Skip to Content

AppleCare Help Desk actually helpful!

emac dark screen

I just wanted to share a positive Apple experience with everyone, since all too often, all you hear about in public is the negative. There’s plenty of negative to go around, for sure, but when Apple does the right thing, I think it’s worth noting.

I’ve had a barely used 700MHz CD-RW eMac (with AppleCare) for a while now which was destined to be my 3yo niece’s first computer. Unfortunately, this eMac developed a well-publicized video issue within hours of coming out of the box. Apple dutifully sent someone to repair it since it was still under warranty and although I do this for a living, I prefer to let Apple service in-warranty machines instead of doing them myself without anyone to send the bill to. They replaced the display/analog assembly and it was fine for a few months. Then the eMac lost video completely. Apple again sent someone out to repair it.


This time they replaced the display/analog plus the logic board. It was again fine for another month or so. Then a new, but related problem started - a flashing strobe when waking from sleep and no other video appearing - and I called Apple again. Once again they scheduled a house call and sent out another display/analog replacement. That was last week. Today, the eMac’s display is dark again. It’s on, I can Timbuktu into it, the fan is blaring, but the display remains dark. Apple has already spent considerably more on parts and labor than this eMac is now worth and there is clearly something inherently wrong with this machine. I think it’s time to replace it instead of throwing more parts at it.

I expected to have to put up a fight when I called Apple again this evening, but instead I was quickly (if you don’t count the 15 minutes on hold in the queue) elevated to “Paco,” a product specialist who agreed that 3 strikes was enough.

Without much prompting on my part, he offered to replace the ailing Mac with a current low-end model eMac - a 1.2GHz with a Combo Drive. I certainly can’t argue with that. More importantly, he treated me with respect, listened to what I had to say, explained the whole exchange process thoroughly despite the fact that it was clear that I knew my way around these types of situations and he didn’t have that familiar condescending and hurried tone you usually get from a guy who has gotten stuck with you as his last call before quitting time.

The sick eMac will be on its way back to the mothership on Friday and a new shiny one will take it’s place in 10-14 days. Now I have to figure out how to explain to a 3 year old what a megahertz is so she can appreciate how much faster her new computer will be :) Will Elmo’s World be twice as wondrous for her now as it was before?

Anyone else have a pleasant Apple experience to share?



I just wanted to share a positive Apple experience with everyone, since all too often, all you hear about in public is the...
 

Add a Comment

*0 / 3000 Character Maximum

4 Comments

Filter by:
RP

My 3-gen iPod broke and had to be sent back (it turned on, but the internal hold switch was stuck, so I couldn't do anything). Since it was engraved, I expected the fixed (not replaced, and therefore taking aa longer time to have an iPod in my hands, according to the AppleCare warranty), to come in the quoted 2-4 weeks after shipping. I, however, got it back in a week. I was pretty amazed.

February 12 2005 at 9:32 PM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply
Jasmeet

My G3 iBook was one of the models that had poor quality of service. First time, it was the monitor cable getting stressed from thge opening and closing of the lid. 2nd time, the video f'ed up. They replaced the mobo, which was nice cause the headphone port was bropken (made from plastic, bad move) 3rd time, the hard drive was about to die. However, AppleCare was not gonna replace the drive unless I could let them listen to the weird sound it was producing (only happpened when it was on for a long long time, and doing something intensive like compiling, or rsync'ing). Finally it died, and they took it. It came back with a new drive and Jaguar (eek!) and the even put in an drive optical drive because the paperclip wasn't working on the previous optical drive. Too bad the new drive's texture clashed with the actual iBook's smooth texture. After that repair, for some strange reason... the iBook kept locking up on me. It coould be because I was unplugging something like my d-link BT adapter or power cable. Took it into an Apple store: Mac Genius: You're iBook has gone in for repair 3 times. Say the magic word, I'll replace with the current model Me: Lemon! The iBook is nice, but I wish the keyboard wasn't so loud (I'm having them look at it today) and I miss regular Airport which was better at picking up faint signals. Oh and having a tray optical drive allowed me to use mini CD's. Oh, and I wanted topay the difference to have BT installed, and apparently that's a factory thing, so too bad on that.

February 10 2005 at 6:41 PM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply
Neil

My month-and-a-bit iMac G5 wouldn't start up when I got back to Uni in the week between Christmas and New Year - not a good time for customer service, I assumed. Fortunately I still had my PowerBook G3 so I used Apple's online support chat thingie that they've introduced. This meant that I didn't ring up a phone bill to get the problem diagnosed, so when it turned out that I needed my entire midplane board replacing I should have been able to order it online. For some reason the "order spare parts" webthing didn't work so I did have to call it in - but when I did they successfully accessed my user account and the online chat diagnosis had been registered! So that went much quicker than it could have done. They gave me a "5-7 working days for delivery" quote, but it turned up less than 48 hours later! On New Years Eve! I swapped them over [http://neil.chrisfleming.org/personal/mt/archives/000172.html], checked everything still worked and my data was intact and sent the duff one back. One very happy customer (not so happy that it broke in the first place, but y'know).

February 10 2005 at 7:26 AM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply
Kevin Ballard

Heh, my computer's going back in to AppleCare for two reasons: 1) the right speaker is dead 2) The hard drive beeped when I installed Tiger on my second partition Yes, Apple is going to replace my hard drive because it beeped. That's service.

February 10 2005 at 12:52 AM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply
Buy an ad here

Hot Apps on TUAW

Tweets

© 2012 AOL Inc. All Rights Reserved.