Skip to Content

Snow Leopard reviews roundup

With only a few hours more to wait until the packages start arriving and the stores start selling Snow Leopard, the reviews are beginning to pour in. To summarize: it's faster, it's (mostly) stable, yay new Finder, mostly yay new QuickTime (good thing you can still install the QuickTime 7 player), and in the words of our colleagues at Engadget: "Here's the thing about Snow Leopard, the single inescapable fact that hung over our heads as we ran our tests and took our screenshots and made our graphs: it's $30. $30!"

  • Uncle Walt Mossberg at AllThingsD: "Overall, I believe Snow Leopard will help keep the Mac an appealing choice for computer buyers, and I can recommend it to existing Mac owners seeking more speed and disk space, or wanting to more easily use Exchange. But I don't consider Snow Leopard a must-have upgrade for average consumers. It's more of a nice-to-have upgrade. If you're happy with Leopard, there's no reason to rush out and get Snow Leopard."
  • Gizmodo's Brian Lam: "Challenging 30 years of ever more bloated software tradition, the changes here are about becoming a more effective middleware between the media and the hardware, reducing friction while becoming more useful by, well, being lighter, less visible."
  • Macworld's Jason Snell: "Failing a massive makeover, then, we've got to take joy in the little gifts that Snow Leopard gives us. And there are a lot of them. I'd like to pick my favorite, but the fact is, they're all small enough that I can't really choose one. But if I could gather up the whole lot of them in my arms, I'd give them a hug."
  • Ed Baig at USA Today: "In my experience, Mac OS X was already a superior operating system to Windows. With Exchange and other technologies, Snow Leopard adds bite, especially for business. But as upgrades go, this one is relatively tame."
  • Wired's Brian X. Chen: "This upgrade won't deliver any radical interface changes to blow you away (not that we would want it to), but the price is more than fair for the number of performance improvements Snow Leopard delivers."
  • Jason Parker at CNET: "Overall, we think that Snow Leopard did almost everything Apple says it set out to do: it refined and enhanced Leopard to make it easier to use. Though the system performs well in everyday use, many of our tests indicate it is slightly slower than the older version of Leopard in more intensive application processes. Still, we highly recommend upgrading for all the new features and Microsoft Exchange support."
  • David Pogue in the NYT: "[I]f you're already running Leopard, paying the $30 for Snow Leopard is a no-brainer. You'll feel the leap forward in speed polish, and you'll keep experiencing those "oh, that's nice" moments for weeks to come. If you're running something earlier, the decision isn't as clear cut; you'll have to pay $170 and get Snow Leopard with Apple's creative-software suites -- whether you want them or not. Either way, the big story here isn't really Snow Leopard. It's the radical concept of a software update that's smaller, faster and better -- instead of bigger, slower and more bloated. May the rest of the industry take the hint."
  • ...and the aforementioned Engadget review, with lots of delightful videos (captured with QuickTime X's new screencasting feature).

If you've got Snow Leopard questions, we've got answers. Throw a comment in this post, send us a tweet over at the Ask TUAW account, or visit over on the Facebook page. We're also hoping to put together a late-night Friday liveblog to take live feedback from upgraders, and then we'll be live again Sunday night for the talkcast where it will be all Snow Leopard, all the time.



Categories

Reviews Snow Leopard

With only a few hours more to wait until the packages start arriving and the stores start selling Snow Leopard, the reviews are beginning...
 

Add a Comment

*0 / 3000 Character Maximum

36 Comments

Filter by:
Caspian

Where's the suppose-to-be Marble Interface we talking about b4?
Just curious...

August 30 2009 at 6:15 AM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply
Gregory Cornelius

Not happy today. Snow Leopard is stuck somewhere between New Jersey and Ohio. It's 7PM EST Friday and I was supposed to have received from Apple via FedEx overnight by 3PM to my office. Of course now the office and mailroom are closed until Monday. Last FedEx web update was a shipment departure from Newark, NJ at 10:30AM. Looks like a depressing weekend while everyone else installs Leopard. :( Does anyone know if Apple does anything in situation like this?

August 28 2009 at 7:04 PM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply
Eug

can someone please clarify the install process? is it an absolute upgrade (where it just overwrites the system files, but keeps user libraries - itunes, iphoto, documents, etc) intact? or does it over-write everything? is there an option to do a fresh install (in which case, what files do i need to backup other than favorites, music, pics, and documents?). what is this migration assistant?

thanks!!!

August 28 2009 at 11:10 AM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply
1 reply to Eug's comment
Michael Rose

Hey Eug,

The default install is an upgrade: all your apps, files and settings remain in place. This is what I would recommend.

A 'clean install' is possible by booting from the Snow Leopard DVD and then erasing your hard drive pre-installation. Not necessary unless you have a special requirement to do so.

Migration Assistant is a utility included with every Mac to move settings from one machine or system to another. Usually helpful when buying a new Mac.

August 29 2009 at 1:09 AM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply
Hawkman

We all know there's only one review that's really going to be worth reading. I trust Mr. Siracusa is putting the finishing touches to it right now!

August 27 2009 at 2:59 PM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply
Ken

Sorry, I meant the reordering in the sidebar. Apple's site says, "The sidebar in Mail is now reorderable, so you can arrange your mailboxes exactly the way you want them."

August 27 2009 at 2:15 PM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply
Ken

With Apple Mail, how is the reordering ability different than in 10.5's Mail? And is the IMAP syncing with gmail fix in 10.6's Mail? As of 10.5.6, if you read or delete an email on say the iPhone, its status in Mail will not change until you quit and reopen Mail. Thanks!

August 27 2009 at 2:13 PM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply
Rafael Sarrô

What performance gains/looses can be obtained by installing Snow Leopard on a first generation Macbook (Core Duo, 32bit)?

August 27 2009 at 2:02 PM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply
roonster09

what's up with apple's obsession with naming their os's after endangered jungle cats? i found a funny post on the subject here: http://onthebutton.wordpress.com/2009/08/26/apple-snow-leopard/

August 27 2009 at 1:56 PM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply
waiownsyou

Will installing Rosetta on Snow Leopard affect its performance? Supposedly, Microsoft Office 2008 is partly Universal and partly PPC code, and Rosetta would come in handy as I use my MBP for college. I don't mind if it takes extra hard drive space as I have plenty, but if it's a drag on performance, I may have to find an alternative.

August 27 2009 at 1:25 PM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply
philafication

Did they fix some iCal features? For instance the I-need-to-make-a-gazillion-clicks-to-change-the-details-of-an-event?
Thanks
philafication

August 27 2009 at 1:05 PM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply
1 reply to philafication's comment
Gene

The floating "inspector" is back in iCal. ::whew::
It's a bit annoying, the way Apple takes away features, sits on them for years, then brings them back touting them as "new."

August 27 2009 at 1:21 PM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply
Buy an ad here

Hot Apps on TUAW

Tweets

© 2012 AOL Inc. All Rights Reserved.