended on it. I have heard of some exceptions to this rule for the older Macs, but maybe this was before Apple designed their products to be replaced.

BTW Undesired input != a troll comment. I can't help it if the truth offends readers. I'm mainly annoyed that there is no fully functional AND secure OS. It is a serious project to make a new OS, too. You would think, given all the effort required, they would aim to get it right.

February 21 2010 at 4:19 PM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply
1 reply to Chris's comment
eastmpman

Sounds to me like the world needs the secure & fully functional ChrisOS 1.0 :)

Lighten up man, you're way to amped up over this stuff. No one's requiring you to purchase any Apple products, you know?

February 22 2010 at 9:26 AM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply
Jason

My macbook has been more reliable for me than my Dell machine, but I'm afraid Microsoft is fighting back. Windows 7 is almost as good to work with. I'm not sure it is as secure. But I'm more concerned with the potential downfall of the iphone.
I'm afraid the iphone is about to lose its coolest thing in the world status. The Android and Windows 7 phones actually work cooler. Apple isn't the only phone with cool apps anymore. The Google phones seem to allow much of a smarter flow of experience with widgets and drop down menus.
I'm sure a new iphone is coming soon, but I hope that Apple takes into account the fact that new and slightly better phones are coming out every other month.
They need to match the operating system advantages of the Android system. Android's handling of updates is pretty handy. Blackberry and Google phones come with turn by turn directions. Why not the iphone? Why no flash? A camera button would be nice. Since, they sell millions of iphones, why not offer a version with a slide out qwerty. It would be nice to be able to open at three or four apps since there are other phones that allow many more.
There is actually lots more that they could do fairly easily if they wanted to offer higher end versions that do more than offer more storage. I would like to see something like infrared or RFID so it can be used as a credit card, remote, and key, but with all that power it may need a thumbprint scanner too though.

February 21 2010 at 11:32 AM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply
po11ock

As the "other Apple" products, the Beatles' core work still works despite the fact that Apple Corps is now half corpses. Fave fab flav: the quiet one - George. Send skins.

February 21 2010 at 11:23 AM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply
Steve

I have to agree with Robert. I have been running a Mac Lab at my high school since 1992. I currently have 42 machines in my classroom and over the past 18 years I have purchased at least that many over again. Out of 80 plus machines I have had two machines that I have had to take in for repairs and both were under warranty. As I buy new machines I pass my older ones down to the history lab where many are still in use. The only reason we retire our Macs is because times and software pass them by. The history teacher still uses some G3 all-in-ones that I purchased in 1998 because they capture vhs tapes of which he has a large library.

February 21 2010 at 9:40 AM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply
Chris

Are Apple products really worth what they cost? Yes, just think of the article TUAW did confirming my suspicion that Apple is only marginally more reliable than Dell (which isn't worth shit).

February 21 2010 at 1:18 AM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply
4 replies to Chris's comment
Buy an ad here

Hot Apps on TUAW

Tweets

© 2012 AOL Inc. All Rights Reserved.