If I couldn't use a Mac
Joshua Piven's The Worst-Case Scenario Survival Handbook sits on my desk. The book provides instructions on how to deal with certain scenarios, say wrestling yourself free from an alligator or landing an airplane. What it doesn't provide, however, is a guide for going without your Mac and using a Windows-based PC, which is a worst-case scenario for many TUAW readers. What if I was forced to use a PC notebook? What would I use?
There are certain scenarios in which you have no recourse but to use a PC notebook, so let's run through a couple of them. The first, and most obvious, is if it's standard equipment at your job. Even here, though, there are some variations. Companies with tight computing policies will give you little or no options for hardware and software; they pick out your notebook for you, and you can't install anything because you don't have admin rights.
Other companies, however, will allow you some choice on the hardware but maintain a tight reign on software. Though the converse can also occur, it is less common.
Another scenario, also out of the control of many, is if your parents will buy you a notebook, but they place restrictions -- ahem, "Here's $500 so that you can you get yourself a laptop." You're given a set budget that, even with the extra birthday cash grandma gave you, won't even come close to getting you a MacBook.
Although I've always owned both a PC and a Mac, my first PC notebook was an IBM ThinkPad 500 (now made by Lenovo). Each subsequent PC notebook purchase would also be a ThinkPad: a T20, T30, and company issued T43 and Z60. And if I had to buy a PC notebook, it would be an IBM/Lenovo ThinkPad (most likely one from their T Series). For me, it all boils down to the keyboard. ThinkPads are equipped with full-size keyboards, and their feel and "springiness" are unparalleled, in my opinion.
However, I'm the only TUAW'er in the ThinkPad crowd. For Aron Trimble, Erica Sadun and Mike Rose, "hackintosh-ability" is important. That's why, in addition to her Macs, Erica Sadun owns three Dell Minis; the Dell Mini is a popular notebook in the OSx86 community. Aron Trimble followed in Erica's footsteps by purchasing a Dell Mini last fall. However, if he had to choose a machine that was strictly for Windows use, Aron would pick a Sony Vaio. Aron says that, in his opinion, "they have some of the highest quality and best designed hardware."
Similarly, Chris Rawson half-seriously considered buying a 17" Vaio in early 2008, back when "Apple was taking too damn long to update the MacBook Pro." However, the Vaio's 1.5 hour battery life, and the fact that it came with Windows Vista, turned him off to the idea altogether. "I'd rather have no computer at all than deal with that hot mess," says Chris.
Steve Sande, like many, would prefer to virtualize Windows on a Mac rather than own a Windows-based PC. "If I had to get a PC, I'd still get a MacBook Pro and then install VMWare/Windows 7 on it," says Steve. Why? "Because I could still run Mac OS X on it when I needed to."
But do we even need notebook computers anymore? While notebooks have their place in the personal computing usage continuum, the role has become less diverse than before. Since Aron Trimble purchased his iPad, his MacBook Pro never leaves the desk, where it's hooked up to a 23" Apple Cinema Display. "I feel bad for it," says Aron. Likewise, Steve Sande sold his MacBook Air shortly after he purchased his iPad because "it wasn't being used at all."
Share
Source: http://apple.com/mac
Categories
Joshua Piven's The Worst-Case Scenario Survival Handbook sits on my desk. The book provides instructions on how to deal with certain...
Add a Comment
A very interesting blog unveiling many de merits in a PC based unit among them Bloking of admin right is one of them but it happens only in organizations as to avoid the time wastage and downloading of any other malicious software that may harm the computer.
If I had to use a PC, I'd probably end up getting a ThinkPad or something, and would make it a Linux machine. I despise Windows, and refuse to use it as my primary operating system. I actually *was* in a situation earlier this year when I was stuck with a PC (an Acer *sigh*) and I ended up dual-booting it between Win7 and Ubuntu until I sold it.
July 19 2010 at 1:27 AM Report abuse Permalink rate up rate down ReplyFor me, the software makes the hardware shine. No OSX would be a disaster area. If I had to choose, Ubuntu is a nice runner-up.
June 30 2010 at 2:12 PM Report abuse Permalink rate up rate down ReplyWell, if I couldn't use a mac, I'd go back to reading the newspaper, watching TV and doing my bookkeeping with a pen and paper.
My few attempts at using windoze has made me cranky and frustrated with the antiquated system. About the same as using an Amiga! No crap.
I can't understand the logic.
I am an Apple tech giving support in a town of 25000. I am the only support system and cannot give up my day job as a builder.
There are 3 other businesses employing up to 5 techs each that service PCs.
Go figure which is the best system!
I have no choice at work ... gotta use the evil empire.
Before I switched, I was an annoying Windoze apologist, but wanted to get a laptop while I could still get one with XP -- even then I knew that Vista was a POS. Couldn't find one (using store display models) that felt comfortable.
My first Mac was (and is still going strong) a MacBook, 13" ... when I tried it at the (Soho) Apple store, I knew this was a laptop even my fairly-large, mildly-stiff hands could deal with. Only reason I don't use it all the time anymore, is that I replaced my Dell (6 years old at the time) with an iMac 20", and haven't looked back! Went from Leopard to Snow Leopard (thankful for the family pack) without a hitch - even though I did do a thorough backup and cloned both before upgrading.
I bought a Mac Pro for work because it was either stick with the company issued POS Sony desktop that needed replacing badly or front the money and get something that worked. And since I was the one fronting the cash I got what I wanted. They paid me back and paid for the upgrades. I like it. I just run Parallels 5 and Windows 7 as well as other OSes.
Now I am the IT Manager and people that want(ed) Macs are getting them if I get my budget approved, which is likely.
I cannot use a Mac laptop because some b*st*rd stole mine, and I can't afford a replacement. Instead I'm making do with a used HPad. The real name of it is the HP TC1100, but it's HP's more conservative answer (a few years ago, since discontinued) to the iPad. It's a 10" slate about twice as thick/heavy as the iPad. Like the iPad It has a keyboard/stand which makes it usable like a laptop, but its primary mode of use is as a slate. It uses a pressure-reactive stylus instead of finger touch, which for my purposes is actually better, because I can use it for drawing (not just finger painting). I'm stuck running WinXPtablet on it, but since nearly all of the apps I'd want to use on it (Safari, Photoshop, Manga Studio, OpenOffice) have Windows versions, that's OK... I don't actually interact with the OS much.
June 29 2010 at 3:16 PM Report abuse Permalink rate up rate down ReplySorry, but anyone who thinks the Sony Vaio line represents any sort of quality needs to have a reality check. They are among the worst...
For $500 I would buy a used macbook, powerbook or other mac if possible. Or a think pad (have one that is rarely used), or a panasonic toughbook.
Dell? never... complete crapola.
I agree with everything except number 3. Using OS X and Windows are vastly different experiences.
If you're just emailing and web surfing, the difference is small, but if you're working with photos, video, audio, etc. The difference is night and day.
In fact, even word processing and office functions are easier on my Mac, as I can use things like Quicksilver and TextExpander to streamline operations.
When it comes to high end audio and video editing, though, there is no comparison with a Windows machine.
And none of this is taking into account the potential virus and spyware headaches you don't even have to worry about.
I'd buy a 14" HP ENVY and do a clean install of Windows 7
June 29 2010 at 1:16 PM Report abuse Permalink rate up rate down ReplyHot Apps on TUAW
Deals of the Day
more deals- Altec Lansing Octiv Duo iDock for $48 + free shipping
- Used Apple iMac 17" Core Duo 1.83GHz for $430 + $28 s&h
- Lounge Deluxe Stand for iPhone / iPod touch for $28 + $8 s&h
- Brookstone Surround-Sound Earbuds for $14 + $7 s&h
- Refurbished Skullcandy Tokidoki Smokin' Buds Mic'd Headset for $5 + $2 s&h
- Stitchway Backup Battery for iPod / iPhone for $5 + free shipping
Software Updates
more updates- EFI Firmware Update brings Lion Internet Recovery to 2010-model Macs
- OS X Lion 10.7.3 released with Safari 5.1.3, Wi-Fi bug fix
- Aperture updated to 3.2.2, addresses Photo Stream issue
- Apple updates Keynote to address Lion issues
- Google Search app gets new look on iPad
- Apple releases Apple TV Software Update 4.4.3



36 Comments